Arcanine or Ninetales?

[Knor]

Tough decision... Ninetales looks more elegant, but Arcanine is more powerful... I'm torn.

Arcanine is a Legendary Pokémon... Does that count?

 

[Granzen]

Sure Growlithe/Arcanine.
Because they are very strong pokémon in battle. ;)

 

[Kikaito plush]

I prefer Ninetales as I think Arcanine is over rated and over used by people.

 

[Queen]

Arcanine seems more tough and noble.

 

[pompayyy]

I'd have to go with Arcanine since I really liked that one episode in the anime with Growlithe and James, and I'm not a huge fan of Ninetales' design (even though I like foxes and fire types, I just like Fennekin's design more :))

 

[Ig Pokemon Lover]

Ninetales because to me it looks beautiful

 

[Decimosoma]

Arcanine all the way. It's my all time favorite and gets work done in pretty much every situation i'm put in.

 

[Fitzsy]

Arcanine, so cuddle-wuddle and it could like bite your arm off and that would be so d'aaaw!

 

[GreyVirgo]

Arcanine would be good to go with I like Ninetails but Arcanine has higher base stats and It's design is better than Ninetails. :15:

 

[Victreebel's Bro]

Tough one if you ask me. I like both of them, but I think I prefer Ninetales. I used them both in Heart Gold and just thought that Ninetales was more reliable. I still like Arcanine, but Ninetales wins my vote for this round

 

[antemortem]

I've always been a fan of Arcanine and I've never actually liked Ninetales. I didn't want a Vulpix when I had LeafGreen and I begged my friends for a Growlithe from their FireRed until I got one.

 

[xseed]

Ninetails.

1. I like foxes
2. Just look at her. look how majestic she looks
3. sunny day. perfect for fire boosts and also for sunny day teams
4. it learns moves like for example energy ball

I think the only thing that is dragging her down a bit is her(or his) lack luster stats.(Game"troll"Freak why in the world do you keep making all potential good pokemon have weak stats and or terrible moves.). I also wish she was fire/psychic. but oh well. Ninetails is still overall a great pokemon.

 

[TrinityLovesPokemon]

I personally like both, but I love Arcanine. He reminds me of my now dead dog </3 but when I see an Arcanine I think of Savage *my dog* So Arcanine?

 

[Guy]

Both competitively and in design, I feel like Arcanine comes out on top. Although I do like Ninetales and I'm using one in my current SoulSilver play-through, Arcanine has always been more of the standout to me.

 

[Batty]

Ninetales with Drought.
I like Ninetales design better anyhow.

 

[PlatinumDude]

Arcanine's majestic appearance certainly caught my eye. It was also neat that it had its own signature move in Gen II in the form of Extreme Speed before the move got better distribution.