The Nightmare Before Christmasfia - THE END!

My point precisely. That's not confirmation that a message was delivered. It could have been delivered but it could also have not been as well. Everything is as it should be. You can't take that message from Klippy as confirmation on anything besides that.
 
Yeah u are right Omicron but it is stored in my inbox , which makes obvious for me that I sent message but you know u are right what if small goblins and tiny creatures eat my msg halfway yeah that's the reason ! Case is solved!!!!

yeah its not happened that way I don't know I don't have any proof . Just see where flow takes us. Do what u think right. I gonna go with Golgari plan and see what happens.
 
Ok, you don't seem to understand what I'm trying to say. I'm saying the message could have not been delivered to Nimsy.

Anyway, that attitude will only work against your own interests, there is no need to act like that.
 
Hey many people say that to me sorry if you don't like the way I talk or my behavior but really I didn't mean . It is the way I talk , I am not even angry or frustrated . But really did I act really bad . Sorry again if u find it not right.
 
[KILL Nimsy]

I just don't like how you're trying to take control of everyone in the game and I don't think someone would make themselves an easy target by speaking a lot when you are inno and not talking while mafia. That sounds like a smokescreen to me.
 
Bard, you said so yourself, people won't receive carols if they used a NA, couldn't that be what happened?

I believe that desinishon is the penguin, but I also believe Nimsy, lol. That one is telling the truth doesn't mean that both can't be.
 
Omicron said:
Bard, you said so yourself, people won't receive carols if they used a NA, couldn't that be what happened?

I believe that desinishon is the penguin, but I also believe Nimsy, lol. That one is telling the truth doesn't mean that both can't be.
Click to expand...
Penguins can't sing...
 
that's good to know.

I still believe desinishon, though. So we need to figure our course of action.
 
JohnnyMustang said:
What info exactly? I don't see why you would say that right after i confirmed her innocence. The only reasoning i see behind that, is that you are mafia and you're triying to appear innocent, because, why else you would out yourself like that? Mafia would inmediately target you.
Click to expand...
I didnt see your poat initially and just saw people targeting nimsy
 
Well I'm still not a fan of the way things are playing out but if Nimsy is inno then so be it.
 
Interesting here, and I don't know what to say about desinishon-Bardothren-Nimsy stand-off.
What I will say, however, is that I don't really trust Johnny. Yes, it's completely out of the blue, I know. But consider this.
Fact: Johnny was outed as Sparky the Cutie Dog on Night 1.
Fact: Melody the Rudolph was caught by Shock Night 2. Meaning, she was again visiting someone.
[Fact: Both Rudolph and Zero operate on opposite, non-consecutive nights. See the role description.
In short, I believe that Johnny was outed by Zero, not Rudolph.
There are some flaws with this theory, of course. First is that N1 text said it was Rudolph revealing Johnny, but it makes sense disguising Zero as such, because otherwise nobody will believe it for a second.
Second, more serious one, is that there was no counter-claim. Honestly, I would think that the real Sparky, should I be correct, would have outed to spot the lie (and let us know on what nights who from Rudolph-Zero couple operates).
But what I said before are freaking facts. And I believe facts.
 
JohnnyMustang said:
You're wrong childe. You're all wasting your time triying to frame innocents. I share a chat with Krampus and i know for a fact that nimsy is innocent and that krampus will devour a PR role tonight :)

So yeah, stop wasting your time ok? I'm sided with the town, and i share a skype chat with krampus.
Click to expand...
To be honest, I expected a more thorough answer than "you're wasting your time". Do you actually have something to say against the facts I presented?
We might check if Krampus will devour someone tonight, though (are you saying he'll kill Zero?). For now, you're still suspicious to me.
 
Ugh.
What a long phase this is.
I'll just pop by once in a while to vote.

I'm not sure if I'll be back by phase end so
.
[kill] spartacus
 
If you wish.
JohnnyMustang said:
The only facts you've presented are things that we already know.
Click to expand...
Exactly. We know this for sure because these are the things taken from the phase posts and role descriptions, and that's why I'm calling them facts. Not opinions, not claims, but facts given to us by the GMs.
And they conflict with each other. And as soon as I noticed that, I thought of the reason behind it. That's what I'm basing my theory on - not "wild and wrong guess".
If you really need my train of thought, there. Melody the real Rudolph was visiting someone on Night 2 and was caught by Shock. Rudolph reveals players, and I quote the role description, "every other night". Someone "revealed you" on Night 1. If it had been Rudolph, he wouldn't have been able to go visit someone on Night 2. But he did, so the guy "revealing you" can't have been Rudolph. Conclusion? It must have been Zero.
And for that question you have:
JohnnyMustang said:
How exactly did mafia disguised Zero as Rudolph in a phase post.
Click to expand...
The mafia didn't. The GMs did. Because, frankly, if we were told "Zero says X is Y", than nobody would believe this (because his function is misguiding) and there would be no freaking sense in Zero's role. I've seen this type of false-revealing message before (in Death Note Mafia, I think?)
I welcome everyone to try and find a logical hole in this. But it has to be logical, and not "that's far-fetched and wrong and everything". I dare you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top