PMD: Explorers of Sky Mafia

[Miah]

I think it's either the Nurse healed the NK, or they roleblocked the killer?

If the Nurse was the one that stopped the kill, that is

 

[impulse~]

does that mean if wigglytuff didnt protect anyone someone would be defeated? and if someone were defeated, would we know who they really were?

 

[gimmepie]

I know you think the kill was idled, but it could have been our doctor, right?

Flavour text implies it was a missed kill imo

 

[Kitty]

missed kill? so an inactive person or someone new then

 

[jdthebud]

Alright, let's the ball rolling.

[Vote] BidoofFTW

C'mon speak up.

 

[Kitty]

[vote] xDestroy
targeting the ones i have no idea about really
it's pretty much random

 

[Syndrome]

I really have nothing relevant to add to the discussion as this is day 1 and everything I could've said has already been touched on, so here's my random vote until we get some new info

[Vote] Nakuzaami

 

[impulse~]

[Vote] Miah

 

[Bidoof FTW]

I agree about a miss in inactivity over a doc save, mostly because the post said "because nothing happened" a doc save is pretty much the opposite of nothing happening.

With that, I'd have a lean on xDestroy or Miah, but I feel like this is a pretty meta decision to make a vote off of.

Other than that, do we want dreamer to out early? or wait?

EDIT: I'd probably vote to wait on dreamer reveal because 6/2/1 is a pretty generous ratio, especially with a missed day 1 kill.

 

[Miah]

:thonk:

I think it would be too early for the dreamer to reveal, since it's still day 1 and we don't have a lot of players, so...

also omgus x
[Vote] impulse~

 

[Trev]

flavor text shouldnot be read into nor will it confirm or deny anything

 

[gimmepie]

He says despite his flavour text having very real connotations smh

Anyway, I think it's worth noting I like jd and Doof2's posts so far. It's early days yet but they're looking pretty townie to me. Unfortunately though, I haven't seen much in the way of suspicious activity either. I'm going to throw a vote at Miah based off nothing more than a shaky gut feeling on this one. I am aware that they've already been voted for, but I think there's little point in trying to spread it so there's no doubling up.

[Vote] Miah

 

[jdthebud]

He says despite his flavour text having very real connotations smh

Anyway, I think it's worth noting I like jd and Doof2's posts so far. It's early days yet but they're looking pretty townie to me. Unfortunately though, I haven't seen much in the way of suspicious activity either. I'm going to throw a vote at Miah based off nothing more than a shaky gut feeling on this one. I am aware that they've already been voted for, but I think there's little point in trying to spread it so there's no doubling up.

[Vote] Miah

This better not be another attempt at a sneaky mafia play GP, given how the last one turned out, lol.

[Unvote] BidoofFTW

[Vote] Nakuzami

Hoping this vote works as well as my previous one on Bidoof.

 

[gimmepie]

This better not be another attempt at a sneaky mafia play GP, given how the last one turned out, lol.

Never again.

 

[Miah]

Anyway, I think it's worth noting I like jd and Doof2's posts so far. It's early days yet but they're looking pretty townie to me. Unfortunately though, I haven't seen much in the way of suspicious activity either. I'm going to throw a vote at Miah based off nothing more than a shaky gut feeling on this one. I am aware that they've already been voted for, but I think there's little point in trying to spread it so there's no doubling up.

[Vote] Miah

I think just because people contribute a lot to the discussion, or "are being townie", doesn't necessarily mean they're town. For example, someone may seem very townie but they might actually be mafia or third party. There have been instances in which maf acted very much like town. See Bard in Birb Mafia; he contributed a lot in the discussion, but in the end, he was actually maf.

Also, care to explain why it's a "shaky" gut feeling?

 

[gimmepie]

I think just because people contribute a lot to the discussion, or "are being townie", doesn't necessarily mean they're town. For example, someone may seem very townie but they might actually be mafia or third party. There have been instances in which maf acted very much like town. See Bard in Birb Mafia; he contributed a lot in the discussion, but in the end, he was actually maf.

Also, care to explain why it's a "shaky" gut feeling?

I am the last person you need to tell that first part to :p

It's shaky because I'm not totally sure about it.

 

[Miah]

Oh alright, was just speaking my heart out :joy:

 

[Nakuzami]

Alright, let's the ball rolling.

yes Wrecking Ball is here hi

[Vote] Nakuzami

Hoping this vote works as well as my previous one on Bidoof.

it didn't


also in context of flavor text literally all it said was that nothing happened because no one died. instantly assuming it was from inactive maf---you think the entire maf went inactive on night zero?---is probably not a good use of thought. Possible? Yeah. Likely? Not really, more likely that the nurse targeted correctly considering they had a fairly slim selection of targets.

Perhaps a better question is, who is likely to have been targeted by both the nurse and mafia on night zero? If that's what happened, and we figure that out, could potentially clear someone fairly easily. Only thing it's contingent on is whether a single maf member carries out the kill (and thus makes it blockable if the nurse targets that maf member) or not

 

[jdthebud]

yes Wrecking Ball is here hi


it didn't


also in context of flavor text literally all it said was that nothing happened because no one died. instantly assuming it was from inactive maf---you think the entire maf went inactive on night zero?---is probably not a good use of thought. Possible? Yeah. Likely? Not really, more likely that the nurse targeted correctly considering they had a fairly slim selection of targets.

Perhaps a better question is, who is likely to have been targeted by both the nurse and mafia on night zero? If that's what happened, and we figure that out, could potentially clear someone fairly easily. Only thing it's contingent on is whether a single maf member carries out the kill (and thus makes it blockable if the nurse targets that maf member) or not

The kill being blocked is theoretically possible. Not sure if Trev can confirm that can happen or not though.

 

[Miah]

Well

flavor text shouldnot be read into nor will it confirm or deny anything

Also I don't like getting D1'd but who does, really.

[Unvote] impulse~

[Vote] xDestroy