Fun Game, The Card Collab Collecting Game

[Captain Gizmo]

Artwork: 7/10 Pretty funny :)
Playability: 5/10 His second attack is pretty good for those Pokemon with only one attack
Collectibility: 6/10 Gym leader Pokemon, I like those :)

 

[donavannj]

Artwork: 6.9/10. Very simple and straightforward, but action shots are preferable to me over the Pokemon just standing there doing nothing, not even posing.
Playability: 5/10. Has fairly low HP for a Stage 1, even in the Base Set era.
Collectibility: 4/10. It's from the base set, but it's still an uncommon.

Next up, Poliwrath!

 

[Captain Gizmo]

Artwork: 7/10 Very nice
Playability: 6/10 Good HP, Poke-Power is very good, Spiral Punch needs a lot of energy but could be a one-hitter.
Collectibility: 8/10

Aaaaabraaaaaa.......~

 

[icycatelf]

Artwork: 6/10
It's one of the more interesting Abra artworks, but it seems a bit odd.

Playability: 3/10
Vanish is only useful if Abra is about to be Knocked Out, but it would probably be knocked out before it got a chance to use it. A chance of Paralysis is always nice, though.

Collectibility: 1/10 It's not difficult to find.

Up next... the card that (supposedly) signaled the end of Kadabra cards (after Skyridge):

 

[Captain Gizmo]

Artwork: 3/10 Meh, not really nice artwork
Playability: 3/10 It's pokepower could help you sometimes and mindshock could do 60 damage but it's stuck at 30
Collectibility: 4/10

 

[o Pikachu o]

Artwork: 9/10 I like the holofoil background this card has
Playability: 4/10 Confuse Ray, uses too much energy and it only has 50% chance of confusing. It also has too little HP for a Stage 2 Pokémon.
Collectibility: 10/10 Its from base set, and the first edition version of this card is pretty valuable.

 

[Captain Gizmo]

Artwork: 8/10 Cool looking :D
Playability: 4/10 Abit too much energy for 50 damage
Collectibility: 5/10

 

[o Pikachu o]

Artwork : 7/10 I liked most base set artwork, but I never really liked this machoke that much.
Playability : 6/10 Both attacks use too much energies, and they have bad payoffs too.
Collectibility : 6/10

 

[Captain Gizmo]

Artwork : 9/10 Is there a full art version of this? It would be awesome
Playability : 9/10 Very good Poke-Power and attacks, but high retreat cost
Collectibility : 10/10

 

[o Pikachu o]

Artwork : 9/10 I love the art work on it.
Playability : 3/10 Low HP, Vine Whip is pretty weak.
Collectibility : 4/10 It's pretty common

Weepinbell!

 

[Captain Gizmo]

Artwork : 7/10
Playability : 4/10
Collectibility : 3/10

 

[Necrum]

Artwork : 8/10 (it seems reminiscent of very old cards to me)
Playability : 7/10
Collectibility : 5/10

 

[donavannj]

It's got interesting artwork, but it's not a very useful or collectible card being a 30 HP common.

Artwork: 6/10
Playability: 2/10
Collectibility: 1/10

Artwork : 7/10
Playability : 4/10
Collectibility : 3/10

After checking the first post, the thread creator did not want fakes included! Please refrain from posting fakes in here! Real cards only!

 

[Captain Gizmo]

Oh, oops. Sorry :C

Artwork: 6/10 Nice art from the previous generations
Playability: 3/10
Collectibility: 3/10

 

[donavannj]

^^^ Someone's not aware just how uncommon the Southern Islands cards are!

Geodude has decent artwork, but the red lava in the background is kind of boring. It's attack is horrendous, requiring 2 energy with a 50% failure rate and only doing 10 damage after 1 successful heads flip. It's also merely a common from a very widely collected and distributed set.

Artwork: 6/10
Playability: 2/10
Collectibility: 3/10

EDIT: Would help if I had posted a card:

 

[Captain Gizmo]

I actually got a whole load of those ones, so their value dropped for me ^^'

Artwork: 5/10 It's nice, but can't really tell what's the background
Playability: 4/10 I never really like the Gym Leader set
Collectibility: 4/10

 

[o Pikachu o]

Artwork: 9/10. The background looks amazing, and the Golem is drawn nicely.
Playability: 7/10. Avalanche uses too much energy, but self destruct is pretty good cause it damages everything. Only thing I don't like is that Golem dies lol. Also retreat cost a bit too much.
Collectibility: 7/10.

Ponyta!

 

[Necrum]

Artwork: 10/10 Beautiful. Even better in reverse holo
Playability: 7/10 Pretty decent for a base form Pokemon. It's better than most Rapidash I saw!
Collectibility: 8/10. Gotta love the reverse holo cards. Plus it's a reverse of a normally rare holo card, which is even better!

 

[Captain Gizmo]

Artwork: 5/10 Beautiful. Even better in reverse holo
Playability: 4/10 Pretty bad attack for a Stage 1 Pokemon
Collectibility: 5/10 Because it's a Dark Pokemon

 

[donavannj]

That Ponyta only comes in that "reverse" holo print form because that's a secret rare Shiny Pokemon card!

As for Slowpoke:
Its artwork is adorable, but it's really only good for setting itself up in-game and can't do much. It's also a common.

Artwork: 9/10.
Playability: 4/10.
Collectibility: 2/10.