Map Rating/Review Thread

[Binary]

Zanacross--6/10--Its sorta plain.
Cooley--Oh is this a map of our hack? Ohwell looking good mate ;) 7.5/10

 

[maggi90w1]

Just another route. What do you think?

 

[destinedjagold]

it looks very good for a route. I like it. 8/10 ;)

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

some faketowns and routes...
1st 3 are going to be used in my hack...
Last one is a route and a town pasted together..
ratez?

 

[destinedjagold]

O_O OMG! So many maps to rate! Well, I can see that you've done a little tile editing. ^^

Spoiler:

1st map= Simple. I like it! 8/10
2nd map= looks really good for a route! Peaceful! 7/10
3rd map= a route to enter a cave! sweet! 7/10
4th map= I like the new Pallet town, though there's 3 minor tile error. eheheh :) 7/10
5th map= it lacks some houses for the people to live in... I kinda don't like the pokemon mart and centre... 5/10
6th map= uh.., o_O..? about the water... well, oh well... never mind. a few tile errors with the waterfall splash. 7/10

that's all! :D

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Thanks..:D
The first one is my favorite..:)

 

[Bebetrunks]

Wow Poke-roy, I <3 those maps. They made me wet myself. Which hack are you using them in?

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

It's for a hack I'm working on but I'm planning to post it when I'm at pewter city...
and when I really get in the scripting part...
But I already have a name for it...
(if it isn't already used) Pokémon Brilliant

 

[Bebetrunks]

Oh nice, i'll be waitign for some updates, and again I love the maps.

 

[Geeked]

This is for my hack pokemon black version
its a hack of fire red
This is belthorn city:

 

[Binary]

Young stunna--There are some errors on your maps, ohell--8/10
Poke Roy--Brilliant maps, my iam very impressed, and i see no errors(maybe some)--
1st-8/10
2nd-6.5/10
3rd-6.5/10
4th-9/10(nice tree tiles ;) )
5th-8.5

 

[destinedjagold]

@ yung stunna..,

a lot of mountain tile errors and the tile just above the door of the house on the upper-left corner of your map.

6/10...

 

[Ranger Dude]

GBA Version of Orre, Team Snagem Base



Sunset Village, Starter Town for (NEW) Haven Region

 

[Klingon]

Nice maps dude; you're pretty good at mapping, the tiles are nice.
8/10 for both.

 

[Geeked]

thanks ill try to fix those errors

Heres a few more maps

These are a few maps i did since my hack will not only include my region but the hoenn also

the route to oldale

Oldale:

Littleroot:

 

[johnlycett]

GBA Version of Orre, Team Snagem Base



Sunset Village, Starter Town for (NEW) Haven Region

Nice work ranger dude 8.5/10:)

While im hear ill post some maps

Spoiler:

 

[Ranger Dude]

Really nice maps! Love the style!

9.4/10

Great tilesets! 1 or 2 minor errors but barely noticable

Good Work

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

The same towns from me but with another palette..Ratez?(for the palette)

 

[coin3]

Woah, That town looks like one I made. Well, the main idea of it. With the top corner rocks and a lab on the side with a back area. and then the other houses to the side. But mine was bigger and not as good.

I rate your maps 7/10

 

[Binary]

Nice pallete Pokeroy,
it looks very good,
8.5/10