Curse of the Golden Hook - Epilogue

I had information on Netto Azure, who I found was a Cursed One. Cheshire Cat and Hopeless Masquerade were revealed as innos to me, though Hopeless Masquerade was forced to walk the plank by the time I got back so wouldn't have been able to change their fate. But then, when I went to visit JohnnyMustang, I was told he had an "evil feel about him", "like he was hiding something that could make a good guy bad" and vice versa.

Sorry for not being in the game too much, I haven't been able to time things too well and as this is my second game, I lack experience :/
 
The plot is so thick I can't see where I'm going.

So if we lynch spartacus and he's inno we lost a cop but we can believe what he said.
But we still lose a cop.

Also, there is a tailor so we can't even trust alignment upon death.

So many plot twists.
Idfk anymore :/
 
I trust Lucas to not have lied about his role and reports, and even though it's a bit fishy I trust nimsy

[Execute] JohnnyMustang
 
Well it doesn't make sense to lie just to buy yourself one phase :/
The only one I trust in this game is doof, since he's confirmed.

I still don't trust johnny at all.
But there's a chance that spartacus is mafia and had johnny tailored.
Or johnny is mafia and had spartacus tailored.

I have no clue what to think anymore.
 
Boy oh boy, I investigated Netto to see if there was anything he had/his power because tbh I was slightly confused at the start. I'm not saying that you're a Cursed One, Johnny, but the information I received about you makes it seem like you are. The other ones I had investigated before they died but I never mentioned it in the thread. I still have a weapon to use and if you believe I am a Cursed One then you lose something useful were I to be killed. I investigated you because of the suspicion that some others and myself have about you. As I said, I lack experience in Mafia so my judgement isn't exactly the greatest. It could turn out that I am very wrong about you, but it's a risk I'm willing to take at this stage, quite frankly.
 
Johnny, I wouldn't have picked you as a "baddie" if the power that I was told you have wasn't one I see as that of a Cursed One. I'll keep my pirate name classified for the moment, but I am telling you that it has not been mentioned yet. Furthermore, you did get a Cursed kill, yes. But, I did not confirm you as Cursed, although it might have been a strategy that Netto agreed to, which gave me another reason to investigate him. I'll admit, me not keeping up with the game all the time makes me seem unreliable, but if you get rid of me, you get rid of an inno. I will repeat this point again, I cannot guarantee that you are Cursed, just that your power is suspicious based off of the intel I received.
 
Spartacus said:
Johnny, I wouldn't have picked you as a "baddie" if the power that I was told you have wasn't one I see as that of a Cursed One. I'll keep my pirate name classified for the moment, but I am telling you that it has not been mentioned yet. Furthermore, you did get a Cursed kill, yes. But, I did not confirm you as Cursed, although it might have been a strategy that Netto agreed to, which gave me another reason to investigate him. I'll admit, me not keeping up with the game all the time makes me seem unreliable, but if you get rid of me, you get rid of an inno. I will repeat this point again, I cannot guarantee that you are Cursed, just that your power is suspicious based off of the intel I received.
Click to expand...

Yes but WHEN did you investigate people and what did you learn? I have information that could prove you innocent, or guilty, if you cooperate. Otherwise I'm going to vote for you and assume you're guilty.
 
Spartacus said:
Johnny, I wouldn't have picked you as a "baddie" if the power that I was told you have wasn't one I see as that of a Cursed One. I'll keep my pirate name classified for the moment, but I am telling you that it has not been mentioned yet. Furthermore, you did get a Cursed kill, yes. But, I did not confirm you as Cursed, although it might have been a strategy that Netto agreed to, which gave me another reason to investigate him. I'll admit, me not keeping up with the game all the time makes me seem unreliable, but if you get rid of me, you get rid of an inno. I will repeat this point again, I cannot guarantee that you are Cursed, just that your power is suspicious based off of the intel I received.
Click to expand...

Why out as cop but keep your pirate name a secret?
Your explanation for investigating netto is shaky at best, because by your reasoning he was dead first.

Also, it's only day 3, how have you investigated netto, hopeless, chesire and johnny?

I'm sorry, but I can only trust this weirdness once you die.
Even then you could have been tailored.
 
Last edited:
Nimsy said:
Why out as cop but keep your pirate name a secret?
Your explanation for investigating netto is shaky at best, because by your reasoning he was dead first.

Also, it's only day 3, how have you investigated netto, ketsu, chesire and johnny?

I'm sorry, but I can only trust this weirdness once you die.
Even then you could have been tailored.
Click to expand...

Where did he say those four names? I'm honestly having a hard time understanding what he wrote :/
 
Spartacus said:
I had information on Netto Azure, who I found was a Cursed One. Cheshire Cat and Hopeless Masquerade were revealed as innos to me, though Hopeless Masquerade was forced to walk the plank by the time I got back so wouldn't have been able to change their fate. But then, when I went to visit JohnnyMustang [/B], I was told he had an "evil feel about him", "like he was hiding something that could make a good guy bad" and vice versa.

Sorry for not being in the game too much, I haven't been able to time things too well and as this is my second game, I lack experience :/
Click to expand...


The names are in bold and underlined.
 
I think I am overcomplicating this too much. Basically, I was allowed to investigate Netto after death because I was confused about the situation after he died as I wasn't keeping up with the game too much during D1. Hopeless Masquerade was the first one I investigated and I found out that they were innocent, followed by Cheshire Cat who I was told had not used their powers and were innocent. This is all I was told about those two in compensation for the Netto information. I most recently got intel on JohnnyMustang and was told of his powers. This does not confirm he is Cursed, but gives me a strong suspicion. This is all I know, therefore all I can say. I did not realise that revealing name was so big and I thought it would be fine not to, since I am fairly noob. Nevertheless, it is Lance Lock.
 
I don't trust you :/

People don't get to investigate the dead just because they're "confused".
 
Last edited:
Spartacus said:
I think I am overcomplicating this too much. Basically, I was allowed to investigate Netto after death because I was confused about the situation after he died as I wasn't keeping up with the game too much during D1. Hopeless Masquerade was the first one I investigated and I found out that they were innocent, followed by Cheshire Cat who I was told had not used their powers and were innocent. This is all I was told about those two in compensation for the Netto information. I most recently got intel on JohnnyMustang and was told of his powers. This does not confirm he is Cursed, but gives me a strong suspicion. This is all I know, therefore all I can say. I did not realise that revealing name was so big and I thought it would be fine not to, since I am fairly noob. Nevertheless, it is Lance Lock.
Click to expand...

Ok, since I'm being nice today I'll ask again. What nights did you investigate which people?
 
Wait, here's another thing.
The OP stated that Finnegan Mcswaggybooty was helping another modify his clothing.
So he's a tailor.

And what spartacus said would make johnny out to be the tailor.
I highly doubt that there are two tailors, so spartacus is lying.

I also believe that gunner actually was a cursed and was tailored.
The number of cursed ones wasn't stated this day phase, and that's probably why.
 
Wizardman11 said:
Ok, since I'm being nice today I'll ask again. What nights did you investigate which people?
Click to expand...

"Hopeless Masquerade was the first one I investigated and I found out that they were innocent, followed by Cheshire Cat who I was told had not used their powers and were innocent. This is all I was told about those two in compensation for the Netto information. I most recently got intel on JohnnyMustang and was told of his powers."

I thought I made that quite clear, nay?

I'm just gonna say that once you find out I'm innocent, you've dug yourself a deep hole by killing me. If you don't believe me at this point, I don't think I can change your minds. But I would seriously consider other people as Cursed. I have told you all I know about these people. And by the way, I am not saying that Johnny is a tailor, I was merely providing the information I was given off of him and trying to reach a conclusion based off of that ("evil feel about him, like he was hiding something that could make a good guy bad" and vice versa). As I have mentioned previously, maybe I am not explaining this properly because this is only my second game.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top