Croconaw changed to Totodile. ;) Next time just PM a mod or higher to edit the poll for you, no problem!
As for the poll itself, that's such a tough question! I think I might have to say Charmander. Out of all the starters I've had, it's the one where I actually like all of its evolutions. I love Charmander, I like Charmeleon and I love Charizard.
With all the other starters I've had (Totodile, Torchic, Piplup), there have been parts of it's evolution line that I just didn't like. I didn't like Feraligatr, I didn't like Combusken, I didn't like any of Piplup's evolutions... and as for any other starters that I didn't personally pick? The same thing with them. XD; So Charmander wins overall.