• Our software update is now concluded. You will need to reset your password to log in. In order to do this, you will have to click "Log in" in the top right corner and then "Forgot your password?".
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

4th Gen Do you think Red should always be in Mt. Silver for re-battle?

Should Red be in Mt. Silver everytime for re-battling???

  • Yes!! that'd be great!>.<

    Votes: 25 73.5%
  • Hell No!!!>:D

    Votes: 9 26.5%

  • Total voters
    34

PKMN Trainer Red!

A former trainer champion...
  • 39
    Posts
    14
    Years
    For me I think he should!^.^
    cuz he's the strongest trainer around there and I like battling him alot!

    (Cuz that's my PC name...hehehe)
     
    I think he should be rebattleable.

    And it'd be cool if he'd had different Pokémon depending on the day of the week ^¬^
    This is just me thinking, and it's because I think that as he has (probably) caught all the 149 non-Mew and Mewtwo (since Mewtwo is catchable in HGSS) Pokémon in Kanto plus a lot more, and just having six of them doesn't really seem fair.
    Also, I don't really like that they took away Espeon and replaced it with Lapras. I know Lapras kinda fits him, and he got it during the main storyline, but having two Water types, when you could have a water and Psychic? I know Lapras is ice, which makes it really good out there in the hail, but still...

    If I were to decide, he wouldn't have at least Blastoise. Now that's just my opinion, don't get mad, but well... Change is always nice. Especially when done to the better.

    To get the question answered properly: Yes, I'd like him rebattleable. Good thing he is I guess ^¬^

    He's definitly my fav main character. And I don't think that'll change in future generations.
    But who knows?
     
    Since HGSS is a remake, I'd like to battle the girl Green, too. She's a main character from FRLG.

    In GSC there was no double battle, but in this game they should explore the new feature with a battle against both main chara.


    that would be pretty cool but as said before red is rebattleable everytime you beat the e4
     
    You can re-battle him already, im pretty sure ive beat him twice!
     
    Considering Red can be challenged again every time you defeat the Elite Four, then regardless of my opinion, the player still has the opportunity of battling Red more than once. It makes easy training for the game player and for those who enjoy having a rematch with the strongest known trainer in the game it's worthwhile.

    Although, if I could choose, one battle against Red would have been sufficient enough for me. He's a special character in the game, and if I got to battle him over and over again then it would become dull after an x number of times. I know what his strategy would be like and I know what his team would be like. Plus, I would only be getting stronger, therefore making the battle less of an experience.

    The journey up Mt. Silver is as long as it is, but the Elite Four has always been good enough for when I wanted to easily train a Pokémon. Not to say I won't challenge Red possibly twice, but I won't overdue it just to train a Pokémon of mines when there are other routes to take in doing so. If it's just to battle him, then it's different, but I would prefer not to overdue it or else, again, the challenge would become less of an excitement.
     
    I think it would have been pretty cool that if the second time around you battle him he changes to a random location or maybe you get to battle Leaf instead.
     
    I think you should be able to rematch, as most people won't bother may times, as their pokemon'll be so weak they'll not be able to afford the items.


    And on an earlier point.Double Battling and Blue should appear.How?By battling the two girls, Blue and Kris.I dunno where, maybe bottom of Mount Silver?Or on an added on route onto the top of Mt. Moon. Or on Cinnabar Island, seeing as it's got no gym now
     
    And on an earlier point.Double Battling and Blue should appear.How?By battling the two girls, Blue and Kris.I dunno where, maybe bottom of Mount Silver?Or on an added on route onto the top of Mt. Moon. Or on Cinnabar Island, seeing as it's got no gym now
    No, maybe you could find the girl Green on top of Mt. Silver, instead of Red, or maybe you could battle both of them, Red and the girl Green at the same time. That's just a thought, no big deal about it, please.
     
    A double battle with Red and Green(to avoid possible confusion, Viridian's gym leader) would be pretty interesting...

    To answer the question, I'm really not entirely sure. I suppose I agree with the sentiments that Red is unique like a legendary Pokémon and thus should be battled only once. Besides, don't we have all the other gym leaders to battle for rematches?

    On the complete OTHERHAND, I never did beat my Gold and Crystal games, so I never got to go up against Red....
     
    Back
    Top