A Somewhat Interesting Vanilla Game

You made me claim so that this could happen?
Smart fella

TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan said:

[Vote] Sparkin
That villager claim was out of nowhere and definitely suspicious

Click to expand...

it was not "out of nowhere". Read the post literally right above sparkin's claim...

Bidoof FTW said:

it was not "out of nowhere". Read the post literally right above sparkin's claim...

Click to expand...

Bard said "if you claim" so Sparkin decided to claim villager

TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan said:

Bard said "if you claim" so Sparkin decided to claim villager

Click to expand...

1) Johnny, not bard
2) Johnny is saying if sparkin claims a PR he might be willing to switch the vote, but honestly this was probably just a bait to see what Sparkin would say.

Bidoof FTW said:

1) Johnny, not bard
2) Johnny is saying if sparkin claims a PR he might be willing to switch the vote, but honestly this was probably just a bait to see what Sparkin would say.

Click to expand...

Yeah my mistake but that's true although it's not all that clear that he meant a PR role

I did say it looked like town v scum as well. Probably not explicit with that. There?s no point randovoting if someone has been scumread, no? I haven?t got any other reads unfortunately.

Time's up

I am going to assume that this boy found out who the traitor was so I think that means that the serial killer and the mafia aren't working together does anyone have any other thoughts on this theory

Edit: I meant spy not boy I'm using speech to text

Maf could still be working with the SK tbh. Don?t rule it out just because the traitor got killed. inb4 i now get framed rip

Abby said:

I am going to assume that this spy found out who the traitor was so I think that means that the serial killer and the mafia aren't working together does anyone have any other thoughts on this theory

Click to expand...

I dunno, it's a possibility but I don't think the sk would kill the traitor if they wanted to start taking out the mafia. The traitor doesn't count towards the mafia's majority win. I think I have a good reason why the sk killed Bard. Bard voted for me yesterday for a pretty petty reason, and despite my argument against it he still didn't stop voting for me now we know why, dirty traitor. The serial killer might be trying to frame me in that regard. ?\_(?)_/?

But what I'm more concerned about is the bandwagon on Sparkin that could have easily been avoided. I haven't played mafia in a while, but I remember Sparkin being known for acting scummy, even when he's been innocent. I know he did stupid things during the previous day that didn't help his case, and there were some players who pointed that out when they voted for him, so I'm getting town reads from them. But there were players who voted for him with next to no reason or had a reason that was pretty dumb

I have a slight scum read on Ida and Bidoof for hopping on the bandwagon with no real reasons of their own, which I understand to a point. It was Day 1, there was little to go on, but there were other players who seemed scummier than Sparkin at the time. I also have a read on Saws for the reason he gave for voting on Sparkin that made no sense. It's almost like he didn't read through the posts.

purplecicada said:

I don?t know about everyone else, but I?m townreading Johnny right now. There is nothing in his posts that scream suspicious to me right now. Sparks v Johnny currently seems like town v town, although it could be scum v scum/town. I?m kind of agreeing with Roger and Bard about Sophie, although that?s not necessarily a reason to vote her like that.

If I get scumread for this, fair enough lmao, but I think I?m gonna go for Sparks. I?m only townreading Johnny, but I don?t have anything else to go by. Sorry, Sparks.
[vote] Sparkin.

Click to expand...

>claims there's a chance it might be town/town
>contradicts self by saying she's only town reading Johnny
>proceeds to vote despite previously thinking there's a chance Sparkin is town
>???
>profit

I kinda want to vote on Nicki as she's currently the shadiest out of the lot with that contradiction, but I'm going to wait until Miah and/or Zenithios contributes because neither of them have said a word. I checked through the thread twice, so if they have I'm blind forgive me

Also, don't think I've forgotten about you, metroid. I still don't trust you after following Bard with that weak af vote ?_?

SirDolan said:

I have a slight scum read on Ida and Bidoof for hopping on the bandwagon with no real reasons of their own, which I understand to a point. It was Day 1, there was little to go on, but there were other players who seemed scummier than Sparkin at the time. I also have a read on Saws for the reason he gave for voting on Sparkin that made no sense. It's almost like he didn't read through the posts.

Click to expand...

Uh I'm pretty sure Bidoof is dead lol

Also I did read through all of the posts but I got kind of confused as to what was going on
Yes I realize that Sparkin often acts scummy even when innocent (just like me) but I really couldn't come up with anything better and I haven't really been able to get any reads so far tbh

I am a "somewhat interesting villager", I have nothing to hide

TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan said:

Uh I'm pretty sure Bidoof is dead lol

Click to expand...

Oh, so he is. i told you i'm blind

If you couldn't have come up with anything better, then maybe you should have held off on voting him :p

SirDolan said:

If you couldn't have come up with anything better, then maybe you should have held off on voting him :p

Click to expand...

Yeah I probably should have, thinking about it now but I was running out of time to get a vote in and that kinda contributed to my poorly thought out reasoning tbh

Not gonna lie, I'd like to see a little more from James, the points he raised in his d1 post are invalid now.



Anyone else find it concerning that met kinda dissapeared after getting scumread?

Abby said:

Not gonna lie, I'd like to see a little more from James, the points he raised in his d1 post are invalid now.



Anyone else find it concerning that met kinda dissapeared after getting scumread?

Click to expand...

Isn't James the celebrity, though? Or do you just want him to be posting in general?

Ye, I've noticed. :eyes:

I wanted to see where his head was at BECAUSE he was confirmed haha

Johnny said:

Despite all that, Nicki is still the scummiest person here, simply because of her contradictions (not because Sparkin acts scummy when he's innocent).

Click to expand...

Agreed. It's certainly hard to ignore that, she has however provided SOME defence, which is more than roger has haha

Speaking of that, what're your personal thoughts on roger? P sure he's my main scumread

EDIT: ... okay then. Guess I won't be receiving that answer