Map Rating/Review Thread

[darkmc21]

Map Name: No Name. x3

Map Game: Firered

Comments:Here is started Pokemon (Nameless) With, i changed the tiles a few times. Credits to Don Patch and Kyledove for tiles, i made the grass and water.. (Little edit, water)
Mapshot:

Looks a little to crammed in. Plus , as stated above, there normally isn't grass in towns on Authentic PKMN games.


Anyway, here's mine:

Route 1
Made in Fire Red
I personally like my POKéBALL shaped hedges at the bottom

 

[Kardin]

Map Name: Lowloft Town (Starting town)
Map Game: Ruby
Comments: The region this takes place in; Otherin, is very mountainous, and Lowloft is in a valley. I feel that the map portrays that quite nicely, and I'm very proud of that.

Also, the cause for the big ol' mansion down there is a secret. ;)

Image:

 

[johnlycett]

rate my map
by the way i can do better than this

 

[Adventure-Chan]

Map Name: New Bark Town
Game: Firered
Comment:Custom Tiles by Frario credit to him. Well?
View attachment 37227

 

[gag15]

region map

this is my region map for my hack pokemon blue sapphire

plz rate it out of 10

and give me true comments back


Shot at 2007-06-27


Name is Unduli

 

[foullump]

this is my region map for my hack pokemon blue sapphire

plz rate it out of 10

and give me true comments back


Shot at 2007-06-27


Name is Unduli

Awesome!!! It's big, has water and land, and looks cool with it's devided parts. The islands look awesome too. But there's a crud-load of cities. Won't it be hard to make all of them?
Anyways, I give it a 9 or a 10. Too hard to decide.

And How'd you MAKE the map??

 

[clakes707]

this is my region map for my hack pokemon blue sapphire

plz rate it out of 10

and give me true comments back


Shot at 2007-06-27


Name is Unduli

Rated Map: Above

Rating: 9/10

Reason: The map looks really good, but there is too much space between the islands.

Suggestions: Make at least two of the islands closer, and matbe make a land route( such as a bridge or tunnel) to the othewr one.

PS: How did you make the map?

 

[clakes707]

Petal Pasture

Map Name: Petal Pasture

Map Game: Pokemon Sapphire

Comments: This map is near Petalburg City. The body of water in the north-east corner has been replaced with a path that leads to Petal Pasture.

 

[linkandzelda]

map name: Cherygrove City

map game: Pokemon: Fire Red

Comments: This is a map from a G/S/C remake im doing

map: attached

 

[Lin]

Rated Map: The one above me, the remake of CherryGrove (I can't post links yet and it's an attachment)

Rating: 10

Reason: It's exactly like G/S/C's CherryGrove ;)

Suggestions: Honestly I have none, it's really good

 

[WindBlows]

Map Name: JOYEUX TOWN.

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Just a random map(maybe of my new hack).

Mapshot:

 

[Cartmic]

Map Name: Petal Pasture

Map Game: Pokemon Sapphire

Comments: This map is near Petalburg City. The body of water in the north-east corner has been replaced with a path that leads to Petal Pasture.

1/10

Reason: It appears that no thought has gone into this whatsoever and looks like it was done in 2 minutes. Also where are you entrances/exits from the map?

Suggestions: Just start again.

 

[nrox653]

Map Name: Petal Pasture

Map Game: Pokemon Sapphire

Comments: This map is near Petalburg City. The body of water in the north-east corner has been replaced with a path that leads to Petal Pasture.

Rated Map: Petal Pasture

Rating: 1/10

Reason: This map looks like a 3-minute piece of work. What's with all the flowers and grass? It's a boring and plain map that makes me sort of yawn just staring at it. Not really any creativity. Where's the map connections anyway?

Suggestions: You should add some ledges and more random placement of grass and flower tiles. And just get rid of that empty spot with the fence. Basically, just redo the whole thing over again.

 

[ruby]

Just noticed a small mistake in your map, the only things i would suggest is to have less empty space and have it so that the purple roofed house is not on the path. :)

 

[cooley]

Map Name: New Bark Town

Map Game: Pokemon Gold

Comments: This Map took 13 min to complete and i fell it looks nice

Mapshot: View attachment 37613

 

[Signomi]

...erm, right. This would be best suited in the Map Rating thread in Emulation.

~Moved

 

[treytrey113]

destiny city

Map Name: destiny city

Map Game:fire red

Comments:made by out hacks mapper as one of his works nad i love how he makes maps

 

[Latieon]

This map of mine won the July map making contest.
Id really love it if you people rated it.
Id like to improvise on it and on future maps.

 

[Latieon]

Map Name: destiny city

Map Game:fire red

Comments:made by out hacks mapper as one of his works nad i love how he makes maps

Mapping is bad.Roof is not proper of the white building.
Also there is no need for that fishing bridge like stuff on the road.
why the grass in a city?
Just 2/10

 

[Frostbite]

Map Name: Serenity Path

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: A small little path that is right outside the starter town. The stretch of water on the bottom leads to the pokemon league.