Map Rating/Review Thread

[Osher99]

yeah i know the error tilles just forgot to fix it..

 

[.:God:.]

Map Name: Foret Island

Map Game: Fire Red.

Comments: Littel Island =) Rate it Thanks ^^

Mapshot:

eh... what can i say? double post?

 

[cooley]

Hey guys! The last map I posted, was earlier in the Year, and I think it's time to post another one.

Map Name(s): Malrock City, Route 24

Map Game: Pokemon FireRed

Map Shot:
WARNING! HUGE MAP

Spoiler:

Map Comments: Two maps put together, please rate. And the wierd Rock Tiles, they're a secret ;) Anyone want to guess?

 

[Bishopk]

Map Name: Radell City
Map Game: FireRed
Map:
800 x 800

Spoiler:

Yeah, the flowers do spell BRAI - LLE in Visual Braille
Looking at it now, there doesn't seem to be much going on. I'll probably add more houses or something later

 

[Ryousha]

Hey guys! The last map I posted, was earlier in the Year, and I think it's time to post another one.

Map Name(s): Malrock City, Route 24

Map Game: Pokemon FireRed

Map Shot:
WARNING! HUGE MAP

Spoiler:

Map Comments: Two maps put together, please rate. And the wierd Rock Tiles, they're a secret ;) Anyone want to guess?

I see a tile error on the route, and a tile error on the city/town where the mountains are and next is a tree.

and OMG. It's MT. Eruption :P.

8/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

@cooley: O.o
~faints~

Nice map. :)
I do see a couple tile errors too, one of them is the bridge next to the edge of the water, it's missing the water ledges...8.5/10

 

[FoggyDoggy]

Hey guys! The last map I posted, was earlier in the Year, and I think it's time to post another one.

Map Name(s): Malrock City, Route 24

Map Game: Pokemon FireRed

Map Shot:
WARNING! HUGE MAP

Spoiler:

Map Comments: Two maps put together, please rate. And the wierd Rock Tiles, they're a secret ;) Anyone want to guess?

Do I spot a Rock climb wall? I bet that is it isn't it? Well, I give you a 9.9/10 on the route, and a 9.0 on your town there. (Nothing can be perfect! ^_^) I noticed there is a hole in the rocks in the water, where the player could surf down, unless blocked that with a movement permission... Great maps though!

 

[tImE]

Okay everyone, here's another
of my Maps for Pokemon Nature Force:

Map Name: Sabaku Outskirts
Game Type: Ruby AXVE
Map Shot:

Comments: The entrance to a Desert in my Hack
(Right of map: 2nd town, Below Map: Sabaku Desert)

 

[Mr.Fury]

Rom: Firered
Name: Iunno some route
Original: Sea route above cinibar island.

 

[Luck]

Do I spot a Rock climb wall? I bet that is it isn't it? Well, I give you a 9.9/10 on the route, and a 9.0 on your town there. (Nothing can be perfect! ^_^) I noticed there is a hole in the rocks in the water, where the player could surf down, unless blocked that with a movement permission... Great maps though!

Actually...it isn't that.
i used those "weird rock tiles" because the stairs would ruin everything since they would all be clumped together and look ugly.
but i shall not tell anyone unless Cooley tells me to.

Okay everyone, here's another
of my Maps for Pokemon Nature Force:

Map Name: Sabaku Outskirts
Game Type: Ruby AXVE
Map Shot:

Comments: The entrance to a Desert in my Hack
(Right of map: 2nd town, Below Map: Sabaku Desert)

Ah, thats much better.
The ledges are placed neatly, there is a second path, the trees have near perfect placements, its just great overall.
But the non bike path(you know what i mean) has too little grass. You can go through the whole area by touching 6 pokemon grass only. Not only that, the tree tiles seem really crowded.
Rating:8/10
suggestions: Make less crowded tree tiles and put more wild grass on the first path.

Well, i know no one checks page 58 anymore, and since my maps only got 1 rating, i will post it again.

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

 

[Tyrantrum]

@makunouchi:
Map 1: Everything is put in there nicely, except, add 1 flower at the bottom...9.5/10
Map 2: The shape is nice an the path is used nicely...10/10

 

[KhaosKnight]

@makunouchi

Map1: Hmm nicely done, though i think the ledge in the north east corner is a bt uneeded. My Rate 9.5/10


Map2: I Really like this one, all of the house are nicly placed. and the way the sand/rocky walkways that go well with the grass walkway. Though the path that leads to the southern most house does seem a bit uneeded(because it doesnt give the player a way to detour from the path), and that steel door in the north eastern mountain face seems a bit uneeded as well(i dont see a way the player could get to it) overall i give you a 9/10

 

[Ryousha]

I remade the first town of Faded Horizons, cause my first map was getting weird.

Credits:
Xiderwrong- The Complete Rombase!! <3

Notice:
the water has tile errors, I cant fix that. tough luck

 

[Tyrantrum]

It's a good map Ryousha, very good! :)
Only one tile error.
See attachments...9.5/10

~EDIT~
Never mind, u already saw it! :P

 

[tImE]

Ah, thats much better.
The ledges are placed neatly, there is a second path, the trees have near perfect placements, its just great overall.
But the non bike path(you know what i mean) has too little grass. You can go through the whole area by touching 6 pokemon grass only. Not only that, the tree tiles seem really crowded.
Rating:8/10
suggestions: Make less crowded tree tiles and put more wild grass on the first path.

Well, the reason I did, was because otherwise
the border would get screwed up, but that's
fixed now + now there's a minimum of 10 grass tiles to walk. ^^

//44tim44

PS. Rating of your maps:

Map 1: 8/10
The map is overall really good,
but there's to many and too big "empty spots".
(Try and add some flowers, paths or maybe a tree
in those "empty spots")

Map 2: 8.5/10
This map is really good, but the roads at some places
looks like it's too... (fat? xD)
And also here, too many "empty spots".

DS.

 

[loitraitim]

Map Name: Route 1
Map Game: FireRed (U)
Comments: Custom tile by X-Richie ;)

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Koral Town

Map Game: Ruby

Comments: Just made it on D/P Base rom.. quickly Rate it. Thanks ^^

Mapshot:

Map Name: Route 1
Map Game: FireRed (U)
Comments: Custom tile by X-Richie ;)

Wow very cool tile!..I like it 9/10

 

[Chimchar 9]

i just made a quick map

hack of fire red

please rate

its not one of my greatest maps

 

[Disturbed]

i just made a quick map

hack of fire red

please rate

its not one of my greatest maps

No kidding. The placement of the grass is HORRIBLE. You seem to use WAY too much grass, and it looks like it is just a space filler. The stairs don't have their usual shadow on the left side. But, I enjoy the layout and the placement of trees.
6/10

My most recent firered map:

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Froma Island.

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Not a Island of Fire Red Just Made It From Sea!

Mapshot: