• Just a reminder that providing specifics on, sharing links to, or naming websites where ROMs can be accessed is against the rules. If your post has any of this information it will be removed.
  • Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • It's time to vote for your favorite Pokémon Battle Revolution protagonist in our new weekly protagonist poll! Click here to cast your vote and let us know which PBR protagonist you like most.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Map Rating/Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just a couple of things to everyone out there, just because there is a space in the border, it doesn't mean you can get through it. Try it out. If you have trees in the border there won't be any problem.
 
This is to Maraudah, it didn't say that I was replying to him though.

Your first map
7.9/10
This is a pretty great map. The house without a door looks a bit out of place and the mountain area seems to big but that might just be me. Apart from that though, its great! The path is also great.

Maybe try making the door-less house look a bit more in place. And maybe make the mountain area smaller (its probably just me though so don't worry about it.)

Your second map
6.4/10
The first house doesn't look long enough, the second one looks too tall and the thir done looks a bit crammed. Also the path on the right looks a bit wide. The cave looks a tiny bit out of place. The path is pretty good.

Make the first house wider, add windows (if possible) to the second story of the second house and try to mak ethe thir done look less crammed. Also try and make the path to the right less wide and try to make the cave fit in more.

Your third map
I'm not good at rating these types of maps so sorry but I can't rate it.

Your fourth map
9.5/10
This is great! The craters arn't crammed, the rocks arn't too close to eachother. Ummm, I can't find anything bad. So I'll have to end this here.

Can't think of anything to improve.

Your fifth map
8.7/10
The buildings are in good positions except except the really thin one. The path is good. The trees are all scattered around well. The cave is a bit close to the water though.

Either move or get rid of the really thin one & move the cave away from the water.

You don't have to follow any of my advice. My advice isn't that good.
 
Last edited:
Maraudah said:
I was skipped over 3 times? What is this!?

Spoiler:


Spoiler:


Spoiler:


Spoiler:


Spoiler:



Heh heh heh. 5 maps!
Click to expand...

1st Map: 7/10 Well the vegetation is placed well, but im not sure where the water comes from, and it seems like there's no much flower. Try also adding a window in your doorless house.

2nd Map: I've rated this map..

3rd Map: 8/10 There's an empty space in the south-east part. I wont mind the quantity of the rocks you placed, maybe because, you're right about what you've said about itman1234.

4th Map: 6/10 Its better than before ^^ .. I think its better if you add more levels

5th Map: 7/10 Pls remove the squashed house near the cave entrance. There's also a tile error in the edges of the river
 
Nine-Tailed Assassin said:
here is my very first map its the hero's home town

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
Click to expand...

Sorry man, I give it a 2/10.
Why?: It's plain, the grass looks like a carpet how it's placed, tile error on the long grass on (i think it's meant to be on) the mountain, square, nothing blocks you from going through the border, tile error in the flower baskets, and since when is there a gym/ pokecenter in the first town?!
(the last one is a oppinion.)

Sugfestions: fill it up with trees and flowers and such, fix the tile errors, don't make it square, try multiple grass tiles and don't use just 1. Read a mapping tutorial, that can help you out.
 
deadlyangel91792 said:
hello guys anyone gonna rate it i just starting making maps heres one of my first few please watch it and rate
Click to expand...

not gonna rate till you post a image cause it's impossible to find tile errors in a video.
 
maybe it is an rmxp map, i think the tiles used in those rpg make stuff are double size
 
Neti said:
maybe it is an rmxp map, i think the tiles used in those rpg make stuff are double size
Click to expand...
Nope, these are rpg maker vx tiles.
xD

Btw, ich habe die recolord und im rom eingebaut ;3
Aber naja, der platz ist begrenzt o.O

----------------------->

--
 
Nine-Tailed Assassin said:
here is my very first map its the hero's home town

[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
Click to expand...

I'm srry but i have 2 give it a 0.5/10
It's way to plain it doesn't even have a boarder in the map!
way 2 many rocks around the "mountain"
grass in a town is a no go (unless it has purpose)
Gym in starting town is kinda wierd but thts just me!
the grass on the "mountain" is wierd looking...
the path could be narrower
and thts it!
 
Well Here are two maps by me

Map Name: Frotus Town
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: I made this map for my Hack Fire Red Legends. The border may look as if it is messed up but i changed the height of the border to 4 blocks and I changed the tree pallet and the flower pallet
Mapshot:
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread



Map Name: Platnium City
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: I made this map for my Hack Fire Red Legends.
Mapshot:
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread
 
Spoiler:

Please rate =D

Map Name: Hugelheim
Comments: Well, I'm starting to improve my hack wit new tiles and palettes and well...
thats one map that came out after a bit editing.
 
D a n i e l said:
Spoiler:

Please rate =D

Map Name: Hugelheim
Comments: Well, I'm starting to improve my hack wit new tiles and palettes and well...
thats one map that came out after a bit editing.
Click to expand...

Hmm, a very nice map. (There must be a cave to the west of the map!)
I suggest using a variety of houses, instead of the starter house 3 times, and maybe getting rid of some of the small trees that are cluttering up the space around and behind the houses. Other than that, good job.
9/10
 
Heh.... New maps, finally...

Map name: Tripletwig Town
Map:
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

Comments: please don't rate the palletes, they need fixing
Credits: Alistair for what should be his tree tiles

EDIT: I know about the tile error on the roof of the upper right house, it's already fixed. And I don't feel like uploading maps :)
 
IceCharizard said:
Heh.... New maps, finally...

Map name: Tripletwig Town
Map:
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

Comments: please don't rate the palletes, they need fixing
Credits: Alistair for what should be his tree tiles

EDIT: I know about the tile error on the roof of the upper right house, it's already fixed. And I don't feel like uploading maps :)
Click to expand...
Nice map IC
Ill give it a... 7.5/10
It does seem kinda qauint but tree placement is good
and I think thts it
 
IceCharizard said:
Heh.... New maps, finally...

Map name: Tripletwig Town
Map:
[PokeCommunity.com] Map Rating/Review Thread

Comments: please don't rate the palletes, they need fixing
Credits: Alistair for what should be his tree tiles

EDIT: I know about the tile error on the roof of the upper right house, it's already fixed. And I don't feel like uploading maps :)
Click to expand...
Rating: 8.5/10
Reason: It's a nice and simple map. I like the placement of trees and the houses. Some empty gaps there. But it looks nice.
Suggestions: Probably make a nicer path and fill up the empty gaps.
 
Looks pretty good, a little empty though...
I give it...
5.7/10
It's pretty good, just fill up the empty spaces.
Awesome tiles though! Where'd you get them?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top