Tales of Vesperia Mafia (Game Over)

gimmepie said:
You seem to be asking that a lot but not doing much probing of your own. How does everything that's been said sit with you?
Click to expand...

Even though I asked this once?

There is really not much to say here except we found a possible survivor.

But sure, if this is the reason I'm gonna get D1'ed again, for asking a question, Then sure.

[VOTE] Hypermorian
 
So basically, I'm getting hung because I asked ONCE if we had anything to go on? Wow, what level of skill.
 
The problem is a question like that is NAI, however, you've hardly made an attemt to focus on other player's actions



@home: Yeah it's chill if you claim... don't use it though, could be fabbed. anyone else got an item?
 
Abby said:
The problem is a question like that is NAI, however, you've hardly made an attemt to focus on other player's actions



@home: Yeah it's chill if you claim... don't use it though, could be fabbed. anyone else got an item?
Click to expand...

Well. What is there to focus on? I voted Hypermorian because I don't like random voters without reasons. But it's not like it'll make any difference.
 
L'Belle said:
Alright. I'll say it right here. I will not say anything if this will be the result.
Click to expand...

Being salty isn't going to make anyone less inclined to lynch you. Your post was exactly the kind of post a mafia player wanting to appear town is liable to make. It's designed to give off the appearance of scumhunting but lacks any actual substance. The idea of posts like that is usually to appear like you're a part of the conversation whilst other's do the legwork. Honestly, I was just waiting for a post exactly like that.

Then to top it off, your attempts to defend yourself have been minimal. You're in dire straights right now but haven't bothered to role claim and instead have just decided to be salty and threatened to be a non-participant. That doesn't give off town vibes.

If you want to save yourself at this point, claim.


On a side note, I'm also finding Sparkin' suspicious. I'm just not sure if he's scum and I'm wrong, if he's just new and we shouldn't worry or if he's scum throwing his partner under the bus.
 
Home said:
what do you mean by this?

@abby: oh, I missed the rigged fabricator in the roles list lol.
Click to expand...

Exactly what I am saying

gimmepie said:
Being salty isn't going to make anyone less inclined to lynch you. Your post was exactly the kind of post a mafia player wanting to appear town is liable to make. It's designed to give off the appearance of scumhunting but lacks any actual substance. The idea of posts like that is usually to appear like you're a part of the conversation whilst other's do the legwork. Honestly, I was just waiting for a post exactly like that.

Then to top it off, your attempts to defend yourself have been minimal. You're in dire straights right now but haven't bothered to role claim and instead have just decided to be salty and threatened to be a non-participant. That doesn't give off town vibes.

If you want to save yourself at this point, claim.


On a side note, I'm also finding Sparkin' suspicious. I'm just not sure if he's scum and I'm wrong, if he's just new and we shouldn't worry or if he's scum throwing his partner under the bus.
Click to expand...

I didn't claim because that would only make me seem even more suspicious than I already am. But I'll bite. I am Boccos, a.k.a, someone that can't do anything,
 
HyperMorian said:
To be honest, that was sorta of a random vote. I did it just so I can break the lack of talking in here.
Click to expand...
I agree with your motivations but random votes are always something I disagree with.
Bardothren said:
Well, alright then, I'll randomly vote too. I'm tempted to vote for HM for that random vote, but I know the pain of being lynched for casting the first stone. Instead I'll pick at random

[Lynch] Sir Dolan because that dolphin offends me.
Click to expand...
Yeah, you're also annoying me with this.
Aaron said:
Looks like our bandwagon is under way.

With that in mind: [Lynch]L'Belle but only to make up the 11 - I however am keeping my eye on Sparkin' after that post.
Click to expand...
To make up the 11? I'm used to a majority being needed to hammer and end the day early and I honestly don't think that would help. Is it different this game?
gimmepie said:
Being salty isn't going to make anyone less inclined to lynch you. Your post was exactly the kind of post a mafia player wanting to appear town is liable to make. It's designed to give off the appearance of scumhunting but lacks any actual substance. The idea of posts like that is usually to appear like you're a part of the conversation whilst other's do the legwork. Honestly, I was just waiting for a post exactly like that.

Then to top it off, your attempts to defend yourself have been minimal. You're in dire straights right now but haven't bothered to role claim and instead have just decided to be salty and threatened to be a non-participant. That doesn't give off town vibes.

If you want to save yourself at this point, claim.


On a side note, I'm also finding Sparkin' suspicious. I'm just not sure if he's scum and I'm wrong, if he's just new and we shouldn't worry or if he's scum throwing his partner under the bus.
Click to expand...

See, I was bothered and annoyed by the wagon building for basically no reason but now you've properly justified it.


So many people joined the wagon without actually contributing anything..... Gonna jump on one of those votes.

[Lynch] HyperMorian

Generally, on any given wagon a scum jumps on around third or fourth. This rule's not infallible but it seems decent enough and works both if the wagon is on town or mafia. Sparkin was third but they seem to be new so I'm going to give them some grace, but Morian was fourth. I don't remember if I've played any mafia games with him but I'm not the most active.... but he might also be a newbie in which case I apologize for the discrimination >.>
 
I'm not opposing a lynch but an unanimous bandwagon gets us nothing in terms of info and I'm considering HM as possible mafia.
 
oh things happened while i was sleeping nice

VOTE TALLY
L'Belle (9) - gimmepie, Johnny, Aaron, Home, Melody, SirDolan, Sparkin, Alex Kaz, Hyper Morian
HyperMorian (2) - L'Belle, Selena Fluorspar
Has not Voted - Fletch, Nakuzami, Salzorrah, Bidoof FTW, Uzumaki Naruto, jdthebud, luminitrium, Abby

With 20 people alive it takes 11 people for majority to lynch.

NIGHT ONE IS IN APPROX 10 HRS (MAY 21ST 5-8PM EST)
 
Last edited:
Johnny said:
The suspicion on you is much more justified than the suspicions on Hypermorian. Random votes to create interaction are a common thing and in my experience, mafia almost never do this.
Click to expand...

I disagree with that, but whatever.
 
While I on principle oppose random votes, let me emphasize exactly what a random vote actually *is*.

A random vote is a vote cast on a seemingly randomly selected player for no other reason than "I'm voting randomly". The presence of no other acceptable, logical reason is critical to this definition.

Hypermorian actually openly stated a different reason for his actions; therefore his vote is, at absolute worst, merely suspicious depending on how the target flips assuming he doesn't immediately die the night after and flip villager.
 
Melody said:
[LYNCH] L'Belle Might as well. Definitely seems scummy enough. Sorry man, that's Mafia
Click to expand...

Your posts have had this "im saying something important" look to them but if you read them you're just stating the obvious or doing random speculation that is pretty pointless and gets us off track, your doubt in Abby and your phrasing in this post has me suss.

[Lynch] Melody

EDIT: also incredibly suspicious of GP trying to force a claim on someone who did so little wrong so early, you're either playing scum carelessly or you're bloodthirsty town
 
I thought I was being paranoid about Melody but I guess there's someone who had the same opinion.

L'Belle has claimed, I dunno what else is wanted from him but it seems like he claimed a role that's cc-able. And no one's cc-ing.

I'm playing in way too many different sites, I forgot that random votes are just a thing here (and in any case that's not even why I voted HM). Melody was someone who jumped on the wagon with a "you're scummy" and I haven't seen her try to get much done (I may disagree with HM's random voting but at least his motivations were a point in his favor).

[Lynch] Melody
If we lynch L'Belle and he's town with everyone voting for him, what do we have on day 2? If he's town with half the players voting for him and half the players voting for someone else, it's at least something to gain info from.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top