The Nightmare Before Christmasfia - THE END!

[Omicron]

The biggest problem with your theory, Childe of Malkav, is that there is no way that Zero could have known there even was a Sparky role in the game. There is no mention of it in the OP, it's a hidden role, and was never mentioned before that night in the phase posts.

 

[Childe of Malkav]

The biggest problem with your theory, Childe of Malkav, is that there is no way that Zero could have known there even was a Sparky role in the game. There is no mention of it in the OP, it's a hidden role, and was never mentioned before that night in the phase posts.

It was. On Night 0 we were treated to a charming paragraph about Krampus adopting Sparky. Please reread it.

 

[Omicron]

That's right, my bad. I forgot about the Sparky part.

 

[KetsuekiR]

The biggest problem with your theory, Childe of Malkav, is that there is no way that Zero could have known there even was a Sparky role in the game. There is no mention of it in the OP, it's a hidden role, and was never mentioned before that night in the phase posts.

I read backwards a little bit and if I'm not mistaken, Johnny was revealed right after N1 while Sparky was revealed to the players right after N0. Zero, then, would have known about Sparky, along with everyone else.

Since Melody is confirmed to be Rudolph and the D2 phase post implies that Rudolph was active on N1, Johnny couldn't possibly have been revealed by Rudolph. At least, that's what I understand from what I read and from what Malkav said.

EDIT: Spent too much time re-reading that I got ninja'd.

 

[Omicron]

Hmmmmm. Only one person has been revealed, which is weird, having two revealing roles.

There could be a chance that Rudolph has more than one NA and that's why this happened, otherwise I'm not sure.

Melody was active, so I don't know why we wouldn't have gotten a reveal in N0 if that's when her turns started.

hmmmm

 

[Z25]

I don't know what to make of all of this currently, I'm going to wait a bit more before voting.

 

[Childe of Malkav]

If I remember correctly, Melody was on the inactive players list on Day 1. She might have just missed her NA as well.

 

[Childe of Malkav]

Well, not only that. She could have chosen to not use her na. Rudolph can be as dangerous as a vigilante role, with a vig, you usually don't use your na on n0, you can kill the doctor, the cop. We're missing something too, she might have had an item and was triying to use it on n2 and that's how she got trapped.

Anyway, tonight you will see Krampus devouring someone unless some weird crap happens. If i were liying about my role, there would a counter claim, and there's not.

I see no point on keep arguing this, again, you're just complicating things.

That does make sense, especially the lack of counterclaim. If Krampus kills that someone, you'll be clean again in my eyes. (Although it might be nice if you describe that someone more).
And I'm not trying to complicate things, I just saw a suspicious oddity and decided to act on it=)

 

[Nakuzami]

If any of you geniuses have been paying attention

You'd realize that Johnny is Sparky, Nimsy is Krampus and Bard is James.

 

[Childe of Malkav]

If any of you geniuses have been paying attention

You'd realize that Johnny is Sparky, Nimsy is Krampus and Bard is James.

Woah woah woah, that is sudden. I know Johnny is backing up Nimsy, but how does it necessarily follow that Nimsy is Krampus? I actually was okay with the explanation of "we investigated her", and to be frank, I don't think they'd be so obviously working together, especially when Johnny was supposedly revealed.
And that's if we believe that reveal. I'd paid attention, thank you very much, and now I question this whole chain. Yes, if Johnny is Sparky, then I will believe Nimsy as well, regardless of whether she's Krampus or simply confirmed inno. If Johnny isn't, everything goes to Hell.
Now Johnny.

And don't worry, you won't need any explanation, you'll see what it does in the phase posts.

I understand you might not want to reveal who you gonna kill, because they'll try to act against you (especially if they got a role). However, there are so many things that can go wrong this night. Like Krampus being caught by Shock. Or some weird secret role like the Puppet Master gaining control of his actions. Or another secret role meddling (I'd expect everything at this point of the game). Or, if desinishon claim is true, penguins mating and cancelling all night actions. Or for the hell of it, Krampus simply getting killed.
Though in case of the last one, we're screwed anyways.
I'd just like a more narrowed down explanation than "That night someone dies". I'm not pressing on this one, however: you might really have your own reasons.
I guess I do overcomplicate everything

 

[Pave Low]

Nimsy, I changed my vote to Johnny because he made a comment on how happy he was that no one bw'ed him. I wouldn't have done it if there weren't already a couple bandwagons with a lot of votes. You've already got one inno killed, Nimsy, so you come out as suspicious and if you get another inno killed you're either mafia or you're not as sharp as I may have thought.

 

[Nimsy]

it's one vote.
Get over yourself.

 

[Nakuzami]

I'm sorry

But could you please explain to me how Nimsy got an inno killed

 

[Klippy]

Chill out on the aggression, people. Don't take it much further, please! :)

24 hours remain this phase.

Get your votes in, folks!

If there's room, (and unless I'm too late) I'm in. If there isn't any room, feel free to add me as a sub.

I've never done one of these before... Might as well give it a go. Let me in!

Sign me up please! It'll be my first time at this, so I'll try to do things right!

Count me in! Just one of me.

Since Babylon is on hold, I'll jump in this one (if there's room)!

maybe yes

Count me in.

May I get in? :P

In yo

dropping in through the chimney

better prepare the cookies and milk

Wow that is awesome I'm in

Can't resist. I'm in!

Oh my goodness, let me in.

In

ooOo

Count me in if u can

inner than in

it's the most wonderful time of year~

Put me I coach, im ready to play

I'm in.

Yesyes

Yas, I'm in. I freakin' love Nightmare Before Christmas.

hello i want to play

Hello yes

yes

Time for me to ruin Christmas. I'm in.

Yay time to lure new snails

hi. yes. this is for me. put me in. count me as 'down'.

Looks good, count with me.

Hello from the otherside

Sign me up!

Come on, give me some guns, i'm good with guns, ask netto.

heck yeah

In

 

[Universe]

these games get way too heated lol

 

[Childe of Malkav]

Look, i assume you've read the description of Krampus. He can devour someone by guessing their roles, and he can also investigate someone. After he guesses correctly, he obtains the power of the role he devours, when he uses his new night action, it will be mentioned. Trust me, IT WILL BE.

I won't deny or confirm nimsy being Krampus, i won't hint the most OP role ever so the mafia can kill them.

Oh, thanks, I forgot about that detail. And you have me officially intrigued. Apparently some crazy **** is going down tonight, guys=D
Though, like the all-doubting prick I am, I reread the role description and came up with the following questions.
1. Is it even possible to perform 2 NAs at a time? If I remember correctly, Krampus hasn't yet devoured anybody, so he couldn't have gained a NA that kills.
2. What is meant under the phrase "gains the power if guesses the role correctly"? I'd think if you investigated someone, it wouldn't count, because, well, it wouldn't be a guess. And if it would, then it's one hell of OP.
P.S. And I second Nakuzami. Spartacus' post seems weird and kinda unbased.

 

[Universe]

2. What is meant under the phrase "gains the power if guesses the role correctly"? I'd think if you investigated someone, it wouldn't count, because, well, it wouldn't be a guess. And if it would, then it's one hell of OP.
P.S. And I second Nakuzami. Spartacus' post seems weird and kinda unbased.

no no, it's like a Devourer role.

if the Devourer guesses a person's role correctly, they eat the person and gain their ability. i don't think the person being confirmed as any role prevents a Devourer action, but feel free to correct me.

 

[Pave Low]

it's one vote.
Get over yourself.

Umm you said I was suspicious because of this vote lol, this quote contradicts that.

 

[Nimsy]

Umm you said I was suspicious because of this vote lol, this quote contradicts that.

You contribute nothing.
The only reason you even pop into the thread is to join a bw or try to defend yourself.
Even if you are innocent it's not much of a loss.

I voted you for a specific reason.

The fact that you got all up in arms because one person has voted you is highly suspicious.
So I'm keeping my vote on you.

once again.
Get over yourself.

 

[Pave Low]

Maybe because I've had work for the last 2 days, ill last week and had stuff going on during my birthday?
Well, I don't see what I have done is suspicious apart from jokingly vote for Johnny so, on behalf of everyone, thanks for killing an innocent and attempting to kill another.

EDIT: I didn't even see a vote on me when I read because I missed like 4 pages, I only raised a question because of your "suspicious list".

This is how I see it:
- You put me on a suspicious list
- I want to know why, so I raise the question (mostly so I can stray away from repeating an act that made me seem suspicious)
- I'm told it was because I voted Johnny
- Okay, if you look at the post before I vote him, you can see that I changed my vote to him as a joke and I wouldn't have voted for him if there wasn't already bandwagons for other players.
- You reply with hostility after voting me for a bad reason
- I'm confused and annoyed

Nimsy, if you keep doing this to players, you're just gonna keep killing innos and it's an ineffective method. In fact, it is a harmful method. I believe that the only way to keep Christmas Town safe is by removing threats from it, even if they are CT, to prevent more threats. You jump on small things too quickly, call them suspicious, "oh well doesn't matter if he dies", lose another inno. Not worth it.

[Kill] Nimsy