• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Our weekly protagonist poll is now up! Vote for your favorite Trading Card Game 2 protagonist in the poll by clicking here.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

6th Gen The timeline effect on the games

Salt&PepperDiner said:
Man...how do I miss this stuff? Now I just look stupid. I still don't think that the timeline/continuity is a super-important part of the Pokemon franchise, but thank you for explaining to me how the timeline actually goes.
Click to expand...

No problem, always happy to help(especially given the fact that I'm a timeline maniac lol).
I know that GF can easily ignore the timeline, but like I said before:
"I think it give the franchise much more depth and a lot more to talk about".
 
GF has made it clear that they care more about game mechanics than maintaining a consistent timeline.

For an example, Jasmine's Steel-type Gym. In GSC, she talks about the Steel-type being "newly discovered". However, in RSE and FRLG, there is a Steel-type, despite them taking place beforehand, with no mention of them not being known about beforehand.

Then, HGSS simply retcons Jasmine into talking about how powerful the Steel-type is.

XY, similarly, mentions the newly discovered Fairy-type. And, ORAS, despite taking place beforehand, will also include the Fairy-type, likely with no explanation. Same for Mega Evolutions.

Other examples would be Gen III's trading mechanics - specifically, the ability to trade directly from the main games to both Colosseum and XD, despite them taking place at different times.
 
I don't think it'll impact the games more than some references, and maybe back story into how Megas were uncovered in Kalos (and possibly brought to, or also uncovered in the Hoenn region). Perhaps Xerneas and Yvetal were in Hoenn at one point, or the explosion from the weapon sent "radiation"? as far as Hoenn. Or the people of Kalos met the people of Hoenn much like how they linked Johto and Sinnoh at the Sinjoh ruins.
 
All they need is a time capsule like Gold/Silver/Crystal had and they're set.
 
cyanosis said:
All they need is a time capsule like Gold/Silver/Crystal had and they're set.
Click to expand...
They didn't have the Time Capsule for the Gen V games, or for the Orre spin off games for that matter. So I don't think they'll add it back in (sort of wish they did just to make it sound cool).
 
metalhand said:
Once again we have the tweet, also one of the NPCs tell us that something happaning with team plasma in unova, which make sure that XY take place at the same time as BW or BW2
Click to expand...

This is what Bulbapedia says on the subject (and I'm pretty sure that's the way the NPC put it in the French version as well) :

A male Pokémon Breeder in the Magenta Plaza Pokémon Center mentions Team Plasma "making news a while back in the Unova region"
Click to expand...

So, no, X&Y takes place after B/W/B2/W2.

(source)

I don't know what to think about ORAS and the timeline. What they seemed to do so far, ever since they rebooted everything in Gen 3, was releasing games in more or less chronological order. We had sequels, alternate versions, and adventures that took place more or less at the same time (I say "more or less" because DPPt and HGSS couldn't possible have happened at exactly the same time, because of Jasmine being in both games) , but no prequels.
I still kinda hope the remakes won't be retcons, but more of "history repeats itself"-type stories, but oh well, I can dream all I want.
 
Last edited:
I may be the minority here, but I don't feel like Game Freak gives the time line much priority when developing games. Now, I may be wrong, but what I'm saying is if they wanted to add a feature that might potentially clash with the time line, I think they would keep the feature. Sure, some things should be kept within logical boundaries, but it's not a strict following. Thus, they could do anything with ORAS in this respect - I'm excited to see what it'll be. :]
 
Sagiri said:
GF has made it clear that they care more about game mechanics than maintaining a consistent timeline.

For an example, Jasmine's Steel-type Gym. In GSC, she talks about the Steel-type being "newly discovered". However, in RSE and FRLG, there is a Steel-type, despite them taking place beforehand, with no mention of them not being known about beforehand.

Then, HGSS simply retcons Jasmine into talking about how powerful the Steel-type is.

XY, similarly, mentions the newly discovered Fairy-type. And, ORAS, despite taking place beforehand, will also include the Fairy-type, likely with no explanation. Same for Mega Evolutions.

Other examples would be Gen III's trading mechanics - specifically, the ability to trade directly from the main games to both Colosseum and XD, despite them taking place at different times.
Click to expand...
While I agree with about the mechanics(and I'm fine with, it will be weird suddenly going back to gen 5 mechanics), there still things that doesn't to paradoxal and can still fit the story. For the example the mega evos-even though they are an uncovered subject, it does known for few years, so maybe ORAS will be where it started.

And btw-how you where colosseum and XD take place in the timeline
 
metalhand said:
While I know gamefreak can easily ignore the timeline and do whatever they want, I really hope they won't ignore it, I think it give the franchise much more depth and give us a lot more to discuss on.
Click to expand...

I think they will do whatever they want. Honestly, while I agree it's fun to have things in order, I don't think it matters that much. Zelda's timeline is more important in the span of the games as they actually seem to connect to each other, and it was clear Nintendo didn't have an idea of the order until fans were begging them for an answer. Following that they released their official timeline, which included a split timeline, so that in order to play the games in canon order you had to actually lose while fighting a final boss. That's pretty dumb. So I think it doesn't really matter to publishers/developers involved with Nintendo unless the games are direct sequels.
 
Here's my theory.
R/B/Y/FR/LG - G/S/C/HG/SS - R/S/E/OR/AS - D/P/Pt - B/W - B2/W2 and X/Y.
 
metalhand said:
While I agree with about the mechanics(and I'm fine with, it will be weird suddenly going back to gen 5 mechanics), there still things that doesn't to paradoxal and can still fit the story. For the example the mega evos-even though they are an uncovered subject, it does known for few years, so maybe ORAS will be where it started.

And btw-how you where colosseum and XD take place in the timeline
Click to expand...

RSE FRLG can directly trade with both Colosseum and XD, despite no mentions of time machines in any game, which doesn't make any sense. XD establishes that it takes place five years after the events of Colosseum - RSE FRLG can't take place simultaneously with both Colosseum and XD, because the events of Colosseum and XD occur at different times.

We're talking about a system in which you can, without any mention of time travel, catch a Pokemon in Orre, trade it, and then trade it back to Orre, five years in the past.

The specifics of where Colosseum and XD take place don't really matter - it doesn't make sense no matter where it is.
 
Sagiri said:
RSE FRLG can directly trade with both Colosseum and XD, despite no mentions of time machines in any game, which doesn't make any sense. XD establishes that it takes place five years after the events of Colosseum - RSE FRLG can't take place simultaneously with both Colosseum and XD, because the events of Colosseum and XD occur at different times.

We're talking about a system in which you can, without any mention of time travel, catch a Pokemon in Orre, trade it, and then trade it back to Orre, five years in the past.

The specifics of where Colosseum and XD take place don't really matter - it doesn't make sense no matter where it is.
Click to expand...

I have a feeling R/S/E took place after G/S/C/HG/SS and before or around the same time as DPPt as there are references in DPPt to R/S/E happening in the past. Or G/S/C/HG/SS and R/S/E happened simultaneously. Because Steven is STILL Champion when HG/SS occur, as mentioned in the games.
 
Last edited:
Sideshow Bob said:
I have a feeling R/S/E took place after G/S/C/HG/SS and before or around the same time as DPPt as there are references in DPPt to R/S/E happening in the past. Or G/S/C/HG/SS and R/S/E happened simultaneously. Because Steven is STILL Champion when HG/SS occur, as mentioned in the games.
Click to expand...

The thing is though, since these references don't really impact the game unless the Champion itself visits the region and states they're the Champion, it could always be inconsistencies. Especially with the rate that they are producing mainstream PKMN games now, it's highly implied they have different teams working on different games. Although they obviously have supervisors and a backbone, I'm pretty sure there isn't someone who checks what literally every NPC has to say. So we could never know if its 100% or not unless it's actually confirmed.
 
Sideshow Bob said:
Because Steven is STILL Champion when HG/SS occur, as mentioned in the games.
Click to expand...

If this is the case, then Emerald doesnt take place with Ruby and Sapphire! The problem is that R,S, and E are simultaneously parallel to each other in terms of time. Now, I am not really that sure if Gen I and Gen III took place at the same time, we don't know. The only thing I could think up to tie FRLG to RSE is the Sevii Islands sidequest, but it could aswell be a time capsule for all we know.

I know the timeline is whack as hell but I'm guessing that GF will probably pull off some retconning in ORAS like they did in RSE when the Steel and Dark types were introduced whereas FRLG was = to RSE in terms of time.
 
Avant Garde said:
If this is the case, then Emerald doesnt take place with Ruby and Sapphire! The problem is that R,S, and E are simultaneously parallel to each other in terms of time. Now, I am not really that sure if Gen I and Gen III took place at the same time, we don't know. The only thing I could think up to tie FRLG to RSE is the Sevii Islands sidequest, but it could aswell be a time capsule for all we know.

I know the timeline is whack as hell but I'm guessing that GF will probably pull off some retconning in ORAS like they did in RSE when the Steel and Dark types were introduced whereas FRLG was = to RSE in terms of time.
Click to expand...

Does it state he's acting champion, I mean technically HG/SS had appearances by 5 champions
Blue/Red/Lance/Stephen/Cynthia .

Sorry quoted the wrong person
 
It's Steven xD Second person I see call Steven, Stephen...is it some kind of meme?

I think they'll keep the remakes where they are in the timeline. I think they'll imply retcon the mechanics but keep these games' event happening before B2W2.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top