Map Rating/Review Thread

[haefele]

Your first map.... you have a big future.

For your first map is it great.
The tiles are good, the mapping is not bad -> good map.
But 1 thing... fill up the empty spaces and take a look at your map, you'll find tile errors.

@ Disturbed and Tropical Sunlight: Thank you for the comments...

I hope this map is better than the other 2, if this isn't good I don't know what is good... (was this correct english?)

These are Neti's tiles in dark... look:

img3.imagebanana.com/img/qzja0anf/SchneeNacht1.PNG

(I hate it, that I can't make links, if i haven't 15 posts >.<)

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

I hope this map is better than the other 2, if this isn't good I don't know what is good... (was this correct english?)

These are Neti's tiles in dark... look:

img3.imagebanana.com/img/qzja0anf/SchneeNacht1.PNG

(I hate it, that I can't make links, if i haven't 15 posts >.<)

Mapping - 10/10 - Perfect: I love it. Every little bit of it. It's so...natural and awesome-looking.
Creativity - 4/5 - Very Good: Nothing much to say. It's pretty creative for a mountain town. Although the houses are sorta far apart. :\
Playability - 2/5 - Poor: Up the top, you can see the mountain run into the border. :\ Not good.

Overall, a good map, haefele.

 

[WindBlows]

Hack Name: Pokémon Blaze Emotion
Map Name: Road 1
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[haefele]

Mapping - 10/10 - Perfect: I love it. Every little bit of it. It's so...natural and awesome-looking.
Creativity - 4/5 - Very Good: Nothing much to say. It's pretty creative for a mountain town. Although the houses are sorta far apart. :\
Playability - 2/5 - Poor: Up the top, you can see the mountain run into the border. :\ Not good.

Overall, a good map, haefele.

Öhm... how is with map connections, that the mountain is perfect?
Imo is this no problem.

Is the 2/5 only becaus the mountain? Oo

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Öhm... how is with map connections, that the mountain is perfect?
Imo is this no problem.

Is the 2/5 only becaus the mountain? Oo

Uh, pretty much. It's very ugly to walk in a map with a screwed up border.

 

[Alucia]

Game Name: Pokemon White Light
Map Name: Cielo Town
Mapshot:

now id like proper advice on it what needs changng and such

and credit to KyleDove and to me for the tiles

 

[haefele]

Hack Name: Pokémon Blaze Emotion
Map Name: Road 1
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

The Tiles are great, but the map is... to empty. its bored.

@Ninja Caterpie: sry but i don't understand, i'm from germany and i'm not a english genie. google say mush too xD

 

[пзо]

Map.

Mountide Town

Map of: Pokemon Fire Red
Comments:
This is a map by Aerodynamic, With Lots of edits by me.
If there are nay tile errors please report.
(Appart From the path, im working on a tile for that.)

Here it is, the starting town, for Pokemon Obsidian.
*Sorry no spoiler*

 

[haefele]

There are some mistages, see:
img3.imagebanana.com/img/tydytoo6/mistakes.PNG

The map is not bad, everything harmonies.

But one thing to the map: your empty spaces are filled of flowers and bushes, how is it with trees?^^

 

[Megiddo-san]

Route Trinwos mapped in firered. Credit to Alistair for mountain and path.

 

[пзо]

There are some mistages, see:
img3.imagebanana.com/img/tydytoo6/mistakes.PNG

The map is not bad, everything harmonies.

But one thing to the map: your empty spaces are filled of flowers and bushes, how is it with trees?^^

Thanks.. I really dont beleive your new. you have to be the best mapper ive seen in
my hacking days (Lets say like two weeks xD)
Man you have a Eagle Eye! Ok im gonna fill in the spaces.

Thanks again!

 

[Neti]

Thanks.. I really dont beleive your new. you have to be the best mapper ive seen in
my hacking days (Lets say like two weeks xD)
Man you have a Eagle Eye! Ok im gonna fill in the spaces.

Thanks again!

he isnt new, hes just new to this forum
thats why he cant post links
and yeah, hes really good! one of the best mapper on pokecommunity
but look:

i won the award :p
@haefele: good luck on this month, maybe youll win this time
i voted for disturbed though.. i just like his mapping style more, sry^^
even though i see a lot of similarities in mine and your style

well, gonna get some sleep now, its 23:24 in germany
merry christmas to everybody!

 

[Disturbed]

Map 4 minutes before Christmas xd

Spoiler:

No, there will NOT be any more sand, because it doesn't flow well... and yes, it is in Distant. But this is the only room I will show.

 

[haefele]

The idea of the cave is good, and there are no mapping mistakes, but I didn't like the style of the cave...
7/10.

And, for wish of colcostyles, a map with orignially tiles (I was worked for 4 hours on this map...):

 

[Disturbed]

The idea of the cave is good, and there are no mapping mistakes, but I didn't like the style of the cave...
7/10.

And, for wish of colcostyles, a map with orignially tiles (I was worked for 4 hours on this map...):

Rating: 7/10
Reason: It's well done. The shape of the cliffs is good, the beach looks nice, but there are a bunch of issues you'll run into on this map. One of those things being the border problems on the left side. Another being there is not enough space in the actual town portion to move. You'll be stuck on the path 95% of the time, and in my opinion, the player should be able to freely wander off and on the path. Sadly, the waterfall is done wrong, and leads to a small little pond? That's poorly done. The waterfall should lead to maybe the beach to say the least.

 

[Alucia]

Map Name: Lake Cielo

 

[Semblance]

Map Name: Route 1

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: First route of the game, tried to make it look as overgrown as possible.

 

[Alucia]

not a bad map at all it could do with some filling out and livening up a little bit also there might be a problum with the borders there should be 7 tiles in every direction for the border or the player will see a glitch area outside of the map ther than that its not bad at all the tree placement is great 6.5/10

 

[Master_Track]

Map Name: Route 1

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: First route of the game, tried to make it look as overgrown as possible.

The lower half really looks quite good.
I just think that the upper part looks abit to empty, try to diversify there ;)

I'd give you 7/10 all in all, but I've also got a suggestion...

In your comment, you wrote that you tried making it look as much overgrown as possible...it doesn't look that overgrown. (yeah quite..but it could be more ^^)
My suggestion...make the map bigger..x1.5 width or so..
And then get a lot of vegetation in there, it will look much more like the map you wanted to create ;)

 

[colcolstyles]

Map Name: N/A

Map Game: Pokémon Fire Red BPRE

Comments: I've had quite a number of requests to post another map. It's been a while since I've posted a map here. Enjoy :)

Mapshot:

Spoiler: