Right, where to start. At the start would be a good place.
I think we should push for a lynch on mew_nani. To me, it seems like he's just spouting stuff from the OP and not really contributing to discussion or seeking for scum. Naku mentioned this, I think.
Would seem like "solid reasoning," except Nani does this everywhere. Take FF Mafia, where she was town, and Mafia 102, where she was scum. Some of her posts from both games loosely resemble her posts in this game. If anything, her posts in this game resemble her town posts in FF Mafia more than they resemble her posts from Mafia 102. It's just that the only knowledge she has about TWAU came from the OP so, unlike FF Mafia, she didn't have any prior knowledge to go on.
It doesn't seem to faarfetched for bard to bus like that, hmmm:/
Except it does. It really does. Why would someone who is already
confirmed as mafia take down another mafia member with them? The results of D2 clearly showed that Nani was not part of the mafia, and I really don't like how no-one else picked up on this. It would have made zero sense if she was mafia, especially given Bard's surprised reaction to the end of D2.
Nightkrow, that was just a joke vote, even if it counted, the majority was nl'ing.
The Crooked Man: The leader of the Crooked Crew and a man with a silver tongue. His vote in mafia meetings counts as two and he has the ability to overturn an arrest once.
...I changed my mind. Now I have a new target to kill.
[Lynch] mew_nani
Consider yourself dead.
"Well, I told you what would happen. You dare insult my joy…my love…Stannis Baratheon? So be it. The Crooked Man always makes good on his promises." The Crooked Man then cocked the hammer of the revolver, and aimed it at the trembling man. He put his finger on the trigger, and fired.
You seriously thought this was a joke vote? Bard, as the Crooked Man, was using his ability (bolded above) to kill Nani (which made her clearly not mafia, by the way.) If it wasn't for Snow White, Bard would have killed Nani. Sounds pretty serious to me.
And, for the record, the majority was not nl'ing on D2. They were all voting for Bard. Not that it mattered what the majority were doing because of Bard's ability.
Let me say this, however. Nani blabling is not a legit reason to suspect her, she just does that. She did so in Final Fantasy Mafia where she was town, and she did so in mafia 102, where she was mafia.
Finally, someone else who sees things the way I saw it! I'm not going crazy!
Nani was killed by a gun. And the reasoning was solid, if we had listened to you, we would've listened to a gut feeling, with no reasoning to back you up so don't brag :P
I know she was killed by a gun. I'm not blind.
It was the Naniwagon that caused her to RR, which subsequently caused her to get shot (presumably by Dee/Dum.)
The reasoning was anything but solid, for the reasons given by myself and alex above. I've been on her team for at least two games, one where we were mafia and one where we were town. In both games we shared a chat, and she posts. A lot. With most of it being silly waffle, but that's just how she is. As host of FF Mafia, you should know that too. I'd probably call this "reasoning" just a gut feeling, a hunch if anything.
On the other hand, what I said was anything but a gut feeling. I said that if Nani was mafia, Bard would not have targeted her on D2 with his ability. And where is the reasoning to back this up? The phase post at the end of D2, quoted above. That's where. The phase posts do not lie.
And I'm not bragging, I'm just angry that you (and others) completely dismissed / ignored what I said and didn't take it into account at all when jumping on the Naniwagon.
On a slightly less serious note:
Aaaanyway...now that all that's out of my system (srsly it's been bugging me all day)
Because of my role, I am not able to contribute that much in the discussion, other than pointing out people who are 'attacking' other people in the chat, like you are doing right now.
This smells of Underling to me. Either that or newbie-mafia, but certainly not town. Town would have nothing to hide because of their role.
Elektra Heart, Kaneki, Hibikaze, Eos (yeah, remember him? "I got nothing" on D1?) and to a lesser extent Abby haven't been posting much. Teeny bit suss of Abby for the quote above, but tbh I'd like to hear from all of them. Lurking in the darkness isn't going to do you guys any good you know ;)
![[PokeCommunity.com] The Wolf Among Us Mafia [Dawn Of The Ninth Day][GAME OVER!]](https://t12.deviantart.net/ZyRMNephGGSO31qDWNNUAmXcp4g=/fit-in/150x150/filters:no_upscale():origin()/pre12/08b0/th/pre/i/2010/221/8/0/murkrow_is_unimpressed_by_masterofgeckos.jpg "[PokeCommunity.com] The Wolf Among Us Mafia [Dawn Of The Ninth Day][GAME OVER!]")
