3rd Gen Preferred Series between FR/LG and R/S/E

[Nathan]

I prefer the Fire Red/Leaf Green series. My first pokemon game being Leaf Green, i think it's about nostalgia. Even though i finished the game many times, i still play it today.

 

[Sydian]

I love RSE. I cannot stand FRLG. Though both games are nostalgic for me, FRLG eventually paled in comparison to HGSS as far as remakes go. It was great for it's time, for me anyway. It's still nice to play every once in a while. But RSE I never get bored of.

 

[Gideon Jeremiah]

Seeing as I have SS, I see no reason for FR/LG.

Beyond that, I adore Emerald in every sense of the word.
Simply fantastic game! :D

 

[mishy.]

RSE. Kanto in general never appealed to me very much gameplay wise after Silph Co, and thus I have never beat the Elite Four. That extends to FR/LG, so by default RSE was more enjoyable to me.

 

[Seth Rollins]

I prefer Fire red and lead green. Why? Because my FIRST POKEMON EVER was a Charmander. Yeah I think it's about nostalgia.

 

[denash1]

I prefer emerald.. gameplay is fun and trainers are nice elite 4 is hard as well, overall enjoyed it more

 

[iammickey]

I prefer emerald 2.. Just u know y..

 

[Matty Mayhem]

I think both games have some upsides, but I think overall, R/S/E was much more enjoyable than FR/LG. The reason I think it was more enjoyable is mainly because R/S/E was a fresh start and FR/LG were remake games.

 

[pikakitten]

I love RSE. I cannot stand FRLG. Though both games are nostalgic for me, FRLG eventually paled in comparison to HGSS as far as remakes go. It was great for it's time, for me anyway. It's still nice to play every once in a while. But RSE I never get bored of.

I always find myself agreeing with you Sydian xD It's mainly these two things but also the rest of what you said, off-topic but I love your signature xD But classy girls don't kiss in bars, you fool! xD Gets me everytime xD

 

[PikachuAddict]

I like FR/LG better than R/S/E. It just might be the whole nostalgia factoring for me, since my emulating experience for both games sucks, since I'm playing on my ZuneHD.

 

[BLOOOD-La-ti-]

RSE,seriously those games are awesome,
even though I first played Red.
It would be awesome if they made a remake,
and seriously,if they don't,I would go kill gamefreak.

 

[Brendino]

I personally have FR/LG ahead of R/S on my list, but Emerald really topped all of them, so my entire vote goes to R/S/E. The Battle Frontier was one of the best innovations to the series, and it really gave the game continual playing value after the main story was completed.

 

[MattyJ]

It's FireRed/LeafGreen for me. Despite being a remake, I never got into RSE quite as much as I thought I should have. RSE and DPPt are, in my opinion, on the lower level of the Pokemon spectrum. Not 100% sure why, but that's just the feeling they give me.

 

[Lukar115]

I'm gonna have to go with FireRed and LeafGreen. I love R/S/E, but if you ask me, FR/LG are much more polished. Plus, I kinda prefer Kanto to Hoenn. :P

 

[Seppy]

I'll be voting for Fire Red/Leaf Green.
It's a difficult choice i must say, both the series i liked them a lot. I loved the first generation, and seeing a well done remake made me so happy, and R/S/E were made very well indeed. But still, i love how simple and clean was the first generation, as so it has been the remakes.

 

[vaporeon7]

I love Hoenn. FRLG doesn't hold a candle to RSE in my opinion, they were just that great.

 

[Hikamaru]

Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald for me.

Mainly cos Hoenn was my first region as far as the games go. Also, I loved the unusual Pokemon designs.

 

[PokéZoom]

R/S/E! In my opinion, FR/LG really aren't that great.

 

[Kikaito plush]

LG/FR in my opinion as it brought me back to my favourite tune: Route 1

 

[blue]

RSE without a dobut. Having already played through Kanto it wasn't much different when playing FRLG, I much prefer Hoenn to Kanto anyway.