Map Rating/Review Thread

[Ninja Caterpie]

I have...another map!!
Whadaya think, eh?

Spoiler:

 

[FenderX]

Well, I finally finished inserting Don Patch's tiles (credits to him) after 3 hours(im kinda slow eh?), so here is a map i made using some of his tiles. I know the little pond looks empty, well its because i had no more room for Don's water plants.... And the second lab is supposed to be there, part of the story...heres the map!

 

[Tyrantrum]

It's very good! ^^
Of course, there r a couple spots that feel empty to me...9/10

 

[Ryousha]

I recreated the palletes for the snow to make it brighter, and I have recreated the ground road into a snowish, and I have added a snow bush, and a snowish long bush thing.

C&C, also rate ^^

 

[Neti]

Well, I finally finished inserting Don Patch's tiles (credits to him) after 3 hours(im kinda slow eh?), so here is a map i made using some of his tiles. I know the little pond looks empty, well its because i had no more room for Don's water plants.... And the second lab is supposed to be there, part of the story...heres the map!

a really nice map, ive seeen quite a couple of maps with don patchs tiles but you made good palettes i think which fit them
and dont consider yourself slow, i was inserting tiles a whole day long once^^ well i made 4 tilesets...
i got nothin to complain about except for the pond being squarish...
maybe you could have added a bit more stuff on such a big map, instead of placing so many trees
Rating: 7/10

 

[Flandre Scarlet]

@.Aaron:

Nice. 10/10
The pals are much better, and they really stand out.

 

[BlackRainbow*]

Here is a starting towns from my hack.
GreenBush Town

Hope You Like It

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Aww...Won't anyone rate mine?

Well, .Aaron, your map is quite nicely shaped.
Just, edit the houses to have icy roofs.
8/10

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

Here is a starting towns from my hack.
GreenBush Town

Hope You Like It

The placement is very nice, though you have the same name as my hack (Greenbush)
Will you rename it or do I have to do it?
8/10

 

[Ryousha]

Unfortunately, I dont pal create.

:/ I can some people who have pals of snow hacks,

I wonder if I ask Neti, would he yell at me?


@Dark Lakitu:
Woah I didn't see, your map

It's quite empty, D:

7/10

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

No, Neti isn't mean. He would let you...-cough- I think.

Well, I sorta couldn't fix up the emptyness...:(

BlackRainbow, 8/10

It's pretty startertownish...and small...and quiet...so yeah.

 

[Neti]

i did not make those palettes i got them from dshayabusa
ask him if he gives them to you
anyway ill release my rombase soon with a full ice tileset

 

[Hiroshi Uwishicarwei]

Yami Town Part A

Yami Town Part B
The wild grass there is the entrance to a forest.

I'm not taking:
Its a little too square,
Its too small,
or
it should be together.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Yami Town Part A

Yami Town Part B
The wild grass there is the entrance to a forest.

I'm not taking:
Its a little too square,
Its too small,
or
it should be together.

Why aren't you taking "It's too small" or "It's to square"??
Those are the NUMBER 1 BIGGEST PROBLEM with maps around.
Are the supposed to be joined together?
Why not have them together then?

Well, Map 1
It's... uh...too rectangular (I didn't say it!)
Other than that, it looks quite nice... :)
7/10 for rectangularness

Map 2
This one is much better.
I can't see any problems... (why is there a sign in a flower field?)
...Hmmm...
Why is there wild Pokemon grass in a town?
8/10

For both of them, the grass is too even. Use a different tile sometimes!

 

[Hiroshi Uwishicarwei]

Why aren't you taking "It's too small" or "It's to square"??
Those are the NUMBER 1 BIGGEST PROBLEM with maps around.
Are the supposed to be joined together?
Why not have them together then?

Well, Map 1
It's... uh...too rectangular (I didn't say it!)
Other than that, it looks quite nice... :)
7/10 for rectangularness

Map 2
This one is much better.
I can't see any problems... (why is there a sign in a flower field?)
...Hmmm...
Why is there wild Pokemon grass in a town?
8/10

For both of them, the grass is too even. Use a different tile sometimes!

I'm sorry for saying this but, you need to freakin' figure the god dang piece of crap out on your own...
Me and eeveon had this conversation via PM. I mide these maps on my own. If I can't be respected for what I make, then kiss my shiny metal ass good-bye...
I feel sorry for anyone who reads this and I'll take full respondibility for what I said... I am, from now on, always been ready to take all respondsibility...

 

[Disturbed]

Name: Maraudah's Icy Cave of Perpentual Doom

Spoiler:

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

I'm sorry for saying this but, you need to freakin' figure the god dang piece of crap out on your own...
Me and eeveon had this conversation via PM. I mide these maps on my own. If I can't be respected for what I make, then kiss my shiny metal ass good-bye...
I feel sorry for anyone who reads this and I'll take full respondibility for what I said... I am, from now on, always been ready to take all respondsibility...

I did freaking respect you by rating those maps.
It was some CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM for those freaking maps. It's what you put them in this thread for!

An I don't get the part about "figure out the god dang piece of crap on your own..."

ANYWAYS
Maraudah.
I don't really...uh...get the cave and...uh...it's kinda weird.
Is it meant to be really deep with a funny border or something?

Anyway, it's well shaped and *seems* to be some puzzle.

8/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

This is my first time mapping a cave.
Any comments r greatly appreciated.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

It seems quite nice and small, Eeveon. It's a good map for a first try :)
I can perfectly understand the puzzle and the shapes of the cave are nice.
Great map, overall!

Just a SMALL question, what is the border?

EDIT:
Ack!
I forgot to give a rating!
8.5

 

[Tyrantrum]

Thanx! ^^
The border is the white part on top of the mountains.