Oooh good choice, I really liked Matt Hardy when he was a part of Team Extreme :) But yeah there were a couple of things that happened outside the ring that kinda made me go off him a bit as well.
I was gonna list CM Punk in my favourites down below but I didn't know if I should count him or not seeing's how he's been gone for so long. Aww I'm sorry to hear that, I was kinda disheartened too when Edge left. Hmm... there's always Dean Ambrose maybe if you're looking for someone similar to support? :) He's probably the most like Punk that's still in the company, with entertaining promos and a tendency to speak his mind :)
Ah the memes are great haha and I guess I'm the opposite from you in that I keep up with the show but don't play the video games anymore (well, I still play Wrestlemania 2000 and No Mercy for N64 and Day of Reckoning 1 & 2 for the Gamecube,) but I don't have any games with a more recent roster - might have to change that haha :)