Map Rating/Review Thread

[Zeikku™]

Ok look I re did it with a twist the stairs lead into the forest after an event and when you look at it it looks like a dead end. Really its a shrouded forest that celebi resides in. please tell me its good and The grass became wild but the trees and all kept that way over 1000 years although it has never been touched. Its kinda like the sacred grove for pokemon!
[URL=https://img165.imageshack.us/my.php?image=thegatewayintomysteryfovc1.jpg][/URL]

Ok the map is a little too square, round it up a little. because it's not supposed to look like walking into a room with 4 straight sides.
And stairs that lead to nowhere...please fix that.
Using right tiles is the key, but don't over use tiles :P

Aurum Town (Aurum is latin for gold :))

Fire Red with super DP rom base

(THE TREE IS YELLOW FOR A REASON)

there are a few errors, like the rrof top tiles, and side stair leaking to a rock,
having grass in a town is a bad idea too.
there are a lot more things you can do.
yellow tree is way too bright..lol looks like a light bulb :P

 

[Mitchman]

Ok the map is a little too square, round it up a little. because it's not supposed to look like walking into a room with 4 straight sides.
And stairs that lead to nowhere...please fix that.
Using right tiles is the key, but don't over use tiles :P

Acually I said there the trees act as a barrier made by celebi. Its kinda like a path only you can see. Others if with you would see you dissapearing as well.

 

[Virtual Chatot]

Ok look I re did it with a twist the stairs lead into the forest after an event and when you look at it it looks like a dead end. Really its a shrouded forest that celebi resides in. please tell me its good and The grass became wild but the trees and all kept that way over 1000 years although it has never been touched. Its kinda like the sacred grove for pokemon!
[URL=https://img165.imageshack.us/my.php?image=thegatewayintomysteryfovc1.jpg][/URL]

Rating: 7

Reason: You should add more grass in the center, and more flowers.

Suggestions: ^ See above

 

[Mitchman]

I thought about rounding it as well. I am goin to that and as well as some other things.
I kinda made it round. Now it doesnt even look deep in the forest!

 

[garra911]

Ok the map is a little too square, round it up a little. because it's not supposed to look like walking into a room with 4 straight sides.
And stairs that lead to nowhere...please fix that.
Using right tiles is the key, but don't over use tiles :P


there are a few errors, like the rrof top tiles, and side stair leaking to a rock,
having grass in a town is a bad idea too.
there are a lot more things you can do.
yellow tree is way too bright..lol looks like a light bulb :P

Better?

 

[Tyrantrum]

Name: Forestgreen Village

Hack of: Fire Red

RB: Super D/P Rom Base; by X-Buster

Image:

New starting village for my hack Pokemon Wave.

 

[Melash]

^Nice, I like the waterfall in the starting town. I give it a...5/10. You see, you have some glitches in it! Here are some suggestions:
Change the mountains next to the waterfall going up, so it looks better.
Make a mountain border on the top
Make the steps on the top side of the second mountain go from one end to the other
Don't make the group of trees on the right side so square
Overall it's pretty good! Now rate mine!


Map Name: Route 29
Hack name: Awakened Legend (Hack of Gold)

Map description: The same Route leading from New Bark Town to Cherrygrove City. I wanted it to look flooded and destroyed. Also this one:
Map name: Cherrygrove City

I also wanted this to look flooded and destroyed. And finally:
Map Name: Whirl Cave

This is the remake of the whirl islands. I't s a major part in the storyline of Awakened Legend. Although it's square, you won't be able to tell whie your playing!
Please rate them #1,2, and 3!

 

[Tyrantrum]

I'm not good at gold maps, so I'll do my best...
#1: 7/10
#2: 5.5/10
#3: 9.5/10

~EDIT~
How's this?

Spoiler:

 

[Melash]

Umm, could you tell me why...?

 

[Tyrantrum]

#1: The cut tree is there for no reason, so it took out some points...
#2: Too small...Tile errors on the rocks in the water...
#3: Perfect!...Except for the tile error in the middle of the map on the far right...
I'm really not very good at G/S/C maps...

Also, I edited my post above urs.
Could u rate it?
Or anyone else if they want?​

 

[Melash]

Yeah, I like it a lot better! 9.5/10! I like it a lot because it's the starting town and I think it's a very scenic and good place to start! Keep up the good work!

 

[Kaizer-X]

I'm not good at gold maps, so I'll do my best...
#1: 7/10
#2: 5.5/10
#3: 9.5/10

~EDIT~
How's this?

Spoiler:

the map looks nice for a starting town. i like the forest theme but i think the rock thing doesnt really fits in well.

7/10

 

[One Winged Angel]

Hey guys, haven't been here in awhile.
Hows this Map? It's for my Hack Pokemon
Destiny.

This is Route 2.

And this is a remake of Demitri City.

Credits to my Good Friend X-Buster, for the Rom Base, And for Remaking all the Maps I do and Giving it some Spice.

 

[Mitchman]

Demitri city is pretty nice 9/10. Also it shares my name!

 

[LaurenLOVESTONED]

Hey guys, haven't been here in awhile.
Hows this Map? It's for my Hack Pokemon
Destiny.

This is Route 2.

And this is a remake of Demitri City.

Credits to my Good Friend X-Buster, for the Rom Base, And for Remaking all the Maps I do and Giving it some Spice.

i don't really like the grass on Route 2. its all over the place and it looks like it was done carelessly. apart from that they're both really nice maps. great work
8/10

 

[bugsbunny]

Map Title: RuralTown Village
Game: FireRed
Comments: I work on a Mac, so I had to make it in Photoshop. When I make a hack, I'll put this map in. It's for my hack, Tropical Yellow.
Attached at Bottom

Map Title: Winding Path
Game: FireRed
Comments: I work on a Mac, so I had to make it in Photoshop. When I make a hack, I'll put this map in. It's for my hack, Tropical Yellow.
Attached at Bottom

 

[Neti]

Map Title: RuralTown Village
Game: FireRed
Comments: I work on a Mac, so I had to make it in Photoshop. When I make a hack, I'll put this map in. It's for my hack, Tropical Yellow.
Attached at Bottom

Map Title: Winding Path
Game: FireRed
Comments: I work on a Mac, so I had to make it in Photoshop. When I make a hack, I'll put this map in. It's for my hack, Tropical Yellow.
Attached at Bottom

please turn off the rgid before making map shots, i cant really rate the overall impresssion aof the maps liek this...
but there wer aome things in the route that definitely caught my eyes: why are their stairs going upwards on the outside??? thats unlogical...
and the bridges somewhere on the water are also unseless.

i wont rate your map cuase of the grid and because i drunk some alcohol^^
if you reupload them without the grid ill rate them tomorrow

 

[Melash]

Okay, here's some more maps for my hack of Gold Version:
Map Name: Azela Town
Hack Name: Awakened Legends

This is Azela Town, now Azela City! I made it much bigger and better. NOTE: The Radio Tower is an IMPORTANT part in my hack! Here's the other:
Map Name: Blackthorn City
Hack Name: Awakened Legends

This is Blackthorn City, just like in Gold. NOTE: The Radio Tower is also important! Just because there's a Radio Tower in both doesn't mean you should lower your score!
I tried to make this town look kind of like the last sanctuary for the 'good' people. You'll understand more when you play my hack!

 

[bugsbunny]

please turn off the rgid before making map shots, i cant really rate the overall impresssion aof the maps liek this...
but there wer aome things in the route that definitely caught my eyes: why are their stairs going upwards on the outside??? thats unlogical...
and the bridges somewhere on the water are also unseless.

i wont rate your map cuase of the grid and because i drunk some alcohol^^
if you reupload them without the grid ill rate them tomorrow

Repost of RuralTown Village without the grid.

 

[/Circa]

Map Name: ---
Rom: Fire Red
Credits: Kyledove.
Map Description: Its my starting town, so theres not much too it, im using Kyledoves DP tileset, hopefully Ill change some things around later.

(attachment)