The Wolf Among Us Mafia [Dawn Of The Ninth Day][GAME OVER!]

[Choose]: 33
 
Last edited:
[Choose] 17
 
Well a lot has happened and I've been mentioned a fair bit so I'll reply to what I can :)

Superjolt said:
I like this post too and I find myself agreeing on jappo. Thoughts on Kendy and Lycan?
Click to expand...

Thanks for bringing me up, you have given me loads to reply to! :D

alexkaz61 said:
Kendy is on the same boat with jappo, in the sense that it's their first game. I called jappo on his low contribution because he said he's played mafia irl, so he probably has the hang of the game. Kendy looks kinda neutral to me, he looks neither scummy nor townie for the moment. Maybe that neutrality could be read as an underling's attitude, but judging from my first game here, he is just there trying to figure out what's going on.
Click to expand...

-Insert Thank you gif here-
Yes! this is my first game, I'm still learning the ropes, but trying to contribute where I can, I didn't even know mafia existed before joining PC, so sorry about my inexperience! (I have played TWAU a few times though which is helping a lot). I came up with the last riddle everyone is using at the moment for the mirror so I am trying :D

Juno said:
Kendy has been super, super agreeable, imo, and I hate that reading the Championships have influenced me to think this way, but I do feel like there's some merit to the argument that being too agreeable is a little scummy, because it seems like you're trying to make safe plays to follow the crowd and avoid drawing too much attention. It could just be because he's new though, and a nice guy, so I'm not too sure yet. :P
Click to expand...

Awwwh a nice guy? If that's the impression you have of me so far then thanks <3 I wouldn't think about the championships when it comes to me though this is my first game ;)

IMO my plays haven't really been safe, I've been using my opinions and trying to follow what's been going on (I've already made mistakes)

Elektra Heart said:
I'm seconding this. Kendy was very quick to jump off of Johnny after a claim, and that makes me want to keep an eye on him as well. Mafia tend to play nervously, making quick moves to avoid being caught. Sheeping isn't uncommon for newcomers, but we can't give him the benefit of the doubt for everything, so watching would be a smart thing to do.
Click to expand...

Sheeping? :( I'm trying hard not to, but when experienced players are coming up with good ideas why would a noobie like me oppose them if I agree? I did change my vote rather quick for Johnny, but he straight came out and told us who he was, seems like the right decision to me.

I'm not saying to give me the benefit of the doubt! definitely not, anyone should be on your radar who's roles you don't know!

Superjolt said:
Ok I see now (I made my last post around mid-page 16, so hadn't seen jappo's other posts yet) and actually agree. I dislike how part of jappo's suspicions stem from people suspecting him, making them sort of OMGUS but it's probably not very alignment-indicative. Kendy's never played before? Thought he mentioned previous experience somewhere but might not be remembering correctly
Click to expand...

no, I've never played, the guys in UGSC introduced me to EM a few days ago so I've played that maybe 3 times?

Zehn said:
Kill him! Oh sorry just want some death today other than mine. sorry kendy
Click to expand...

Zehn! :( I don't want to die so fast!


Klippy said:
It seemed like enough of us requested @ the Mirror. :/
Click to expand...

This! I honestly don't understand why we didn't get an answer... thoughts peeps?
 
As I said, Mary was watching. The Mirror will not answer if Mary is watching. That's why I didn't expect a response today, and lo and behold, none came.
 
Nakuzami said:
As I said, Mary was watching. The Mirror will not answer if Mary is watching. That's why I didn't expect a response today, and lo and behold, none came.
Click to expand...

There was exactly a 50/50 chance that the mirror would respond as we haven't been told specifically when it would reset so we could use it. You might not have expected a response, but by the looks of this thread many people still agreed it would be worth it to ask the mirror a question.

Do you think we should stop even trying to use it until Bloody Mary is out of the picture?
 
Or maybe one of the peeps who asked the question WAS Bloody Mary, thus resulting in the mirror not spurting out any info.
 
Y'know, the Bloddy Mary thing could mean that everyone else has to "Beware of Mirrors".

[PokeCommunity.com] The Wolf Among Us Mafia [Dawn Of The Ninth Day][GAME OVER!]

I don't know.
 
Uuuuh Bloody Mary, both in TWAU and normal legends, draws her power from mirrors. The "beware of mirrors" is definitely referring to everyone else.

And Kendy, I'm not sure where you got that "50/50" chance from. The mirror can be asked a question every other day, and yesterday was that day. But with the mirror being cautious of Mary, it would refuse to answer a question the next time it was asked. It's what happened in the game, it's what it sounded like in these narratives, and it's what Nimsy would do with the role. That's why I didn't think it would work, but I did still ask the question in case it did. But it didn't.

And no, I don't think we should simply not use it while Mary is around. For one thing, we can't kill her now that Bigby is revealed. Secondly, since the mirror refused to answer a question, Bloody Mary should no longer be watching it. But it's likely she'll watch it again if a similar question about the mafia is asked that caused her to watch it in the first place.
 
Welp, I take a walk back to my place for 6 hours and I immediately missed a lot of conversations. Im back you guys! I will buy you all a drink later this night.

Since I am kinda lost in the large amounts of threads, I am willing to answer any of you guys questions. As long as you dont ask about me, my FamiLy, where I live, what I do for a living and the rest of my background. ;)

Can I asume that the Mirror didnt reveal anything? So know we have to wait 2 more days before asking?

Have a wonderfull night everyone!

I pick number 7
 
jappo I think Omicron has taken 7 already.

Also

Elektra Heart said:
Don't worry, I trust you now. Sheeping comment was a reach. Lycan is a much better direction imo.
Click to expand...

Desi liked this post and he is Faith. Does that mean he has something on Lycan? But wouldn't that be a loophole of outing info he was not supposed to out cuz of his ribbon?
 
alexkaz61 said:
Desi liked this post and he is Faith. Does that mean he has something on Lycan? But wouldn't that be a loophole of outing info he was not supposed to out cuz of his ribbon?
Click to expand...

If the answer is debatable I don't think he's particularly giving anything away, in the game some ribbon wearers were able to give bigby some good hints as to what was going off without breaking any rules, I don't think Desi would have done it without clarifying with the GMs first (although this is a guess) :o
 
Last edited:
I don't like it because of lycan.


I like it because how fast kendy got off suspicious just like "sheeping is just a reach" or I liked it because I like bac and I want to like bac's post just randomly. There are thousands of scenarios.

Out of all you think about I'm trying to find loopholes hn. Sounds like panicked scum.

How the **** I told you any of the conversation or information about pudding and pie.

"Yeah I want to lynch lycan" so what I want to lynch you too. You're also a bad boy Alex don't ya.
 
Desinishon said:
Out of all you think about I'm trying to find loopholes hn. Sounds like panicked scum.

How the **** I told you any of the conversation or information about pudding and pie.

"Yeah I want to lynch lycan" so what I want to lynch you too. You're also a bad boy Alex don't ya.
Click to expand...

Wat.

Let's have it your way, Desi, and suppose I am scum. Why would the mafia be panicked at this point of the game? They have killed the doc, Vivian slipped through as the mirror didn't give us anything at all, Bigby is outed so Mary is technically immortal and they know most of the important roles after all these reveals. Why would I panic? What benefit would I have by trying to pick a mafia lead?

Regarding the loophole thing, I only mentioned it because I like to play fair. Outing info you were not supposed to out is cheating, even in the form of a like and I'm sure Nimsy would notice it anyway. I'm also wondering why didn't I mention this in my mafia chat... Oh yes, it's because I don't have one.

Speaking of mafia, you can win with mafia, can't you? What a better way of helping them than throwing suspicion on someone before the day even begins.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top