Bidoof's Beginner Mafia: An Intro Game [Mafia Wins!]

[Syndrome]

I specifically asked Saws why he voted for the same person as me immediately after I voted, and all he did was echo basically everything I said. That seems more like an issue of him not being able to form his own opinion.

 

[Sawsbuck]

I did not sheep Syn, I looked at the arguments and made my decision based on that.
I voted Calzone D1 because most people suggested that it would be bad if we didn't lynch anyone. Mars claimed that we might hit a villager, but whether it was the right call or not we don't know yet
I voted Neon because there weren't any better options and as I said before, Tail's reaction to Mars' case is hard to read, and Neon is the most suspicious at the moment.
A lot of this is still confusing to me, but I'm still contributing what I can

 

[Mars]

I specifically asked Saws why he voted for the same person as me immediately after I voted, and all he did was echo basically everything I said. That seems more like an issue of him not being able to form his own opinion.

Ok, so we're now in the second half of Day Two, and we have 7 players left. Two of them have not voted yet in this game, so if they do not vote tonight, then they are removed anyway, so at this time I see no reason to vote for either Neon Sword or Calzone407. If Neon does vote tonight, my vote will switch to Neon, because the rather sporadic activity has got my attention as well.

Among the rest of us...I am not entirely sure, but Saws was probably going to be my third choice after Neon and Mars. For me it's rather hard to figure out who might be what right now. What I am more interested in is the possible scenario that both Calzone and Neon are in fact town. If that is true, then the mafia wins in Night Two unless the kill is blocked by the Doctor if it is still around. So my voting in probably a few hours from now (rather, I might have to make a final vote on my part in a couple of hours since I'll be gone most of the day), is going to assume there's one or two active mafia members.

I did not sheep Syn, I looked at the arguments and made my decision based on that.
I voted Calzone D1 because most people suggested that it would be bad if we didn't lynch anyone. Mars claimed that we might hit a villager, but whether it was the right call or not we don't know yet
I voted Neon because there weren't any better options and as I said before, Tail's reaction to Mars' case is hard to read, and Neon is the most suspicious at the moment.
A lot of this is still confusing to me, but I'm still contributing what I can

This won't be another wallpost, I promise.

As it stands, we don't have much coordination here. If our votes are too divided, it'll be easy for the mafia to sneak in a lynch. Think it'll be best to just reach a consensus soon, get a concrete idea of everyone's positions. In my case, I still believe that there's at least one mafia in the saws-syn-tails trio. I think the best move would be to lynch one of those three and cop one of the remaining two. Assuming we don't get them today, it'll be an easy POE.

As for Neon and Cal, they'll both get subbed out if they don't vote, so there isn't any point in targeting them today. I was feeling pretty uneasy about Neon but looking at his history, it's consistent enough with his character.

 

[Mars]

Mars and tails is looking town vs town to me.
and geez stop killing newbie mars xD ( you should change ur name to newbie slayer)

Sorry Ez mn snip ( syn ) but saws just making me think you guys are both mafia. The time you guys are posting. I know its not enough to suspect someone but I'm going for..
[Vote] Saws
we were going for flame before, right? ( though I thought they were newbie town) Idk saws just tell me why you keep tagging syn votes like that. I thought only flame was being like that but you're not making any sense too.

Edit:
Mars is only one who is looking town since he is actively scum hunting, not making content less post and you find that scummy - _ - though I still think that is just salt speaking.


Like I said saws and syn looking sus to me. ( saws more.. )
Neon idk but cop can definitely pay him visit this night. ( AND PLS COP REVEAL IF YOU HAVE 2 CONFIRMED TOWNIE BEFORE YOU DIE )

Mars is town to me.

Tails - can't really give everyone a pass with beginner mindset. But still think he/she is town. If it comes to last ditch pls reveal.

crazon-guy: null.

Syn!Saws wouldn't make sense. If they were scum buddies, they wouldn't make the mistake of appearing in the same time frame to say the exact same thing. My guess is that Saws was having trouble forming reads and sheeped Syn. Vote on D1 was reasonable, since GP was pushing for a lynch as well, and he subbed in mid-phase. Seems like he's played a pretty passive game in general. Is that how he usually is?

Still don't know what to think of Syn. Already pressed him a couple of times, but it was something along the lines of:
"Dude, you're suspicious"
"Sorry about that, bro"
"Alright, cool"
Letting him get away with it would be dumb as hell, especially now.

[Vote] Syn
Need a better idea of where you're at in all of this. What are your complete thoughts on Me, Tails, and Saws?

Think syn-tails-saws should claim, honestly. It'll be worth the risk if we can catch a mafioso in the process.

 

[Mars]

Almost forgot:

Friendly reminder that Impulse sucks.

 

[Syndrome]

I'd like to start this off by saying that pressure votes don't work on me

Also, you're probably the cop trying to determine who to visit tonight based on what others tell you about their reads, so what's up with those past investigations?

 

[Mars]

The cop would've claimed by now if they had anything useful. This is a standard procedure, so I'd appreciate it if you could cooperate.

 

[Syndrome]

Then I'd like them to claim, because we're going nowhere fast

 

[Mars]

Yeah, this clearly isn't going anywhere. Where the hell did everyone go.

[Vote] NeonSword
At this point, I'm just gonna put my vote on him. Aren't enough people around to decide anything. If he flips town, then fuck. We'll gain some info, at the very least. The cop should target one of the three people I mentioned. Their alignments will become clear soon enough.

 

[TailsMK4]

(I just now had a chance to view the thread, just so you guys know)

I'm a townie, and my vote has changed to:

[Unlynch] Mars
[Lynch] Sawsbuck

 

[Desinishon]

Yeah, this clearly isn't going anywhere. Where the hell did everyone go.

[Vote] NeonSword
At this point, I'm just gonna put my vote on him. Aren't enough people around to decide anything. If he flips town, then ****. We'll gain some info, at the very least. The cop should target one of the three people I mentioned. Their alignments will become clear soon enough.

if you're confident that tails-saws-syn got a mafia. Then let's lynch one of them for greater good. Saws/chrome was confused townie to me and you still think that too. I don't think that someone can be so petty to use a IRL excuse in order to save themself from an argument/lynch ( tails) So that leaves syn...he is active but i don't know where to put him in my reads so we can lynch him while cop can investigate tails or saws.
[Vote]Easy money sniper
Like you said Neon gonna get subbed/removed but if neon/clazon tried to vote at last minute then they're scum in my eyes. We can go for lynch on them next day.

 

[impulse~]

Almost forgot:

Friendly reminder that Impulse sucks.

rude

 

[Mars]

Phase isn't over yet?

if you're confident that tails-saws-syn got a mafia. Then let's lynch one of them for greater good. Saws/chrome was confused townie to me and you still think that too. I don't think that someone can be so petty to use a IRL excuse in order to save themself from an argument/lynch ( tails) So that leaves syn...he is active but i don't know where to put him in my reads so we can lynch him while cop can investigate tails or saws.
[Vote]Easy money sniper
Like you said Neon gonna get subbed/removed but if neon/clazon tried to vote at last minute then they're scum in my eyes. We can go for lynch on them next day.

Yeah, I still am. Don't know about Tails anymore, but I don't like how evasive Syn was. I'd prefer it if he could claim and defend himself right now, but this is the best chance we've got of nailing the scum team.
[Vote] Easy Money Sniper

The mafia must've shot the vigilante, and the vigilante shot the fool. At least we took an anti town in the fool.

I see that you're online now. Don't know if you're just waiting to get subbed out or what, but you need to at least say something. Seriously.

 

[TailsMK4]

I don't know why the phase isn't over yet either. It does seem like Bidoof FTW is busy in rl right now. I chose Saws since I thought Saws had the most votes outside of Neon (who I know is getting removed once the phase is truely over)...but with this phase extension, it seems like the suspicion is on Syn now. While I do think Syn is just acting his usual self, he usually does contribute a little more than he has. I think waiting for a reasonable defense is too little, too late now. I wouldn't change my vote again like this, but this is due to the phase extension.

[Unlynch] Sawsbuck
[Lynch] Easy Money Sniper

That doesn't mean I still don't suspect Saws, but I do want to help a lynch be meaningful for the town if possible.

 

[Syndrome]

Me revealing won't help in any way since it'll lead to my death tonight regardless, so

Guess I'll just die

 

[Mars]

Me revealing won't help in any way since it'll lead to my death tonight regardless, so

Guess I'll just die

What the hell. Not sure if I buy this, but

You do realize the situation we're in, right? If we mislynch today, then we'll be in lylo tomorrow. If the role you're softing is legit, then the cop gets weeded out with ease, and our lead disappears. At most, if we manage to clear you, we'll have a better chance of hitting actual scum today, and you'll absorb the night kill. It's already out there, so the best thing you can do for us is go all-out. Who was your target yesterday, and who do you think should be lynched instead?

 

[Syndrome]

I've targeted no one, because we've had no useful intel to go off of

I'm positive that one of Saws or Desi is mafia, so either of them

 

[TailsMK4]

Yeah, I'm beginning to think more that EMS is indeed town. I believe him.

[Unlynch] Easy Money Sniper
[Lynch] Sawsbuck

...I'm repeating the mistakes of my last mafia games, but I believe EMS to be innocent, so I have to change my vote back to my second vote. At least with my vote change, the vote is now tied to my knowledge, so at best we only lose Neon and Calzone. My hope is one of them is mafia, but I'm not betting on it.

 

[Syndrome]

Yeah I'm gonna swap to [lynch] Saws before the phase ends on me again

 

[Sawsbuck]

Yeah I'm gonna swap to [lynch] Saws before the phase ends on me again

Any reason for that other than me sheeping one vote?

And Tails, if you think one of them is a maf why don't you vote one of them instead of trying to tie a vote and hope we don't end up in LyLo?
Also do you really trust someone who claimed out of nowhere and states that they have not targeted anyone to back up their claim?