Map Rating/Review Thread

[Dratii]

Okay here is my new map:

Map Name: Mt. Something
Rom: FR
Comments: Here is a mountain (inside) I made. Took me about 2hrs.

Spoiler:

 

[Neti]

Okay here is my new map:

Map Name: Mt. Something
Rom: FR
Comments: Here is a mountain (inside) I made. Took me about 2hrs.

Spoiler:

brillinat map, not many ppl manage to create such natural looking mountains with a lot of highlights such as sand, rocks, crates and sources
anyway you could have added more rocks ON the path, not only at the sides
and at some places you should have made it a bit tighter
but still a great map
rating: 8.5/10

edit: I felt like posting a map...

Map Name: Dahai
Base: FireRed (Frozen RomBase)
Game: Pokemon Legend of Fenju
Mapshot:

Comments: Some people call it "Silver Wing City". When coming here, you got to visit the public pool or the famous Pokemon Lab!

bte, dont send me any maps for the review anymore, ive already written it^^
and from the next week on the review will always be about the map of the week winner

 

[Sarcastic Prince]

Good map, Neti.

No improvments needed.

9.4/10. (No one's perfect)

 

[Hiche..]

brillinat map, not many ppl manage to create such natural looking mountains with a lot of highlights such as sand, rocks, crates and sources
anyway you could have added more rocks ON the path, not only at the sides
and at some places you should have made it a bit tighter
but still a great map
rating: 8.5/10

edit: I felt like posting a map...

Map Name: Dahai
Base: FireRed (Frozen RomBase)
Game: Pokemon Legend of Fenju
Mapshot:

Comments: Some people call it "Silver Wing City". When coming here, you got to visit the public pool or the famous Pokemon Lab!

bte, dont send me any maps for the review anymore, ive already written it^^
and from the next week on the review will always be about the map of the week winner

That's an amazing map. No tile errors, the trees are well placed, and mostly I love how you did the path. Only add some small trees or normal trees on the upper left of the map.
Comment: Legend of Fenju will be a great hack. :D
Rating: 9.5/10

 

[Neti]

That's an amazing map. No tile errors, the trees are well placed, and mostly I love how you did the path. Only add some small trees or normal trees on the upper left of the map.
Comment: Legend of Fenju will be a great hack. :D
Rating: 9.5/10

if i add trees there, you wont be able to leave the map to the north anymore^^
or do you mean just make the pat ha bit tighter?
thx for the good rating anyway^^

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Great map Neti. 8.5/10
The map's great, as well as the shape of the trees, path and whatnot, but the mountains follow the same path in some places. Also, it's annoying to walk along diagonal paths...Meh.

 

[Hiche..]

if i add trees there, you wont be able to leave the map to the north anymore^^
or do you mean just make the pat ha bit tighter?
thx for the good rating anyway^^

I meant to make the path a bit tighter :D
But it's up to you.
Your welcome too.

 

[zetavares85]

I recreated the palletes for the snow to make it brighter, and I have recreated the ground road into a snowish, and I have added a snow bush, and a snowish long bush thing.

C&C, also rate ^^

Good map, but why there isn't snow on the top of the buildings ?
Do you know where there are flowers in a place full of snow ?
Why did you put a Gym roof on a Lab ?

Except for this it's a very beautiful map.
Rating 8/10

Map Name: New Bark Town
Game: Firered
Comment:Custom Tiles by Frario credit to him. Well?
View attachment 37227

Are you talking serious about this map ?
It's not New bark Town.
There's not a single fence in the original map, and this is just the first mistake.
-No windows in the small houses,
-The roofs should be green
-Just 2 flowers
-What about the headbuttable trees ?
-There isn't that place behind the player's house
-You mixed Hoenn's ground (dark green) with Kanto's ground (light green).
-The light green ground should be on the left side of the lab, around the sign, and behind the right small house.

Just a tip: Go to Google images, search for New Bark Town, and LOOK at the original one to do your map.

Rating: -1/10

 

[Surf]

Well heres the map for a route i made

i am aware of the tile errors on the stairs
credits to pounder_zenkku for the base

 

[loitraitim]

Ok! Make new map (hje)...
Map Name: Azure Town
Base: FireRed
Game: Pokemon Never B & W
Mapshot:

Please comment and vote for it ^^!

 

[Tyrantrum]

Ok! Make new map (hje)...
Map Name: Azure Town
Base: FireRed
Game: Pokemon Never B & W
Mapshot:

Please comment and vote for it ^^!

Sorry, new maps have been added hours ago! :P

Anyways:
Rating: 7.8/10
Errors: It still seems a little too square to me, and there are a few empty spots. I also don't really like what you did with the path near the Elite Four Building.
Suggestions: Fix what I just said. xD
Comments: This is still quite a nice map, and after seeing your other maps, I look forward to seeing more maps by you.

 

[negative]

I guess I got left out :(
PLease rate everything exept the palette glich in the water grass!

 

[Likewise]

credit to fenderX and Alistar for the rom base.

 

[Pheya]

I guess I got left out :(
PLease rate everything exept the palette glich in the water grass!

Rating: 9/10
Errors: I think you could fill it up a bit more at the upper left corner, but it still looks good.
Suggestions: Already told you. ;]

 

[Geeked]

Map Name: Undecided
Map Game: Pokemon Crimson Version
Map Shot:

 

[+Sneasel™]

Map Name: Undecided
Map Game: Pokemon Crimson Version
Map Shot:

Good map overall, a few tile errors (mostly with the trees' shadows).
Rating: 8/10
Suggestions: Its only an 8 cause of the errors + I think closed houses look very very ugly, i think you should make a door, and make a 'door is locked script' instead.

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

A new map by me.. not to good to be honest..

 

[Hiche..]

A new map by me.. not to good to be honest..

No actually this is not a bad map. I only don't how the mountain is shaped..too empty
But everything else is good.
Rating: 7.7/10

 

[Neti]

No actually this is not a bad map. I only don't how the mountain is shaped..too crowded.
But everything else is good.
Rating: 7.7/10

In my opinion the mountain is too empty, not too crowded...
but youre talking about the shape, its kinda good, even though it could be done better with more details

 

[Hiche..]

In my opinion the mountain is too empty, not too crowded...
but youre talking about the shape, its kinda good, even though it could be done better with more details

oops. I meant too empty.. sorry about that. I'll edit my post.
The path where you walk on (the mountain) is kind of empty. I only don't like a part of the mountain's shape(the middle mountain were there is four blocks over each other)