Map Rating/Review Thread

[Chimchar 9]

rombase : fire red
credits : kyledove

map 1:

map2:



please rate !

 

[Tyrantrum]

Map 1: Very nice. I see no tile errors, just some empty space.
9/10~

Map 2: You seem to be doing better with the mountains on both maps. ;D
It's great, but also some empty space.
9.3/10~

 

[.Seth]

Well, here goes...

ROM: FireRed
Map:

*Saved as JPEG to prevent theft.*

Info: Just a town I've made. Not really much else to say. Yes, that is a rock hill in the middle.

Please and Thank You for rating. :)

Credits:
Kyledove: For the tiles

 

[Mages4ever]

I like it, but I can't rate because I know nothing, but I like that building.

 

[Sarcastic Prince]

Good map, Seth-Kuh.

It's really good!!

No Tile Errors!!

9.4/10!!

 

[.Iramet]

Well, here goes...

ROM: FireRed
Map:

*Saved as JPEG to prevent theft.*

Info: Just a town I've made. Not really much else to say. Yes, that is a rock hill in the middle.

Please and Thank You for rating. :)

Credits:
Kyledove: For the tiles

OK first off I hate those tiles the palettes destroy my eyes!
But I'm not gonna rate the map on those tiles.
How come their is a waterfall for such a small amount of water?
Wouldn't the top just empty out?
And there is no visible land route out of this place. :/
BUt I suppose their could be an underground tunnels from one of the houses.
With this being said I rate your map...a 6/10.

 

[Disturbed]

rombase : fire red
credits : kyledove

map 1:

Rating: 6/10
Reason: Kyle, I think you are just being lazy now. Sorry if I sound mean, but look outside, it isn't the same tree over and over again. So you might want to get onto the block edittor, and with all those border trees, lose half of them and add a diversity of trees.
map2:

please rate !

Rating: 7/10
Reason: Same as above... your just being lazy :( Overall, if you fix that up, this is easily a 9.5

Well, here goes...

ROM: FireRed
Map:

*Saved as JPEG to prevent theft.*

Info: Just a town I've made. Not really much else to say. Yes, that is a rock hill in the middle.

Please and Thank You for rating. :)

Credits:
Kyledove: For the tiles

Rating: 3/10
Reason: The only thing I like about this map, is honestly, the shape of the rock. The overall shape of this map is square, the diversity of trees is horrid around the border, the waterfall is all one big tile error (see cape brink) and there is no exit. Yeah, I'm downgrading you for no exit, because if their was an underground tunnel, you would need to mention that. I deeply apologize, but this map needs ALOT of work.

 

[Hiche..]

rombase : fire red
credits : kyledove

map 1:

map2:



please rate !

Both map are wonderful.
Although, putting different trees seem better.
No tile errors. Very well done.
Rating(1): 8.2/10
Rating(2): 9/10

 

[.Iramet]

Map name: none yet
Map game: FIrered
Comments: Please rate.

 

[Mages4ever]

Map name: none yet
Map game: Firered
Comments: Please rate.

I give it a 8.5/10.
(First rate)

No Tile errors From what I see.
Nice layout.
Only 1 connection though.
Also, whats with the 2 hops?

 

[Likewise]

[URL=https://img293.imageshack.us/my.php?image=wowmo7.png][/URL]
credit to avatar ryan for the rom base
click the image on the imageshack website for better quality.

 

[Disturbed]

[URL="https://img293.imageshack.us/my.php?image=wowmo7.png"][/URL]
credit to avatar ryan for the rom base
click the image on the imageshack website for better quality.

Rating: 5/10
Reason: well, I think that this is your best map, but looking at it, I counted around 24 tile errors. The shape of the rock could use some improvement too.

 

[.Iramet]

I give it a 8.5/10.
(First rate)

No Tile errors From what I see.
Nice layout.
Only 1 connection though.
Also, whats with the 2 hops?

Thanks for the rating I don't get to many of these.
XD
Are you a mapper?
@ Elements~ map: I think it looks awesome but there are a lot of tile errors...I'll pretend I don't see them.
With errors 5/10
Without errors 8.4/10

 

[cooley]

[Map Name]
Rainier Town

[Map Game]
Pokemon FireRed(BPRE) - Pokemon Eruption Map ;)

[Map Shot]

[Map Comments]
It will be the third town you will have traveled, to and from out of 7(completed)

[Addtional Comments]
Give feedback, Eruption's almost here, so...I need to fix it up, and make it as good as possible ;)

P.S. I love CSS :P

 

[Mages4ever]

[Map Name]
Rainier Town

[Map Game]
Pokemon FireRed(BPRE) - Pokemon Eruption Map ;)

[Map Shot]

[Map Comments]
It will be the third town you will have traveled, to and from out of 7(completed)

[Addtional Comments]
Give feedback, Eruption's almost here, so...I need to fix it up, and make it as good as possible ;)

P.S. I love CSS :P

No rate here, but a question. What is with the grey tiles as the path, it doesn't really match IMO.

@emoakt

Not really. Map in my spare time, I learn from people.

 

[Tyrantrum]

[Map Name]
Rainier Town

[Map Game]
Pokemon FireRed(BPRE) - Pokemon Eruption Map ;)

[Map Shot]

[Map Comments]
It will be the third town you will have traveled, to and from out of 7(completed)

[Addtional Comments]
Give feedback, Eruption's almost here, so...I need to fix it up, and make it as good as possible ;)

P.S. I love CSS :P

*cough*CSSfreak*cough*

Rating: 7.3/10~
Errors: Well, the mountain shape is odd, too symmetrical, it's also very empty. The houses at the bottom with no windows and/or doors disturbs me a little. There are a couple empty spots on the grass too.
Suggestions: Fill in the empty spots, and fix up the shape of the mountain.
Comments: I love how you blended the trees with the street tiles, as well as the rocks with the street, looks very nice!

 

[TB Pro]

Hey, haven't posted here in awhile. I just finished with palettes and tiles. So without Further Adeu.

Map Name: Thunder Path

Game: Onyx

Base ROM: Ruby

Credits: Me - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles, Saurav - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 1:00

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

 

[Dratii]

¿TB Pro™ I give your map 7.8/10

Because the blue spots look weird and un-natural and the trees blend in with the grass too much

Suggestions: remove the blue spots (if they are not important) make the tree/grass areas a bit less "crowded".

Other comments: Nice variety of trees and good map shape.


Now one from me:

Map Name: City two
Rom: FR
Comments: Map 3 from me. And dont rate the bottom part (has been fixed)

Spoiler:

 

[Satoshi Sugimori]

Hey, haven't posted here in awhile. I just finished with palettes and tiles. So without Further Adeu.

Map Name: Thunder Path

Game: Onyx

Base ROM: Ruby

Credits: Me - Tiles, Kyledove - Tiles, Alistair - Tiles, Saurav - Tiles

Mapping Time: Around 1:00

Mapshot:

Spoiler:

All the colors make it hard for m eyes to concentrate on the map XD lolz
It looks pretty nice but The little puddles annoy me theyre a bit unnececary and they are too dark if you look at the other tiles there is much grass and some big open spots.. But everything seems to be placed very thoughtfull My rating: 7.9/10

¿TB Pro™ I give your map 7.8/10

Because the blue spots look weird and un-natural and the trees blend in with the grass too much

Suggestions: remove the blue spots (if they are not important) make the tree/grass areas a bit less "crowded".

Other comments: Nice variety of trees and good map shape.


Now one from me:

Map Name: City two
Rom: FR
Comments: Map 3 from me. And dont rate the bottom part (has been fixed)

Spoiler:

Hmm the other ones where better to be honest it's very empty and very blocky you should fill it up or something or make the map smaller... My rating:5/10

 

[Zeikku™]

TB pro I'll give your map an 8/10
it works well I just dislike the circular puddles