Map Rating/Review Thread

[Likewise]

Thanks :) and i will work on the suggestions :)

 

[Tyrantrum]

Yo peeps. :D
I gots me a new map to post:

Please rate and comment. :)
P.S. This is a sneak peek of some new palettes I made. ;)

 

[.:God:.]

Yo peeps. :D
I gots me a new map to post:

Please rate and comment. :)
P.S. This is a sneak peek of some new palettes I made. ;)

Pretty cool Eevee. Don't like the use of the one particular house the whole way and one house has no windows. Unless it's meant to have a lot of rocks or something, I'd say there are too uch. | I'll give it a 8/10.

 

[+Sneasel™]

Hey, rate this :)

Yay, hope you guys like it!

 

[Tyrantrum]

I love it. :)
The only problem is that it has way to much unused space.
7.3/10

 

[Chimchar 9]

hey i fixed my map
please rate now

 

[Neti]

Hey, rate this :)

Yay, hope you guys like it!

hey i like it, you seeem to have some serious skills
but as wind already said, theres too much unused space
if you practice a bit more you can become a great mapper for sure

 

[Disturbed]

hey i fixed my map
please rate now

Much better!! I like the sand too. BTW, you didnt fix the small trees in the top left corner though. 8.5/10


EDIT: Forgot to mention, if you surf to the west side, you can see the Cliff go into the border

EDIT: (again: Since nobody has posted since I did, I have to edit this post. Here is my most recent Map.

Forest Pathway (FireRed)

Spoiler:

 

[Tyrantrum]

@maraudah: The shape is good and everything is put together nicely, but, there are a few empty spots.
9.8/10
------------------------------
Here's my map.
It's the starter town for my hack re-done.

Please rate and comment. :)
Thank you.

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Tombe Cave

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: 2 Maps of Tombel Cave.. Rate ut Thanks ^^

Mapshot:


Map 1:

Map 2 :

 

[Bishopk]

Here's my map.
It's the starter town for my hack re-done.

Spoiler:

Please rate and comment. :)
Thank you.

I love snow towns, and this one is beautiful. My only complaint would be that the path seems to dominate the map, but in such a small town I understand that.
9.7/10

Map Name: Tombe Cave

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: 2 Maps of Tombel Cave.. Rate ut Thanks ^^

Mapshot:


Map 1:

Spoiler:

Map 2 :

No cave is that square. While it may be quicker just to make squares, try to take the extra time and make it more convoluted, like a natural-made cave.
The second map, since it's tiny, is acceptable. I would fix the second set of stairs in the middle, I think it's going the wrong way.
6/10

 

[Tyrantrum]

Thanks for the rating. :)
I think I know how to fix it. ;)

 

[Mr.Fury]

Alright guys after looking over netis tut and many failed attempts i believe that for once i have made a decent map. but i am not the judge here, you are.

what do you think:
name: iunno that one map

 

[Tyrantrum]

This is a pretty good map. :)
The path and pond are nice, the building placement is descent.
But, two pokemon centers? :\
Also, your gonna have border errors and an empty spot below the PC at the left.
5.3/10

 

[Mr.Fury]

This is a pretty good map. :)
The path and pond are nice, the building placement is descent.
But, two pokemon centers? :\
Also, your gonna have border errors and an empty spot below the PC at the left.
5.3/10

There is a cave that you go through. So you should be pretty roughed up after you get out of the cave.

 

[Seraron~]

Here I prove to be two maps of my game: Pkmn Lost Treasure.

Isla Zero ->

https://i38.tinypic.com/35bf8e9.jpg

Inverse World ->

https://i37.tinypic.com/o791yh.jpg

For Mr.Fury: 7, two centers?? xD
For Wind: 8 ;)
For Osher99: 6,5 has some Mistakes

 

[Binary]

Here I prove to be two maps of my game: Pkmn Lost Treasure.

Isla Zero ->

https://i38.tinypic.com/35bf8e9.jpg

Inverse World ->

https://i37.tinypic.com/o791yh.jpg

For Mr.Fury: 7, two centers?? xD
For Wind: 8 ;)
For Osher99: 6,5 has some Mistakes

1st map:
Rating: 9/10
Reason: I think it's a great map. I like everything about it. The tiles are great and the palletes really match. Everything looks really neat and tidy and I love your way of mapping. It looks really good. Superb job.

Inverse World
Rating: 9.5/10
Reason: OMG where did you get that idea? *steals idea* XD. That's like the most imaginative map I've ever seen. It seems to be like somewhere in space. Really super job. The tiles look really awesome and I like the complete Idea of the map. Well done.

 

[Mr.Fury]

Wind~ and Seraron~
if you enlarge the picture you can see that there is a huge cave dividing the area, its a cave that is early on so you have to go through it. and you should be pretty beat up by the time you get out.

@ Seraron your maps are great.

9 for the first one because i dunno. XD
its to good to give it anything less but not good enough to give a 10.
if that clears things up.

same for the second one.

 

[colcolstyles]

Map Name: Route 5 (?)

Map Game: *image removed* BPRE

Comments: This a route I have been working on for quite some time now. I thought I'd put it up here for some suggestions. This is my first time posting here so let me know of anything I need to change so I can break any bad habits now.
EDIT: Oh and there's a trainer blocking the exit in the southwest corner between the two smaller trees.

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[Tyrantrum]

This is absolutely a wonderful map! :D
I love the shape, the waterfall, and the little sandy area! XD
Except, your missing 2 tiles in the little crater on the left mountain near the bottom. :\
9.7/10