The Graphics Rating Thread [READ THE FIRST POST. D:<]

[Idle.]

@Raixz Very nice sig.The BG could do with a big moe ZANG! to it but overall its pretty good.

:S new brush tryouts.

 

[Zebra Thunderhead]

@Viper - I think it's very funny that you comment on how Kai's stock was extremely hidden and then you go and do the same thing. I recommend reading your own advice.

 

[Idle.]

I took in what Color Me Evil said and made a new banner with the render less hidden by brushes.
EDIT: Update, added another render and some new text.

=]]

 

[evilcheese]

you read it wrong. the thing is to blend the render in but not so much. this isnt blended very good. try some smudge blending and no outer glow.

 

[Pikabloo]

Viper;; Outer glow = no D: Also, I don't like the brushes on top of the renders. Work on spacing as well, since there's a massive gap between the two renders. The varying quality of the renders is quite distracting, as in one render is sharper than the other. Oh, and work on colours. Just using blue seems so... boring.

---

Pff, another product of my boredom:

Feel free to laugh at the bad text >.>

 

[Idle.]

>< I can't take off the outer glow b/c it makes the outline good quality.I could rub it away though.I'll try again later today.

 

[/Circa]

Shiranui
HAHA LOOK AT THE TEXT!

Actually, the text is good, I like it :)
I cant really find much to disagree with, though you could try to make Narutos face stand out as much as the scroll behind him, it's very good though!

 

[Aizuke]

Shiranui; I quite like it. ^^ The colours blend really well together. Putting the text is always quite hard, but yours suits the banners' colour and gives it more.. Feel I supppose? XD But it's really good, wish I could do stuff like that. ^^;;

 

[Nytkoi]

Ooh. purple xD.
//8/10
the colors are ok,. but coloring the links would be god, since there's not a inch of blue in the banner.

 

[Aizuke]

Um.. Why do I need blue on my banner...?

Aren't you suppose to rate the graphics, not the signature as well...?

 

[Nytkoi]

o_o oops sorry, Akari! I got mixed up!

 

[Loki]

Here's some icon lovin'~

And, which one looks better out of the two below?

​

<3

 

[Nytkoi]

I personally think the first one ia better, it fits in more xD
rate pwease ><

 

[Uryū Ishida]

Kai;;its ok, i see you've used some vector brushes, correct me if im wrong. but i think it would of been better to leave the background white and more simple, the scanlines are alright. but the whole banner overall is a bit bright, then render is overblended (or just badly blended. 7/10

---

Made By request in my shop.

 

[Pikabloo]

Xenocrates;; I likey :3 The first one looks nice and simple. It took me forever to realise the musical notes to the left of his head xD The second one looks nice as well: the colours are nice, and the dot brushes make it look more, er, interesting. Although the lighting at the corner looks a bit too bright. I'm totally loving the third one <3 I prefer the first version, since that shade of green is better than the lime-y one on the second version, although the bit that says 'magic' looks a lot cleaner on the second one, rather than the first one. But yar, they're all good. I'm almost inspired to make icons of my own xD

Kai.;; The render blends too much into the background and everything looks far too bright (or at least on my screen, it does). The vector brushes look nice, though. And the blocky font for the text matches with the vector shapes. But everything looks too monotone. Work on the colours and image blending ^^

Ishida;; Nice smudge xP But I really, really don't like the distracting bright patches of yellow/orange/white D: It also doesn't help that most of these patches are located right next to the render, and that the render is low quality, from what I can see. The text is also quite distracting. The scan lines look fine, though. Basically, tone down the bright patches. Those are probably the most distracting things about it.

---

I added too much more effects, and got rid of the text:

There actually is text there, but you'll only see it if you look really closely. And no, it's not supposed to be visible if you only glance at it. It's not supposed to be visible, period.

 

[Renyui!]

Shiranui: nice with the text thing, i like how you make it shine atone end, and then fade away at the other, really nice.

some random animated avatar i made, you dont have to rate it, its pretty simple..
!Edit!
also a banner! i kinda overdid the dodge though..

 

[Uryū Ishida]

Poke'd;;Nice Banner, but sort of plain..the blurred background isnt good at all, and the text is just horrible...im sorry thats just my opinion. but it is a nice try, especially for a gimp user:P

---

The more ratings i get, the more i realise how sucky i am.

 

[Renyui!]

ah, ok man, thanks, that helps.
Uryu Ishida: its good, the size is a bit too big for my taste, and i dont really think the scan lines, needed to be there. good work man!
!Edit!
i just love making banners, i made this for my little bro, Sheimi. it's pretty good for me.

and thanks for th ppl of acanthie for the cool renders.

 

[Uryū Ishida]

Poke'd;;thats a big improvement :P!!! it would be alot better if you blended the render some more but great job i like the small text you've put across the right hand side. But where it says Bad egg. im surprised i could read that..you should definitely change that. 8/10

---

Here. i really thought i rushed your banner in my request shop. so i made another one for you. you dont have to use it though.

It would be cool to be rated as well.

Made from shira-chans tut.

 

[/Circa]

Uyra:

The first is a bit strange, for me atleast. The red and orange don't mix with the purple. and the focal point seems to be away from the render, so it puts it off, plus the text looks a bit slapped, buy hey, your probably better then me :P.

The second one I like MUCH more, it's effects go together well, so theres not much I can say.

I have a banner here, I don't think it's very good, I tried to make a banner in a completely off style :P. I still haven't made many good banners, so alot of criticism and ideas would help me alot, thanks.