Map Rating/Review Thread

[Binary]

Nice maps,
1st map looks plain but good--8/10
2nd map, simple and nice--6/10

 

[Prof. 9]

Spoiler:

This is my map, Skiplit City. There's the Train Station in the top left (the train goes underground, that's why you don't see any rails), the Science Labs in the top right, the Television Tower in the middle, and Team Energy's Hideout in the lower right (that's a fake wall, there's a door behind it). =D

 

[destinedjagold]

ya know, it looks alright, but I think having the same coloured buildings itches the eyes...

anyways, 7/10..

 

[maggi90w1]

Route 2

(I'm very, very unhappy with the tents and the campfire. It was my first attempt on making new tiles... I guess I have to practise this a lot)

 

[cooley]

I think that is very Creative.
8.5/10

 

[destinedjagold]

well.., the tents look like they're viewed on top view. slightly change the angle of view and everything will be looking fine. I like the camp fire. ^^

no errors whatsoever. 7/10... :)

 

[maggi90w1]

We finished the first two citys (three with Pallet Town). What do you think?

 

[~Wave]

.:Map Name:.

Mazla Hills

.:Rom-Base:.
FireRed Version

.:Comment:.

My next hack: Pokemon Species (Re-Make of first hack by me)

.:MapShot:.

Attached to post.

 

[Lady Berlitz]

Let me see... I see no errors. I think it's perfect.
The only gameplay problem (if you were to play on that map) is the land beside the waterfall. It is a bit too squeezed in. Yes, I know that your purpose is to block everything off. But to give the player a bit more purpose in exploring there. Other than that, 9.9/10.

 

[~Wave]

well, thanks Esmas. I will show more maps, more often. But they will be from Pkmn Crystal Sea, (my actual hack), because Species is supposed to be later and no one has information about it.
---------
magi90w1:
on the upper level, on the edge of the mountain you could use the same block as on edges of lakes. Some errors:

1.-You can't get into some houses.
2.-Maps are too empty.
3.-If you upload images on .png format they will be on perfect quality.
4.-Your grass palettes are too kinda weird. You may have to change the tree palletes.

 

[Binary]

~Wave--Very impressive maps. There are lots of pathways and good
creativity-- 9.5/10
Maggi--The maps have alot of creativity but a few minor errors--9/10

 

[Zanacross]

Map is Sapphire

I'm just trying to home my pallet skills and mapping

i just want to know what everyone thinks.

I feel I'm getting good at pallet editing

Please can you tell me if theres any errors and what you think i should add or remove .

(i need help editing the house pallets, anyone got the offsets for pallet 1 5 6 7 8
Help will be appreciated)

 

[destinedjagold]

brightly colored... but the map is good...

7/10

 

[Binary]

Nice map Zanacross, there is a error on the mountain,
but its ok--7/10

 

[Zanacross]

Can you tell me any errors plese

I will be editing the house tile at a later date.

 

[~Wave]

zonacross, i suggest you to change your map extensions to .png, so when you upload it they would look with bst quality. By the way, although you're mapping well, I don't like how the original tree palletes are with the better grass palletes.

If you're going to do something, do it complete.

Change the tree pallete and it would look better.
Good Luck! ^.^

 

[cooley]

Map Game: FireRed

Map Name: Glistern Village

Map Shot:

Comments: Do not steal my palettes, Or my map.

 

[destinedjagold]

there's a ttiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiinnnnnnnnnnnyyyyyyyyyyyyy bit of error there.

eheheh, but anyways, the map is somewhat uh... looks like a route.

eheheh... 7/10

 

[cooley]

Can You tell me what the Error is?

 

[destinedjagold]

here...

Spoiler:

but no harm done. Just a simple tile error.