Gunner's Vanilla Mafia

Okay, I want to hear thoughts from people now

Who are you all scum reading?

Would like to hear from BadSheep especially today
 
Me be a Fool? Nah. You just said Gimme- I'm pretty smart.

Anyways, Superjolt wanted me to speak. So here I am. Im an open book. I guess. Shoot!
 
Abby and Lost Heart are both quiet, Abby posting the bare minimum and Lost saying nothing really other than defence. Bad Sheep is a loose cannon, but I doubt he's mafia because he has zero organization or reason. I trust gimme, and I mostly trust Superjolt, so I would suggest we focus on the other two.
 
BadSheep said:
Me be a Fool? Nah. You just said Gimme- I'm pretty smart.

Anyways, Superjolt wanted me to speak. So here I am. Im an open book. I guess. Shoot!
Click to expand...
I wanna hear your thoughts - who do you think is suspicious, who would you be willing to vote for today?
gimmepie said:
I still feel iffy on Lost and maybe on Abby. I don't have anything solid though, just gut feelings. BadSheep is a pretty smart dude so I wouldn't be surprised if he was playing dumb in order to get himself lynched as the Fool.
Click to expand...
I feel the same about Abby and Lost. I was with Pecilia when he was questioning the wagon on Lost yesterday, but now I'm not so sure, especially with Zap flipping inno. Part of me wonders if I'm underestimating Nero too.
Abby said:
-
Click to expand...
Lost Heart said:
-
Click to expand...
Time for the silent ones to weigh in
 
Lost Heart is suspicious in my opinion because, as The Nero pointed out, she is very defensive.

However, The Nero did catch that very hard-to-find and tiny clue. It makes me think he is trying too hard. Its a little suspicious to me.

Thats my two cents, i think.

I am currently undecided on who to vote for, but so far Im leaning The Nero.
 
BadSheep said:
Lost Heart is suspicious in my opinion because, as The Nero pointed out, she is very defensive.

However, The Nero did catch that very hard-to-find and tiny clue. It makes me think he is trying too hard. Its a little suspicious to me.

Thats my two cents, i think.

I am currently undecided on who to vote for, but so far Im leaning The Nero.
Click to expand...

Catching clues is a bad thing?
 
BadSheep said:
Lost Heart is suspicious in my opinion because, as The Nero pointed out, she is very defensive.

However, The Nero did catch that very hard-to-find and tiny clue. It makes me think he is trying too hard. Its a little suspicious to me.

Thats my two cents, i think.

I am currently undecided on who to vote for, but so far Im leaning The Nero.
Click to expand...

Jeez you're a shitposter BadSheep.
 
My thoughts? I'd think it's fairly obvious that BadSheep is playing a rather poor fool. Other than that, I'd say the only person I feel confident is town is gimmepie. He could have bussed Altaria the first day but I doubt that's the case.

I'm somewhat suspicious of Superjolt simply because he didn't seem to be as investigative right from the start as he usually is.
 
Alright, the options are just getting broader here, and time is running out too quickly. I've taken a look, and I feel like this game is going to end in one of three ways unless we make the right choice.

1: Either Abby or Lost Heart are mafia. They attempt to win by being quiet and only posting when necessary. At the start, I noticed Abby mention lynching Gimme jokingly. Bard, who was maf, agreed and voted for him, possibly expecting Abby to back him up, Abby instead remaining quiet seeing as though the Altaria/BadSheep bandwagon was too strong anyway. Abby and Lost both haven't done enough to read properly, but because everyone else seems to have excuses it makes them look like the only suspects.

2: Superjolt is mafia. He started the BadSheep votes instead of voting against Altaria. He also said that he was iffy on Altaria being voted. What then doesn't make sense is Bard voting for Gimme afterwards, however. After N1, Superjolt doesn't do anything sus, but I doubt this is him trying to be sneaky after his cohorts were offed. On D2 he mostly just back and forthed with BadSheep and voted for a reasonably suspicious person. Right now, I keep getting more and more suspicious of Superjolt, but at the same time I'm constantly reminding myself that Superjolt being maf doesn't add up.

3: BadSheep was the mafia the whole time. As a new player, he plots to distance himself from the other mafioso, votes based purely on who he feels like voting for (mostly me) and covers it up with the excuse that 'he's new'. Then, once he's confident that the fool is dead, acts as (but never claims) the fool role. Confident that nobody will vote for him, BadSheep comfortably sits back and watches as the remaining villagers split themselves apart, knowing that by the time they work out who the true mastermind is, it'll be too late. I'm sure that there's a tiny chance of this being true.


So yeah, I'd prefer to vote for Abby or Lost, but I'm really conflicted on what's what now. Earlier, I would've only voted for Superjolt if the other two were out of the game, and maf wouldn't do that unless they were BadSheep. The fact that I'm now doubting myself is causing alarm bells to ring in Lost's direction. Gimmepie, I trust you, and I also trust you to make a better choice than I will due to knowing their playstyles, so I'll leave the vote to you and back you up.
 
Last edited:
BadSheep said:
Lost Heart is suspicious in my opinion because, as The Nero pointed out, she is very defensive.

However, The Nero did catch that very hard-to-find and tiny clue. It makes me think he is trying too hard. Its a little suspicious to me.

Thats my two cents, i think.

I am currently undecided on who to vote for, but so far Im leaning The Nero.
Click to expand...
Evidence/clues are what we're looking for though (Which clue are we talking about here btw?)
Lost Heart said:
My thoughts? I'd think it's fairly obvious that BadSheep is playing a rather poor fool. Other than that, I'd say the only person I feel confident is town is gimmepie. He could have bussed Altaria the first day but I doubt that's the case.

I'm somewhat suspicious of Superjolt simply because he didn't seem to be as investigative right from the start as he usually is.
Click to expand...
Probably because I'm not quite feeling it this game (or maybe it just wasn't the best to try and get back into mafia close to the holidays lol), it doesn't help that most people are being quiet anyway though

What do you think about Abby? Or the rest of the players?
 
BadSheep said:
It depends how you catch them, you see. Its like 'MERICAN football players catching a football within the game boundaries verses out-of-bounds. One is legal and the other is a counted as a dropped ball.
Click to expand...
Not sure what you mean exactly?

Anyway...

I considered that possibility @Nero about BadSheep too, but really don't think it's true

I think it does ultimately boil down to Lost and Abby (I mean, that "looking like they're both inno" comment from Abby is just awful no matter what), but dammit I wish Abby would post something (and not just some one-liner comment) because I think my decision on which one to vote for will be based on what they say

Tried to picture a world with scum!Nero, can't really come up with anything (same for GP too kind of)

So this is where I stand now, waiting for a response from Lost and an actual post from Abby
Abby said:
-
Click to expand...
Ding-dong! Time to wake up Abby
 
NIGHT THREE​

gimmepie - gimmepie
Abby - DID NOT VOTE
Lost Heart - DID NOT VOTE
The Nero - Lost Heart
Superjolt - DID NOT VOTE
BadSheep- DID NOT VOTE

A coin toss decides the fate between gimmepie and Lost Heart

The coin toss decides gimmepie as today's lynch.​

GIMMEPIE HAD FOOLED THE TOWN.
HE IS THE FOOL.

GIMMEPIE HAS WON THE GAME.​

YOU HAVE 24 HOURS UNTIL DAY​

RULES​

❋ The PokeCommunity Rules and the Underground Guidelines apply here
❋ To vote for someone, you must format your vote as [LYNCH] Name.
❋ Not voting for two day phases will result in your elimination or replacement.
❋ You may not share your PMs. You may share the information contained in them at your discretion.
❋ If you are out of the game for any reason you may not post at all. You are allowed one deathpost which should not contain any information about the ongoing game.
❋ You may not post during the night phase. This may result in elimination from the game.
❋ You MUST vote for someone. Abstaining is not allowed.
❋ In the event of a tie, a coin toss will determine who dies.
❋ Night actions should be sent to me by PM or Discord.

If you have any questions, you can PM or message me on Discord ​

THE PLAYERS​
Salzorrah as the Game Master

Aquacorde as innocent [N0]
Altaria as mafia [D1]
Rainbow as innocent [N1]
Bardothren as mafia [N1]
Zapmolticuno as innocent [D2]
wakachamo as ??? [D2]
Pecilia as innocent [N2]
gimmepie as The Fool [D3]

Abby as ???
Lost Heart as ???
The Nero as ???
Superjolt as ???
BadSheep as ???​
​
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top