Map Rating/Review Thread

[Epsilon]

About the land routes in the sea,
that's also on the D/P Sinnoh map..
I haven't added them to the islands because i'm not sure i want to make so many surf routes :P

But anyway,
thanks for your (good) rating! :D

 

[Master_Track]

well you don't have to make surf routes, you can make paths over the water ^^
I like the region maps too, they look like they would be from an original game!

But since I don't know that much about maps I wont post a rating.

 

[One Winged Angel]

Its the First City that I redone.. I hope its better.

 

[cooley]

Hey guys, It's been a wile since I posted a map, so here's one:

Map name:
Walby Town

Map comments:
Well I changed the starter town, to appear more like a quiet town. It still looks noisy though xD

Map Shot:

Enjoy!

 

[Tyrantrum]

Serious Improvement

Could someone rate this?
I need to know how to improve this to make it look better.

Spoiler:

 

[Gerri Shin]

Could someone rate this?
I need to know how to improve this to make it look better.

Spoiler:

well it's very obvious that it's a remap of viridian city. I would suggest trying to change the surrounding trees and mountains to something other than how they are arranged around viridian as well as a few more trees and flowers might help.
It is a little squarish, but I think that trees and flowers will help decrease that
overall it gets a 6/10 for the time being.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Thanx, not one of my best maps.
I'll fix it up and post it l8r.

 

[Dan13x]

Hey guys, It's been a wile since I posted a map, so here's one:

Map name:
Walby Town

Map comments:
Well I changed the starter town, to appear more like a quiet town. It still looks noisy though xD

Map Shot:

Enjoy!

Rating: 9/10

Reason: I like it how there's a beach, and the way you've used those tall, thin trees.

Suggestions: The top right house has a small hedge on the roof, I think you'd better move it.

My 50th Post!

 

[Binary]

Hey guys, It's been a wile since I posted a map, so here's one:

Map name:
Walby Town

Map comments:
Well I changed the starter town, to appear more like a quiet town. It still looks noisy though xD

Map Shot:

Enjoy!

Ah, it's a remake of my map :3
Rating: * 9 * 8.5 /10
Reason: Looks good, It looks like a nice quiet starting town to me. The trees are arranged in a good way. The pathways are nice and the flowers add simplicity to the map. The sandy shore looks great. There was a small error on the roof of the house, but everything else looks fine.
Suggestions: Fix some of the errors and you're fine.

 

[Neti]

Hey guys, It's been a wile since I posted a map, so here's one:

Map name:
Walby Town

Map comments:
Well I changed the starter town, to appear more like a quiet town. It still looks noisy though xD

Map Shot:

Enjoy!

Wow this map look really nice (and quiet, not noisy^^)
I really have nothin to correct here except for one tile error at the upper right house's roof, there is a bush covering it
rating: 8.5/10

Could someone rate this?
I need to know how to improve this to make it look better.

Spoiler:

Also a really nice map! I really like the tiles and how your map looks all in all.
But there are some things that are quiet useless, like the ledge at the bottom right, the hill/mountain with the sign on it and the ledge in fornt of the gym.
I also think it would look better if you would not use so many diffferent types of paths in one town.
Another thing is that this huge building in the center doesnt really fit in there, all the other buildings are small.
Tile Errors: Small trees at the bottom right and the roof of the huge building where it meeets the windows (you used the roof tile that is supposed to be above a door)
rating: 7/10

 

[X-Buster]

remember Kyura Region..?

if not, heres an image:

I was bored so I converted it into D/P theme, Here it is:
Kyura Region D/P theme:

 

[destinedjagold]

well, I'm not really good at rating region maps, so......
RATINGS: erm.., 8/10
REASON: I like the (region) map, it's very nice.
SUGGESTION: Use some darker water to make it more realistic... Cyan/Sea Blue hurts my eyes...

 

[blaster911]

I made what seems to be my most complex map so far.
Here it is:

Spoiler:

Please rate it!
and you start from the top left corner.
Credits to cheesepeow for the rombase

I rate it 10/10
it is so complicated but good it should have been used in a real pokemon game.

 

[One Winged Angel]

I have another Map.

Please criticize.

 

[Tyrantrum]

This map seems pretty good!
But...:
1. Too much empty space.
2. Grass in a city/town; don't do that, ever!(unless it matches up to the theme of the place)
3. A building peace as a bridge?(actually, that's not a bad idea, kinda matches as a bridge)
So...7/10
Izzat good?

 

[One Winged Angel]

Well thanks i didnt kno there was grass(where is it)
and I think the building tiles look better than the bridge.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Yeah building tiles do look better. Grass is next to what the bridge crosses -.-*

8/10
Bit empty... There's a path of flowers... Oh boy we love it...
Suggextions: Add more stuff?

 

[Neti]

i can just repeat what the others said: too much empty space, a path of flowers and grass in a city (besides i dont consider this too bad...)
the bridge mad eof house tiles is a good idea i think and it really looks like a bridge!
so 8/10 from me

 

[One Winged Angel]

Thanks Neti, I like ur rating because you tell people the details. Im gonna go fix my map.

 

[/Circa]

I have another Map.

Please criticize.

Uhh, this map is way to square and empty. The mountain is unnatural, and I dont really see why you need the fences there. I also beleive the trees overlap eachother to the side, which you didnt do. Plus the flowers look too organised, and really have no point in having a path. Again the map is way too empty, you didnt use the tiles in such a way to make it seem a little less empty, huge spaces dont really make a map interesting. Plus, having the building as a bridge is a bad idea, it doesnt match the ground at all, and stands out too much. 4.5/10