Map Rating/Review Thread

[Disturbed]

@itman1234
Let's be realistic, if you picture a mountain, or a really rocky area, wouldn't it have a bunch of rocks all over the place? Thanks for the comments though, I'm improving my cave now. Also, as soon as you exit your house, oak brings you to the cave and gives you your pokemon. So, no glitches :P



...my new map, you know nothing of.. I hope, except for megiddo, he knows.

Spoiler:

I'm just that tricky.

 

[.Iramet]

map

map name-nothing yet
comments-please don't not rate it because its not from one of the regulars^_^

 

[KhaosKnight]

Well i give it a 8.9

Why: I like the snowy tiles, everything looks ok, but that cave opening is really oddly placed...try to find some space to make special for a cave opening(thats what i do anyway unless it is just a one room item cave) but other than that is is ok.

 

[.Iramet]

~jaw drops~
my first good comment!thank you so much for this you are awesome KK!
Heres another map.

 

[Tyrantrum]

The route, is, way too small, too plain, too empty, the mountains are weird, nothing to block up from getting to the border line.
1.4/10

 

[Binary]

~jaw drops~
my first good comment!thank you so much for this you are awesome KK!
Heres another map.

Rating: 7/10
Reason: I like the map. It looks simple and nice. But you also have to take note of the border. You can get outside the border on that map. So you have to prevent that.

 

[Disturbed]

@itman1234
Let's be realistic, if you picture a mountain, or a really rocky area, wouldn't it have a bunch of rocks all over the place? Thanks for the comments though, I'm improving my cave now. Also, as soon as you exit your house, oak brings you to the cave and gives you your pokemon. So, no glitches :P



...my new map, you know nothing of.. I hope, except for megiddo, he knows.

Spoiler:

I'm just that tricky.

rate please?

 

[Sgt. Custard]

Hmm... No-one rated my map, so here it is again...

 

[.Iramet]

Rating: 7/10
Reason: I like the map. It looks simple and nice. But you also have to take note of the border. You can get outside the border on that map. So you have to prevent that.

thanks cell heres that map with the border fixed.

 

[Tony the Awesome]

My Map:

Game: Doofation hack of Firered
Comments: Tiles added by Zeikku and TB Pro

 

[+Sneasel™]

My Map:

Game: Doofation hack of Firered
Comments: Tiles added by Zeikku and TB Pro

Rating 8/10
Its really really crammed together. Space the houses out a bit more. Also, a tile error on the wood fence.

 

[Makorin]

if someone could please rate these cuz i need 2 no if im doing anything wrong or if u people like 'em or wat...

Anyway Here are two maps by me!

Map Name: Frotus Town

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: I made this map for my Hack Fire Red Legends. I shall say tht though the border may look as if it would be messed up i had chang the height of the border to 4 and the width stays 2 (so it a 2-by-4 border) and the tree pallet may look messed up but i changed it along with the flowers

Mapshot:

and the other

Map Name: Platnium City

Map Game: Fire Red

Comments: Same as above

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[maoh4567]

@itman1234
Let's be realistic, if you picture a mountain, or a really rocky area, wouldn't it have a bunch of rocks all over the place? Thanks for the comments though, I'm improving my cave now. Also, as soon as you exit your house, oak brings you to the cave and gives you your pokemon. So, no glitches :P



...my new map, you know nothing of.. I hope, except for megiddo, he knows.

Spoiler:

I'm just that tricky.

6/10.. There's an empty space, i dont like that in a map. I dont like the arrangement of flowers. i also dont like the placement of the little vegetation in the bottom part whereas it mixes up w/ the trees but i do like the placement of the trees in the left part.
Suggestions:Fill up the empty spaces

 

[Golden Shaymin]

Ok here's one that I just made:

Spoiler:

 

[Geeked]

Hmm... No-one rated my map, so here it is again...

Well, your map is fairly empty, and there are a bunch of house tile errors, are you just beggining?
6.2/10

My Map:

Game: Doofation hack of Firered
Comments: Tiles added by Zeikku and TB Pro

8D, I love this map, I actually like when things are cramped!
8.3/10

 

[UltramasterBDX]

xD
Well, just another New Barktown <3

Greetings, xD

 

[Makorin]

My Map:

Game: Doofation hack of Firered
Comments: Tiles added by Zeikku and TB Pro

Looks nice
I mostly like tiles but the placing is good not the best but good...
very well done i give you a 8.5/10 :D

 

[Disturbed]

I was skipped over 3 times? What is this!?

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

Heh heh heh. 5 maps!

 

[Golden Shaymin]

if someone could please rate these cuz i need 2 no if im doing anything wrong or if u people like 'em or wat...

I'd love to rate this but there's no pictures

 

[.:God:.]

xD
Well, just another New Barktown <3

Greetings, xD

What... the... ****...
Is this even Pokemon?