• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Dawn, Gloria, Juliana, or Summer - which Pokémon protagonist is your favorite? Let us know by voting in our poll!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Mafia 102 [GAMEOVER]

Kaneki!!! said:
Ok sorry i was with my TOS mentality and sorry for that i am already calm, my points are: I have been contributing since early game, my reasons for killing vespy is him asking us to dont linch wich is suspicious, me asking for the cop was just me being dumb and forget this happened, asking for a gunsmith kill only reveal the shooter username (at least that is what i understood) and maf knows everyone who is inno lastly I was the first to go against random lynch why would i attack vespy for having tought of the same thing as me?
Click to expand...

Thanks for telling us. I choose to believe in Kaneki, therefore I am not voting for him. It's unfortunate for me if he's a mafia. At least for the time being nothing indicates he is, other than his rage which is a baseless point to direct him as the mafia.

Lisia said:
If anyone has a gun, don't shoot Kaneki. I don't really think that helps anyone because then we still have to lynch someone else like Dedenne1 said, who again at this point will probably still be an inno.
Click to expand...

You mean the person with a gun? They can be actually mafias too.

For example if a mafia has a gun and a doctor/cop is revealed, those 2 vulnerable roles will be killed off immediately.
 
The maf knows every inno there is no risk in him being town revealed.
 
Well if the changes are made as they have been we have approximately 11 hours till the night phase begins so i suggest everyone get in their votes by then and anyone with a day action take it if you wish.
 
Absol I've never seen anyone start Day 1 with your proposed strategy. That just isn't how games here on PC go.. :/
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sun
Dedenne1 said:
Ya thats the hard part i understand if hes the miller then he wants to show up as a miller but that doesnt help the villagers in any way... and why ask for the cop to reveal him/herself? Its just all suspicious sorry but thats how i see it.
Click to expand...

Because he was desperate. Supposedly if a cop has investigated him (during the night), the cop can prove his innocence.

But what he doesn't know/he might have forgotten because of his own rage, is that a cop cannot conduct an investigation during the day.

Am I correct, Kaneki?
 
Kaneki!!! said:
No i said to let me live so the cop invest me on the night
Click to expand...

Let's just say if

If you are the mafia, why would we let you stay alive just to be investigated? That just gives you one more day to kill the inno.

Don't forget the mafia isn't a one man team, we'd rather wish the cop to use his powers to investigate a person that we have barely interacted than a person who is almost dying.
 
Kaneki!!! said:
Ok sorry i was with my TOS mentality and sorry for that i am already calm, my points are: I have been contributing since early game, my reasons for killing vespy is him asking us to dont linch wich is suspicious, me asking for the cop was just me being dumb and forget this happened, asking for a gunsmith kill only reveal the shooter username (at least that is what i understood) and maf knows everyone who is inno lastly I was the first to go against random lynch why would i attack vespy for having tought of the same thing as me?
Click to expand...

Ok so i see how you were trying to help although most people where at the beginning but my only problem i see is your asking me to forget about you asking for the cop to reveal himself to help yourself. This does not help the village it only hurts it and helps the mafia overall and asking to forget that it happended seems suspicious to me sorry.

Sun i understand that hes desperate but thats no reason for a villager to hurt the village the explanation i see is that if the cop investigated him as a miller which he has CLAIMED he is then hed show up mafia so that wouldnt prove his innocence thatd just buy him time till the next day phase where hed likely be lynched. So basically all these actions would only hurt the village and help the mafia atleast in my eyes.

Sun said:
Let's just say if

If you are the mafia, why would we let you stay alive just to be investigated? That just gives you one more day to kill the inno.

Don't forget the mafia isn't a one man team, we'd rather wish the cop to use his powers to investigate a person that we have barely interacted than a person who is almost dying.
Click to expand...

But heres the thing hes supposebly a miller so he could never be shown to be innocent so either hes lying about being a miller or...umm idk

So to sum it all up he first told everyone not to reveal themselves then when accused he asked the cop to reveal himself to show hes innocent which is only bad for the village and then he says hes a miller which would not be shown to be innocent so it doesnt add up it would seem that hes lying sorry but that seems the most likely outcome.
 
Last edited:
I said that if i am miller it will suck for the whole inno because they will think they caught a maf.
And me saying about the cop thing is a normal thing in the game i normally play town of salem and i was just bot paying attention when i said it.
 
Dedenne1 said:
Sun i understand that hes desperate but thats no reason for a villager to hurt the village the explanation i see is that if the cop investigated him as a miller which he has CLAIMED he is then hed show up mafia so that wouldnt prove his innocence thatd just buy him time till the next day phase where hed likely be lynched. So basically all these actions would only hurt the village and help the mafia atleast in my eyes.
Click to expand...

You know what, I'm swaying right now as well.

I don't even know who to lynch now.

[PokeCommunity.com] Mafia 102 [GAMEOVER]


Miller
Sided with the village. The miller does not know their true identity - they see themselves as a normal villager. When investigated or lynched during the day they will be revealed as mafia. If shot dead or night killed they will appear as Miller.
Click to expand...
 
I didnt claimed i said that there was a chance that i was a miller and we cannot take risks with one inno dead and me to go.
As i said every vanilla can be whitout any knowledge a miller and that includes me.
 
Ya but the entire first day is a risk we have no idea whos who and by asking for the cop and shooter to show themselves your hurting the villagers atleast in my eyes and as i see it you are the most likely suspect ik its hard to show a good defense so perhaps show who else would be a good candidate to kill who else has enough suspicion on them to be voted off first. Who else is more guilty than you, that is what will get you out of this situation not swearing or saying shoot me :3
 
Kaneki!!! said:
I didnt claimed i said that there was a chance that i was a miller and we cannot take risks with one inno dead and me to go.
Click to expand...
That chance is very low though. We currently have 5 normal villagers left alive, so the chance that you are Miller is roughly 1 in 6. In terms of probability, you are probably not Miller.
 
Anyway is better to not take risks.
Also absol is here for a long time he is suspicious because of not being new and doing a newbie move. kill absol used bite
 
@Kaneki: The only situation in which it makes sense for cop to reveal this early is if there is another role that can protect them, like a doc, and if they have info on a maf. I don't think there is a doc in this game, so it would make no sense for the cop to reveal just to tell us all about your identity.
 
I didn't feel like reading 3 pages of posts but it looks like Kaneki is still gonna die.
Do you guys know what would be fun? If we had court cases for people. They could hire anyone who's willing as their lawyer. Or is that going too far? {XD}
 
SteveTheFish said:
I didn't feel like reading 3 pages of posts but it looks like Kaneki is still gonna die.
Do you guys know what would be fun? If we had court cases for people. They could hire anyone who's willing as their lawyer. Or is that going too far? {XD}
Click to expand...
I'm... not entirely sure having a court and a bunch of lawyers would help that much. Half the jury would be axed before Day 3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sun
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top