Map Rating/Review Thread

[Binary]

this is my first Region Map..!^^

Kyura Region

Wow, I like the region map. The land and the sea routes look well in place and it looks like the top of another region underneath it. It looks great! You could've also added some small islands. Just a suggestion.
8.5/10

Just fun to get some comments....

Rating: 7/10
Reason: Looks like a great little map. I like the small houses and the light green pathways leading to them. The little lake also looks good. It looks like a nice starting town. The dark shade under the rock in the small lake thing dosen't look good, fix it in block editor.
Suggestions: I guess...nothing...

 

[Luck]

I made what seems to be my most complex map so far.
Here it is:

Spoiler:

Please rate it!
and you start from the top left corner.
Credits to cheesepeow for the rombase

 

[Pinky Diaper]

I made what seems to be my most complex map so far.
Here it is:

Spoiler:

Please rate it!
and you start from the top left corner.
Credits to cheesepeow for the rombase

I personally like this map, however I think you've overdone the bridges a bit; they're fine but there's just too much. Apart from that, great map.

9/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

Hey, here is my map of Pewter City!
It's in my hack, Pokemon Wave.
I need help thinking of a name though...
Well, here it is:

Spoiler:

Hope u like it!
Plz rate/comment.

 

[One Winged Angel]

OK, I know I'm not that great at maps, but I give Furby's Map a
6/10
The reason is because its just to plain...
Theres not that many Tile Errors(I only See 1)
And the House has no windows.
The Bridge Kind of kills it.

 

[Barker]

I made what seems to be my most complex map so far.
Here it is:

Spoiler:

Please rate it!
and you start from the top left corner.
Credits to cheesepeow for the rombase

Very, very impressive. Easily one of the best maps I've seen in this thread. I can't point out any one thing I like, because I generally love the whole thing. However, like has been said, the bridges are a little much, unless they have a point in the story. Second, I would use side-stairs for the depressions; they're not hard at all to insert, and make more sense.

9.5.

 

[One Winged Angel]

Ok, I'm back with my renovated maps.
All Maps are for my Hack Pokemon Destiny/Destiny Legends. I'm using the D/P Rom Base from PHO.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it's made by Green Charizard???

Spoiler:

Here is The First Town

Here is the First Route. You can buy Pokemon In the House in the Corner.

This is my First City. The Green building is a Post Office(you work there). Next to it is a Jail.

Theses are both Route 2. They are connected by caves.

Please Criticize.

 

[Neti]

Ok, I'm back with my renovated maps.
All Maps are for my Hack Pokemon Destiny/Destiny Legends. I'm using the D/P Rom Base from PHO.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it's made by Green Charizard???

Spoiler:

Here is The First Town

Here is the First Route. You can buy Pokemon In the House in the Corner.

This is my First City. The Green building is a Post Office(you work there). Next to it is a Jail.

Theses are both Route 2. They are connected by caves.

Please Criticize.

Nice to see you took the critic seriously and overworked your maps! They look much better now!
They are not so squarish anymore, first route is still a bit but it is way better now.
the only map which has not improved is the first city (the bigger one). Did you change anything there?
Unfortunely i have a lot to do so i cant rate your maps and go into detail.
good luck

 

[Tyrantrum]

Ur maps look a lot better now, yunghove. :)
U just have to get rid of the grass in the city.

 

[One Winged Angel]

More Maps!!!

Spoiler:

These are some more maps from my Hack
Pokemon Destiny. Check it out.

https://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=134354

Another Map.

A Redid Map.

Please Criticize.

 

[Tyrantrum]

More Maps!!!

Spoiler:

These are some more maps from my Hack
Pokemon Destiny. Check it out.

https://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=134354

Another Map.

A Redid Map.

Please Criticize.

They're not bad.
map1: 8/10
errors: I don't think the rock bridge will work
suggestions: N/A

map2: 7.5/10
errors: I don't see anything wrong.
suggestions: N/A

Total suggestions: U've improved in ur mapping quite a bit.

Hey, here is my map of Pewter City!
It's in my hack, Pokemon Wave.
I need help thinking of a name though...
Well, here it is:

Spoiler:

Hope u like it!
Plz rate/comment.

Could someone plz rate my map.

 

[Dan13x]

Hey, here is my map of Pewter City!
It's in my hack, Pokemon Wave.
I need help thinking of a name though...
Well, here it is:

Spoiler:

Hope u like it!
Plz rate/comment.

Rating: 10/10

Reason: I love the tiles and the palletes, and the way you've mixed the gym roof tiles with the guard post tiles.

Suggestions: N/A

Here's a map for my hack.

Name: Aqua Town

Game: Pokemon Flash Yellow

Comments: The starting town.

 

[destinedjagold]

From the looks of it, there's a connection directed both North and South from that map, correct? :3

RATINGS: 8/10
REASON: I love the simplicity and the balance of the map. Though those bushes blocks the lab sign, what's it's use? :\
Also, the palletes are pleasing to the eyes. :)
SUGGESTION: Remove the lab sign if it's blocked by those bushes, or remove those bushes if the lab sign if important... :\
Also, make it less square... :\

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
My turn!​

MAP NAME: Sky Path North Sector
MAP BASED ON: POKéMON Ruby U.S. Version
MAP DESCRIPTION: In RoL, there's Sky Path, well, in RR, this is the Sky Path just above Rentelbud City, only accessable in RR...
It's the only pathway connected from Gento and Hevah...
I want it rated 'cause I'm not quite good in mapping sea routes... :\
MAP:

 

[One Winged Angel]

I luv it =D
The pallets are really pleasing!
I like the Complexity of it.
8.5/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

I seem to like it.

rating: 9.5/10
reason: I like the maze-like map u made.
The rocks r in a good position.
I don't really plan on re-making sea routes.
This was a good map.
suggestions: N/A

 

[Gerri Shin]

My turn!

MAP NAME: Sky Path North Sector
MAP BASED ON: POKéMON Ruby U.S. Version
MAP DESCRIPTION: In RoL, there's Sky Path, well, in RR, this is the Sky Path just above Rentelbud City, only accessable in RR...
It's the only pathway connected from Gento and Hevah...
I want it rated 'cause I'm not quite good in mapping sea routes... :\
MAP:

I'll give you a 9/10 and the only addition I would suggest would be to use some sort of border tile for the edge of the grass when it meats the mountain tiles.
other than that great job dude.

 

[Dan13x]

Here is the suggestion destinedjagold told me.

 

[Neti]

Here is the suggestion destinedjagold told me.

you definitely have to get rid of those grass tiles! They really hurt my eyes!
the rest is fine xD

 

[Epsilon]

Well, i'd like to share some maps with you.
They are for my hack, 'pokemon golden skies'.
The top left one is the main region 'Acitus'.
They're DP styled, and i even added a little animation for all the islands.
(just to make things clear)

Animation:

Spoiler:

 

[Binary]

Well, i'd like to share some maps with you.
They are for my hack, 'pokemon golden skies'.
The top left one is the main region 'Acitus'.
They're DP styled, and i even added a little animation for all the islands.
(just to make things clear)

Animation:

Spoiler:

Wow, I love your region maps, they look great! I love all of them especially the island ones. I love the D/P styled palletes and sprites, nice work! But in the First one there are land routes in the sea? Anyways, all of them looks good!
Overall rating: 8.5/10