4th Gen Totodile? Cyndaquil? or Chikorita

[Caelus]

Ever since I first played Silver I've always liked Cyndaquil. I used to like Totodile most, since its water and they're almost always my favorite, but I found Cyndaquil and its evolution to be the easiest to use.

 

[indyracer500]

my vote tied totodile and cyndaquil lol

im gonna go with totodile. cyndaquils cool and all, but totodile ftw!!

 

[ShinyMeganium]

Why making the same poll 1000 times?
Chikorita. That's my second favorite starter out of the 12 (first is Charmander). Would be awesome to see how it follows you and stuff, and would be even more awesome to see how stronger it became with the new moves/features of 3rd-4th gen, in it's home region.

 

[blue]

HG

LOL, Totodile & Cyndaquil are Drawing with 22 Each

 

[Empty Pot]

-shakes head- Why do we get so many of these...

Anyways, I am going to choose Cyndaquil considering it makes Silver have Totadile like in PokeSpe.

 

[☆Rei☆]

Cyndaquil!
It's good against alot of gyms but I struggle with Clair.

 

[Retro Bug]

Cyndaquil, I just like it's looks. [:
Even though I love water types, but I always pick the fire types, well not in D/P/Pt.

 

[Mew~]

Tatodile ALL THE WAY MAN!!!!!

 

[moac]

I think Ill start with chikorita . I might not evolve it. Ill have a perma chikorita. its the cutest in its first evolve stage<3

 

[Cнαяcнιc]

I like them all :]

Chikorita is the cutest, but Cyndaquil is the best...and evolves to be the most powerful. I like Totodile, hate the evolutions though :/

Charchic.

 

[SuperLightning]

gotta be totodile. it has its own style and kinda disapates from the other 2. i mean the others are considered cute while
totodile would be considered awesome looking. Also he would have an advatage in battle.

so in short TOTODILE FOR THE WIN

 

[Guns]

Wow surprised cyn is winning back in 2nd gen times me and my cousins/friends would all choose totodile.

 

[Equus]

I'm going to choose Totodile as I always have. It's the only non-Grass Starter I've ever chosen.

My first choice is Totodile, and if not Totodile, I'd choose Chikorita. I've never really liked Cyndaquil as much as the other two

 

[Fenrir Reki]

Im going to use Cyndaquil as my first choice because he was my starter in silver. Tododile would be next, then chikorita.

 

[TheReal]

I'll choose Totodile like I did in silver, it's the only non-fire starter that I choose. I didn't like cyndaquil, but I still prefer it than chikorita.

 

[Chrono]

Totodile or Cyndaquil for me : P

 

[KitFox]

Ill pick cyndaquil, love fire starter pokemon

 

[Soul Silver]

I picked totodile but I really like cyndaquil as well might go with him because he was my first choice when I got the original Silver version...

But in truth I really want both, plus there is a few real good water options handed to you in the second generation (Suicune & Red Gyarados)

 

[ckn]

i'll be picking cyndaquil ^!TYPHLOSION!^ then i'll jusr get totodile and chikorita throug trades ^^

 

[King of Boos]

I chose Cyndaquil in Silver so I'm not gonna make a change this time around either.

Chikorita is prolly the worst to chose from since you have to face a flyin gym and a bug gym early in the game.