{Tile/Palette Rating Thread}

[TB Pro]

Introduction:
The purpose for this thread is so that hackers can post maps with their tiles/palettes here, and we can rate them, so they can know what we all think of their hack's looks. I thought of making this thread when I wanted an opinion of my tiles/palettes for my hack, and I didn't want to make a thread for my hack yet.

Rules:
→ No stealing palettes/tiles, unless they are public, or the maker gives you permission.

→ No posting maps with stolen tiles/palettes.

→ No off-topic posts, or posts without the proper structure.

→ No posting of tiles/palettes that are part of a ROMBase, unless you make MAJOR changes.

→ Don't post just tiles. If you post, make sure you post something that is actually inserted into a ROM.

Posting Structure:
Map Name: The name of your map.

Base ROM: The base this map was made on i.e. Fire Red, Ruby, ect.

Comments: Any comments you have on your map.

Mapshot: The map.

Credits: Who made the tiles,palettes, ect.

Rating Structure:
Map Rated: A quote of the map you are rating.

Rating: The rating you give the tiles/palettes.

Comments: Any comments you have for the maker.

Suggestions: Anything you can suggest for the maker to make the tiles/palettes better.

​

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

This is a great idea.

Map Name: Not really got one...
ROM Base: Firered
Comments... None really. I made this as a test
Mapshot:

Cresits: Kyledove for the tiles and pallettes, me for inserting, Zeikku for the house.

 

[Neti]

So the map itsself (structure, placement, space usage etc) isnt rated, only the tiles and palettes?
thats sweet


Map Name: Doesnt have a name, its not even a real map xD
Rom Base: Firered
Comments: Desert Tiles for my Hack
MapShot:

Credits: Dshayabusa, Serg!o & PHO for some tiles

 

[Hiche..]

Neti, I really like those tiles :D Especially the mountains ^^
I have to rate it right?

Rating: 9/10

 

[cooley]

This is a great idea.

Map Name: Not really got one...
ROM Base: Firered
Comments... None really. I made this as a test
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Cresits: Kyledove for the tiles and pallettes, me for inserting, Zeikku for the house.

Well the palettes are okay, but look a little dead. And the flower palettes don't match up with each other. I also think that the dark part of the mountain is too dark, maybe it should be a darker gray, perhaps?

Overall 8/10

 

[TB Pro]

This is a great idea.

Map Name: Not really got one...
ROM Base: Firered
Comments... None really. I made this as a test
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Cresits: Kyledove for the tiles and pallettes, me for inserting, Zeikku for the house.

I like the tiles, but not the palettes. The palettes are badly made. The tree palettes are just not good. Try changing the darkest color to a lighter color.
Tiles: 9/10
Palettes: 6/10

So the map itsself (structure, placement, space usage etc) isnt rated, only the tiles and palettes?
thats sweet


Map Name: Doesnt have a name, its not even a real map xD
Rom Base: Firered
Comments: Desert Tiles for my Hack
MapShot:

Spoiler:

Credits: Dshayabusa, Serg!o & PHO for some tiles

Whoa! This is great Neti! I really like the variety of buildings you used. I also love the Cubone/Marawak skulls! There is also a great variety in rocks that you used. I also like that you used so many different types of wild grass. Some of the palettes are a bit iffy though. Like the little hut palette, it just looks messed up. So, here's my rating.
Palettes: 7/10
Tiles: 10/10
P.S. Fangking Omega made the majority of those tiles.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Dude, I was actually thinking of making something like this! xD

This is a great idea.

Map Name: Not really got one...
ROM Base: Firered
Comments... None really. I made this as a test
Mapshot:

Spoiler:

Cresits: Kyledove for the tiles and pallettes, me for inserting, Zeikku for the house.

The regular building/house palettes are perfect in my eyes. But the path, and grass palettes are WAY too bright. The mountain palettes are descent, and the tree palettes are pretty funky, but other than that..it's pretty good. So...
Palettes: 7.5/10~

As for the tiles, to me, they are perfect, because Kyledove and Zeikku tiles are really good mixed together. ;D
Tiles: 10/10~

So the map itsself (structure, placement, space usage etc) isnt rated, only the tiles and palettes?
thats sweet


Map Name: Doesnt have a name, its not even a real map xD
Rom Base: Firered
Comments: Desert Tiles for my Hack
MapShot:

Spoiler:

Credits: Dshayabusa, Serg!o & PHO for some tiles

Okay, perfect palettes and tiles..but some problems...

The PokéMart's door palette is, as I said before, really ugly, and bright.
Palettes: 9.5/10~

The tiles are perfect, I also like that little tower at the middle left of the map. It looks good facing diagonally. :)
Though, it's shaped a little weird to me, but...
Tiles: 9.5/10~

 

[Megiddo-san]

Spoiler:

More so palettes xD

 

[Tyrantrum]

Okay, here is the starting map fro Tensai's Secret. (Map isn't final, but this is the Tile/palette rating thread! xD)

Spoiler:

 

[machomuu]

This is a great idea.

Map Name: Not really got one...
ROM Base: Firered
Comments... None really. I made this as a test
Mapshot:

Cresits: Kyledove for the tiles and pallettes, me for inserting, Zeikku for the house.

Palletes 7/10 The rock palletes are kinda freaky.
Tiles 9/10 It has a beautiful nature theme to it.

So the map itsself (structure, placement, space usage etc) isnt rated, only the tiles and palettes?
thats sweet


Map Name: Doesnt have a name, its not even a real map xD
Rom Base: Firered
Comments: Desert Tiles for my Hack
MapShot:

Credits: Dshayabusa, Serg!o & PHO for some tiles

Palletes 9/10 It goes perfectly with the desert theme.
Tiles 8/10 The metal rooms are an eyesore, but still impressive.

Spoiler:

More so palettes xD

Palletes 9/10 They fit the night theme very well.
Tiles 9/10 Work very well with the palletes

Okay, here is the starting map fro Tensai's Secret. (Map isn't final, but this is the Tile/palette rating thread! xD)

Spoiler:

Palletes 9/10 colorful and works with the environment.
Tiles 7/10 the concrete is an eyesore and is also looks like 1st generation.

 

[Darthatron]

More so palettes xD

3/10 for the palettes.

Honestly look at the shadows under the trees, they are completely messed up. Also those paths are WAY too bright. The stairs are too bright as well, but not as obvious. Anyway... Fix those shadows and make everything darker. Then I will rate you decently. :P

 

[Megiddo-san]

Spoiler:

Revision of my previously posted palettes.

 

[Ryousha]

Well people being giving complaints about the paleltes. so i revised alot and was wondering if it's better or not.

 

[/Circa]

This is a great idea.

Map Name: Not really got one...
ROM Base: Firered
Comments... None really. I made this as a test
Mapshot:

Cresits: Kyledove for the tiles and pallettes, me for inserting, Zeikku for the house.

Just asking, but isn't that house kyledoves aswell?

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Just asking, but isn't that house kyledoves aswell?

It says in the credits that it is Zeikkus. It may be replaced with Kyledoves at some point.

 

[Ryousha]

It says in the credits that it is Zeikkus. It may be replaced with Kyledoves at some point.

The House D/P styled is Kyledove, those are the faded version of Kyledoves.

Zeikku's looks like that except with a little size difference and a bolder color.

 

[Aquila]

old tiles

Here's some old tiles I made a while ago(trees only)..

 

[Zeikku™]

The House D/P styled is Kyledove, those are the faded version of Kyledoves.

Zeikku's looks like that except with a little size difference and a bolder color.

Actually, it's not my tile at all it's kyledoves. I'm assuming you guys just used my pallettes, or took my tileset 2 from my rombase.

rate my tiles though

 

[TB Pro]

Actually, it's not my tile at all it's kyledoves. I'm assuming you guys just used my pallettes, or took my tileset 2 from my rombase.

rate my tiles though

As you know, I'm a big fan of your tiles xD
Tiles: 8/10 - The trees look great(except for the short one)! The grasses look nice as well. The signposts look pretty good(ONE IS MINE #@$%(lol(joke))) besides the big blocky one. The buildings look good, especially the gym. The mountains are great! The boulder-ish platina rip is kinda...bad-ish. The water is great(I WAS GONNA DO THAT @#$^(Lool))! The paths are wonderful as well.

Palettes: 9/10 - I like the palettes on everything except the house. It looks a bit dark to me, Idk.

 

[0m3ga_S1nn3r]

Actually, it's not my tile at all it's kyledoves. I'm assuming you guys just used my pallettes, or took my tileset 2 from my rombase.

rate my tiles though

These are... as I say... WONDERFULLYMAGNIFICENT
10/10

Well people being giving complaints about the paleltes. so i revised alot and was wondering if it's better or not.

Everythings is good except for the rocks... they look a bit corrupted.
7-8/10