• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • It's time to vote for your favorite Pokémon Battle Revolution protagonist in our new weekly protagonist poll! Click here to cast your vote and let us know which PBR protagonist you like most.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

B????????L??????????A???????R????????G??????H???????B?????????A???????H???A?????????R??????????????GA?H????????????J?????A?????A????A?

I don't even think someone can investigate Ida unless we had multiple cops. I don't feel inclined to vote for Ida as it appears Aaron is paired with them and we're going to kill an innocent (or two) if Aaron's telling the truth about being paired with them. I feel their behaviour is scummy (ie. "I haven't been paying attention"), however it is something we need to look into.

I partially agree with Bard's point on the Pumpkin thing. But that's not really a reason to vote for Kits, even though both her and Flotch brought attention to it. It's worth keeping an eye on her behaviour. However, it seems that all votes are randomly placed and if I place a vote on anyone, RNG might decide so I could either do that or stack a vote which would make me look scummy.

@Doof I don't think Johnny is scummy just for that one post.

[vote] Neko Maid Kapper as he could be either. He hasn't given information on who he has equipped guns/vests with, and no one else has confirmed whether or not they received anything.
 
Been inactive due to other responsibilities.

I think I'll follow Bard's logic. It seems a plausible connection and it's the lead I want to follow rn [Annihilate] Kitty
 
After doing a bit of reading here's my collective thoughts:

Charlie Brown forgot Sparkin was the sheriff and scumread them. This is very sloppy but could go both ways. I don't often see people making sloppy mistakes like this as mafia, but it's possible.

UncreativeSawsbuckFan edited his post to delete whatever it originally said. This is actually a big red flag for me, makes it seem like he accidentally leaked something he shouldn't have. However at the same time he's a new player and seems more scared of getting lynched in general. Doesn't really justify editing a post like that but it's something to consider.

Ida and Rabinov. They claim that they're partners and it just seems way too obvious that they might be scum together. Therefore I'm reading them as town all the way.

Purplecicada is getting on Neko, who claimed blacksmith on not revealing who all he visited. Well I read this really badly, the best thing for Neko to do is just reveal what he gave out each night as opposed to who. If he gives out a gun to someone and the mafia knows that they have that gun, they could target them and remove the gun from being used or fab a gun to that same person, rendering it useless. The fact that Purp wants Neko to reveal so much that could be used to the advantage of the mafia is going to make me swing my vote at her [Vote]Purplecicada

Gonna try and post a bit more when time permits it, been busy grinding in a game and work, which really only allowed me to read over the thread.
 
Pecilia said:
UncreativeSawsbuckFan edited his post to delete whatever it originally said. This is actually a big red flag for me, makes it seem like he accidentally leaked something he shouldn't have. However at the same time he's a new player and seems more scared of getting lynched in general. Doesn't really justify editing a post like that but it's something to consider.
Click to expand...

The one I deleted was a random vote, which I didn't know was against the rules
I deleted it and made a new, more thought out vote so I wouldn't get kicked from the game
 
Last edited:
TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan said:
The one I deleted was a random vote, which I didn't know was against the rules
I deleted it and made a new, more thought out vote so I wouldn't get kicked from the game
Click to expand...

You aren't getting killed for a post before the event started. Please don't delete posts in mafia games.
 
I only wanted him to reveal who he gave guns to so we could work out whether or not there was a fabricator to see if there were any fakes and if so who received them. I received a gun N0 for reference.
 
purplecicada said:
I only wanted him to reveal who he gave guns to so we could work out whether or not there was a fabricator to see if there were any fakes and if so who received them. I received a gun N0 for reference.
Click to expand...

I know that I received a gun, and I'm not sure who would trust a rookie that suffers from mental breakdowns with a gun other than a fabricator (or a crazy gunsmith)
 
Last edited:
I quite honestly haven't been visited at all during this game, nor have I used any actions (I don't want to waste mine). I've been keeping an eye on the thread at a whole but this is my first maf game in years and I'm very rusty (plus I was never very good to begin with) so I don't know what I'm really looking at, I guess in hindsight I shouldn't have joined such an involved game for my first game back but what-ho, we're here now.

In terms of votes, after having read back through the thread I agree with Pecilia's points on Purp; it is pretty suspicious that she's trying to get Neko to reveal names when it's strategically advantageous for town not to so [annhilate] PurpleCicada
 
So that's five guns being claimed by now?

Let's see if we can make an overview:
N0: Bardothren, purplecicada
N1:
N2: Bardothren
???: Johnny, TheUncreativeSawsbuckFan

Neko, which ones are yours?
 
Looks like no matter what I do or say is going to stop me from getting lynched now. I'm innocent, and I can partially prove Aaron's innocence as I used my NA on him and he accepted (although this doesn't always mean he is inno). My NA can only be successful if the person accepts it. Fletch rejected the action which made him scummy in my eyes, however I didn't reveal this because I would have died otherwise. The only person who can confirm this is Aaron, as Melody got killed, and she accepted my action N1. So, to clear things up:
N0: Fletch, rejected.
N1: Melody, accepted.
N2: Aaron, accepted.
 
Bardothren said:
Interesting. Which night did you give me a gun? If you're outing, you might as well say who got your other gun.
Click to expand...
N0 i gave Nicki a gun, i gave you a gun on N1 and last night i gave Johnny a gun
I'm the gunsmith c:

EDIT: [annihilate] Lycanthropy random vote, because I'm not sure who to vote and just in case i forget to vote later on
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I'm finding ScribblyGryphon a bit scum right now. His reasoning to lynch Nicki isn't really that valid like, you can't confirm someone that they're not innocent if you haven't been visited.

[annihilate] ScribblyGryphon

Also, I notified our lord and savior that I will unfortunately be inactive for the rest of the week. I'm also busy today, so excuse my lack of forethought in this post :x
 
Salzorrah said:
Honestly, I'm finding ScribblyGryphon a bit scum right now. His reasoning to lynch Nicki isn't really that valid like, you can't confirm someone that they're not innocent if you haven't been visited.
Click to expand...

Your point is fair and valid and I'm not surprised you find me scum but it was either that or randovote and die by event and I did at least read back through the thread for a better argument, given that I haven't actually been visited at all I don't have anything new to add to the table on anyone.
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm trying to be a pacifist for a being a third-party myself. Although, random vote on someone who was revealed as a visiting role makes you sound like you're not paying attention for the game at this point.

However, I will also not justify who's who and what's what either. If there's anything I'd do, I'll just try voting somebody else who I think needs attention.
[Annihilate] Kiyotaka Ishimaru
 
Pecilia said:
After doing a bit of reading here's my collective thoughts:

Charlie Brown forgot Sparkin was the sheriff and scumread them. This is very sloppy but could go both ways. I don't often see people making sloppy mistakes like this as mafia, but it's possible.
Click to expand...

Yeah it was v sloppy of me, no excuses. I'm confirmed loudmouth though, Lycan visited me on the most recent night (my character name is Lil B)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top