He told me to keep Shuckie, because I began training him and he became attached or something...if I remember correctly xD
You know in Cianwood City you get that Shuckie from some guy? Did you ever give him his Shuckle back? I havent bothered to yet even though its level 20 XD I just had him on a stroll in my Pokewalker. What about you guys?
I feel like that happened to me in the old games or something XD I havent trained him at ALL. :P I wouldnt be able to give my Pokemon to some random person. It would be weird.
Not even if they'd developed a special bond like Beca and Shuckie :O
No, I taunt him by saying "no" when he asked for it back.
nope after i got it i never thought of it again. when i got it in the original games i always thought that it was yours to keep as i think it was the only way to get a shuckle to complete your pokedex. (though im prob wrong) so i never even attempted to give it back. lol