Map Rating/Review Thread

[HungryGengar]

Well, here's now my fourth ever map. Well, not COMPLETELY original but.....

This is Old Bark Town, a revamp of New Bark Town... It's supposed to look like 30 years later.
Although it may not look like it but.. I had to do over 10 block edits :S
Oh, and don't rate me on tree shadowing.. I'm still trying to learn that stuff.

e______e beautiful...

9/10!

 

[SmashLucario]

Another....

Used:
~SSKD Project~ Rombase

Credits to:
→Kyledove(Large tree[Slightly edited by iPro]; Flowers; Rock; Small Tree; Bush; House)
→Saurav(Big Tree; Grass Tile[Slightly edited by iPro]; Grass Path)
→Alistair(Mountains[Edited by iPro]; Sand Path)
→iPro(Palettes; Assembling the Base)

 

[Hoshiko Aki]

Who Know witch town it is the own gets a cookie.
Rates

 

[tImE]

Who Know witch town it is the own gets a cookie.
Rates

New bark town? lol

Okay, here's my overall rating: 4/10
And I'm not harsh compared to what some other people would give this map...

Problems:
1. The path is really awkward, no living architect, would lay the
roads (according to the buildings) that way.
2. "- points" for the tile errors
3. The border will get screwed up.
4. Yo have to learn how to make different kind
of houses, except for the window and size, all houses looks
exactly the same T_T...
5. Almost completely square map = I vomit... *Uaeeh....*

Try to improve this and post your new map, and hope to get a
better rating then.

EDIT: New rating

Another....

Used:
~SSKD Project~ Rombase

Credits to:
→Kyledove(Large tree[Slightly edited by iPro]; Flowers; Rock; Small Tree; Bush; House)
→Saurav(Big Tree; Grass Tile[Slightly edited by iPro]; Grass Path)
→Alistair(Mountains[Edited by iPro]; Sand Path)
→iPro(Palettes; Assembling the Base)

Overall rating: 6,5/10

Good path and house placement.

Problems:
1. Too straight/Unnatural mountains
2. If IRL that river would flow down the mountain like
a waterfall instead of floating, like 40cm, from the crest...
3. WTF?! Who the heck would build a fence right through a road? xD
4. Why would the citizens of this town use a cave to get out of the town, when they
can make a permanent road by cutting down like 1 tree? It make no sense.

But othervise, an accaptable map.

 

[~Teh Panda~]

Pokemon underground is back??? Yes it is!

New base, new everything!
Map: Milano Valley

Credits to kay3o for some tiles ;)

Reposting since no one rated >.<

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

@TehTehTehTeh: Nice map! I like the tree placement, but it could be better. 8/10

 

[Liquid Shadow]

Pokemon underground is back??? Yes it is!

New base, new everything!
Map: Milano Valley

Credits to kay3o for some tiles ;)

Nice map, 8/10
Why? Well for one thing the grass placement could be a BIT better.
The mountains are good, but could be a bit more sophisticated giving it a more natural feel.
Tree placement is good, except some of the tress to the right of the second entrance look a bit wierd.

 

[Disturbed]

Okay, I outdid myself on this map. I did this for 5 hours, and over 160 block edits were done. (I know this because the tileset completely filled up after I expanded it)

Now, it's named Route 601, and will be appearing in Distant, meaning it is NOT up for grabs.

I give major credits to Alistair, because I only used HIS tiles in this map.

Well, here's route 601.

Spoiler:

 

[Surf]

Okay, I outdid myself on this map. I did this for 5 hours, and over 160 block edits were done. (I know this because the tileset completely filled up after I expanded it)

Now, it's named Route 601, and will be appearing in Distant, meaning it is NOT up for grabs.

I give major credits to Alistair, because I only used HIS tiles in this map.

Well, here's route 601.

Spoiler:

Oh meh god that would take heaps of block edits too do.
Well i notice no tile errors so i'll give it a 10\10
Great placement with the wide veriaty of tiles
I would kill you after playing this map.

 

[~Teh Panda~]

New map updat with better pal's

 

[colcolstyles]

Who Know witch town it is the own gets a cookie.
Rates

With all those tile errors, it's hard to tell.

 

[Popstar Leafeon]

ROM: Fire Red
Name: Pinfur Town



This is the first REAL town in my game, Pokemon Lavender. Well, when you go to the Pokemon world anyhow. It's on a peninsula, and it's so small, that roads aren't exactly needed.

 

[SmashLucario]

EDIT: New rating


Overall rating: 6,5/10

Good path and house placement.

Problems:
1. Too straight/Unnatural mountains
2. If IRL that river would flow down the mountain like
a waterfall instead of floating, like 40cm, from the crest...
3. WTF?! Who the heck would build a fence right through a road? xD
4. Why would the citizens of this town use a cave to get out of the town, when they
can make a permanent road by cutting down like 1 tree? It make no sense.

But othervise, an accaptable map.

I guess I forgot to add in that the road's closed. xD Yeah that lake was a bit of a mistake. I shouldn'tve put it in, but the idea of the map came from it...

 

[Tyrantrum]

I haven't posted a map here in a long time:

Map of: Fire Red
Map for: Tensai's Secret
Credit: iPro, Kyledove, Saurav, Alistair

Spoiler:

 

[sasquatchd00d]

Tree Shading

Map Name: Trillium Town
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Nintendo - Tiles
Punk Rockers Tree Shadow tut

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

I know I've posted this map before. It has been pointed out that my tree shading was a little off. I read Punk Rocker's tree shadow tutorial and I fixed the shading errors. I'm mainly looking for comments about how the tree shading is done. I want to know if I'm getting it right.

 

[colcolstyles]

Map Name: Trillium Town
ROM: Fire Red BPRE
Hack: Pokémon Enigma
Credits: Nintendo - Tiles
Punk Rockers Tree Shadow tut

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

I know I've posted this map before. It has been pointed out that my tree shading was a little off. I read Punk Rocker's tree shadow tutorial and I fixed the shading errors. I'm mainly looking for comments about how the tree shading is done. I want to know if I'm getting it right.

Well, it's definitely an improvement. However, I still see some errors although all of them are places where you should have shading but you don't. For example, above the red house there's an errors on the bottom third of the tree. On the right side of the map, when you use the small trees directly underneath the big trees, there's an error in the shading of the big tree. That also occurs directly to the left of northern purple house. I'm not really in a position to make an image showing them so you'll just have to go off of my descriptions.

 

[sasquatchd00d]

Well, it's definitely an improvement. However, I still see some errors although all of them are places where you should have shading but you don't. For example, above the red house there's an errors on the bottom third of the tree. On the right side of the map, when you use the small trees directly underneath the big trees, there's an error in the shading of the big tree. That also occurs directly to the left of northern purple house. I'm not really in a position to make an image showing them so you'll just have to go off of my descriptions.

I see what you're saying about those spots. I followed Punk Rockers tutorial and that's how he has it shaded. I assume that is wrong then? I appreciate your help on this subject.

 

[colcolstyles]

I see what you're saying about those spots. I followed Punk Rockers tutorial and that's how he has it shaded. I assume that is wrong then? I appreciate your help on this subject.

Well in his tutorial I noticed that he has one half shaded but he leaves the other half un-shaded. I think that's an error as you usually have either both or neither of the halves shaded. I would reccomend looking at some of the original maps from FR/LG as they would be the most correct.

 

[Geeked]

Okay, I outdid myself on this map. I did this for 5 hours, and over 160 block edits were done. (I know this because the tileset completely filled up after I expanded it)

Now, it's named Route 601, and will be appearing in Distant, meaning it is NOT up for grabs.

I give major credits to Alistair, because I only used HIS tiles in this map.

Well, here's route 601.

Spoiler:

OMG You suck, the whole map is a big tile error!

Great Tree Placement, it looks to have major details put into it, on top of that it looks to have great playability!! Probably one of the best Routes I've seen from you.. from a 1 to 10, it's a certified 20! Since I pretty much can't do that... 10/10..

Those the new Tiles and Pallets for Distant?

 

[colcolstyles]

Here's to 3,000 posts in the Map Rating Thread!

Spoiler: