Map Rating/Review Thread

[Disturbed]

credit to Visual for the rom base


then again i really couldn't chose so............... here's another version xD

well this was and old map of an old hack of mine I decided to redo.........

Both of the maps: 2/10
Reason: There is a load of empty space, the mountains look lazily done... There are absolutely no block edits (hint corner of rock hint) the shape of the water is poor, and the waterfall is not correctly done, and it is leading to nowhere. Also, the water is incorrectly done. I'm sorry but the only thing I like about this map is the shape.

 

[The Abyss]

Here's my first ever map!
Thanks to Zeikku for the Rombase.

 

[Surf]

Well heres a new map
Name: Arora Town
Credits: Alistar for the tiles

 

[Neti]

erm you just posted local links that we cant open, only peopleon your pc

 

[Surf]

Me?
no i uploded it on photobucket

 

[.Iramet]

Map Name: Mayflower City

Map Game: FireRed - Aquamrine

Comments: So, as stated above, this is a map in my hack, Pokémon Aquamrine Version. It's called Mayflower City, and the shop with the Cerulean Bike Store tiles is meant to be a flower shop, but becuase I haven't made the tiles yet, I just used those tiles. Note that it is big, so I linked to it (you may have to click on the picture to zoom in when it loads).

Mapshot: *image removed*

Please rate!

Dude you should try just a lot more.
I give it a 1/10
Sorry!
DX

 

[Golden Shaymin]

Me?
no i uploded it on photobucket

No King Kris put C drive photo's up

 

[Dratii]

Another map from me,
Rom: FR
Comments: It is a town. I am not so good at mapping towns.

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Wow.
8.5/10
dratii, my apprentice, you're getting as good as me!-self flattery-
Everything's really good, except change the grass you use. It looks funny up the top.

That one reminds me of my Jenimie Town map...-.- There are a few tile errors in the houses, btw.

 

[Surf]

Map Name: Hallow Point

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: This is one of m best maps that i have made. Credits to Kyledove for the Base

Mapshot:

 

[Austinia]

So I haven't posted a map in a while since I haven't made one in a while....


I made this test root map just so i can see how some of the new tiles im inserting look...

I'd really appreciate ratings and suggestions for the palettes and tiles i should add etc :p this is just a small route...

 

[Neti]

So I haven't posted a map in a while since I haven't made one in a while....


I made this test root map just so i can see how some of the new tiles im inserting look...

I'd really appreciate ratings and suggestions for the palettes and tiles i should add etc :p this is just a small route...

i love that tiles! would you mind making a rombase with them?^^

 

[Austinia]

i love that tiles! would you mind making a rombase with them?^^

I'm making a rombase kinda, though i've never done it before so i'm not exactly sure what im doing.... butbutbut I think I wanna use them only for my hack so I'm not sure I'd release it :p I do need to find another tree tile that fits with that palm tree. It's sorta unrealistic but i can't find any others :p oh well. so yea idk... depends do you need the rombase?

 

[Neti]

i like it^^
but well, actualyl i dont need it
release it whenever you want

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Here a faketown made by me:
Credits: Kyledove for the Tiles.

 

[Hiche..]

Here a faketown made by me:
Credits: Kyledove for the Tiles.

Wow very impressive. It's a very good map, the tiles are just great. did you insert them?
Rating: 9.5/10

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Wow very impressive. It's a very good map, the tiles are just great. did you insert them?
Rating: 9.5/10

Thanks :D but I would wish that I had inserted those tiles XD XD
I made this one with paint [first time since very long :p]

 

[4th Gen Matt]

I would appreciate it if everybody could rate the first town for my new fan game; Pokemon: Onyx Version and tell me what I could do to improve it.

kkthxbai. :psy copy:

 

[Likewise]

its probably the simplest map i've ever made but i'm happy with it.

 

[Hiche..]

its probably the simplest map i've ever made but i'm happy with it.

Well, I like the placement of the trees, and how you made the ocean/sea.
Only add a couple more of small trees.
Rating: 8.4/10