{Tile/Palette Rating Thread}

[Ben.]

well I re made the bridge for my hack tell me what you guys think

Urmm the tiny tiles on the bridge. they looks really strange uneven.
The bridge looks strange and has a strange shape
6/10
Pallet: 7
Nice pallets but don't go with anything in the map.

 

[NarutoActor]

yeah pokepal said the platelets didnt patch should I make the platelets lighter or darker also the tiles look biger in the game.

 

[Laidjon*]

It's a Pokemon Academy, like in Pokemon Ranger. It's also the first building I have ever made.

It's private, so nobody has permission to use it.

Please rate it very detailled, as I know it must have mistakes :P

 

[Logan]

Name: Slowpoke Well remake.
Project: Harry's sexy ROM Base.
Credits: Newtiteuf - Tiles
Comments: Took me ages, for my ROM Base. (:
Mapshot:

 

[Aljam]

Pretty good tiles! They all blend pretty well except for the rock in the top left. I R not give rating cause meh.

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Name: Slowpoke Well remake.

Project: Harry's sexy ROM Base.
Credits: Newtiteuf - Tiles
Comments: Took me ages, for my ROM Base. (:
Mapshot:

Aljam, give a rating. No matter what reason.

Right, all the tiles do seem to blend in. The rock in the top left does look a little odd (as the brown at the bottom has no strong outline, so it looks like the brown seeps into blue, if you get my drift. Makes it look like the ground is meant to be brown, but whatever), and also the water edge looks a little out of place. All of it looks detailed but that ledge which looks... Kinda cartoony for some reason.

8/10. (Excellent inserting, few tiles and pallettes out of place)

 

[Logan]

Name: <:
Project: Harry's sexy ROM Base.
Credits: Kyledove - Tiles
Comments: Didn't take me so long, for my ROM Base. (:
Mapshot:

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Name: <:
Project: Harry's sexy ROM Base.
Credits: Kyledove - Tiles
Comments: Didn't take me so long, for my ROM Base. (:
Mapshot:

Kyledove's Pallettes too, right?

These flow together, as they are his tiles, so they are expected to. The Light door of the cave looks kinda... Weird, I have no clue as to why... probably that the floor around the light (to the right and left of the light, barely visible) looks darker than the floor.

8/10.

 

[Pokepal17]

Name: <:
Project: Harry's sexy ROM Base.
Credits: Kyledove - Tiles
Comments: Didn't take me so long, for my ROM Base. (:
Mapshot:

It looks nice, and I know it'll look nicer in game.

10/10 for the tiles.

However the brighter bits of the palettes don't agree with my eyes. ¬_¬
I know they're the palettes that Kyledove made them with, but I think they can be improved.

So I'll give you 9.5/10 for the palettes (after all you didn't make them yourself :P).

(Damn, that's gonna be one sexy base).

 

[NarutoActor]

Someone needs to keep this alive. I just want to know how these pallettes and trees fit together in Ruby's Petalburg Woods:

(Credit: Reck - Tiles and Pallettes, Kyledove - Pallette for ledge, Alistair - huge tree)

From a first glance, I thought it look amazing then, after looking closly I relized that the grass looks fake.
7/10

 

[Aljam]

Name: <:
Project: Harry's sexy ROM Base.
Credits: Kyledove - Tiles
Comments: Didn't take me so long, for my ROM Base. (:
Mapshot:

Sexy tiles are sexy! but I hate that the tiny rocks are are a lighter shade of brown. maybe darken them? Anyways, 7.5 for teh rates (you can't just give a perfect 10 ;/)

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Need a general opinion on some new inserted tiles I inserted.

Snow Tiles
Credits: Reck (tree tile, grass tile)
Alistair (the path that is in the snow, the far right one, that path is planned to be the deep snow, like the desert tiles in Ruby, where Pokemon attack)
Kyledove (pallette for the mountain, and original tiles)
Jonny Cheevas (Pallettes, and Snow Tiles)
Me (Custom snow on Mountain Edges!)

Notes: I know the tree looks like it doesn't fit. Planned to recolour that, but I will need to look into how the snow looks on trees, so.. Further research needed.

 

[sab]

I sprited these a minute ago tell me what you think. Also I f anyone wants to use them feel free to.

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

I sprited these a minute ago tell me what you think. Also I f anyone wants to use them feel free to.

The tiles seem OK, but the palletes really don't fit. Try something less saturated and bigger differences between the shades of colors.

 

[Pokepal17]

I sprited these a minute ago tell me what you think. Also I f anyone wants to use them feel free to.

They look nice but the palettes need to be less saturated.

Tiles - 8/10
Palettes - 7.5/10

 

[.Tactic.]

Some Tiles and Palletes to rate from my hack...

Cred -
Me(Palletes,House)
Kyledove(tREES)
TB Pro(Trees,Grass)
Alucus of Borg(Mountains)

 

[NarutoActor]

the trees are way to dark green in comparison to the grass.

 

[Zeffy]

I was thinking of changing palettes. What do you guys think?

Credit:
TB Pro: Project Platina Tiles

*NOTE: Do not judge the map ok?*

 

[Tropical Sunlight]

I was thinking of changing palettes. What do you guys think?

Credit:
TB Pro: Project Platina Tiles

*NOTE: Do not judge the map ok?*

Of course we will not judge the map, it's a Tile/Pallete rating thread.

The palletes seem fine, but the grass tile really deserves more attention.
7/10
Flowers look cool.

 

[Pokepal17]

I was thinking of changing palettes. What do you guys think?

Credit:
TB Pro: Project Platina Tiles

*NOTE: Do not judge the map ok?*

The trees and the flowers look nice and give off an aura of peacefulness. However, the grass needs improvement and in a less saturated palette, IMO.

Tiles - 8/10
Palettes - 10/10