pkmin3033
Guest
- 0
- Posts
Actually, I'm quite willing to acknowledge XY Ash's feats - my point, if you could be bothered to actually read my posts properly just once - is that DP Ash was up against significantly stronger opponents, and that should be taken into account when measuring their strength, because otherwise its a grossly inaccurate representation of their actual strength. Tobias had LEGENDARIES. Alain had just a Mega Charizard X. Pretty big difference in strength there.And you keep downplaying XY Ash's feats to make DP Ash look good.
But going back to the actual topic at hand, if you want to compare XY Ash with Paul, you need to take into account Paul's level of strength at the time he faced Ash in DP and, most importantly, what he took away from that final battle. He would have grown in much the same way Gary grew after losing back in Johto, and Gary's Electivire demolished Pikachu fresh after it beat a Regice. You think Paul wouldn't have Mega Evolution too, or that he wouldn't have other stronger, better Pokemon? You can't just take him straight out of DP as he was and compare him to XY Ash, who is in a completely different place...not necessarily a better one, but that's another topic entirely.
Paul lost solely because he gave up Chimchar, and the Infernape/Electivire battle was very close. He lost by a narrow margin to prove a point. No such restraints if he comes up against XY Ash, and prior to that last battle Paul had always come out on top. He probably would again.