[Eliminate]No one We only get to abstain this once. I really think it's wise to do this over risking losing an inno or bandwagoning until they claim their PR.
So, you'll ignore even those who are scummy?
EDIT: You're looking protective here
^ThisJust because we can afford to abstain doesn't mean we should. We can very easily end up in a situation where we still have no information and are down a townie - possibly even a PR. I'd rather risk being down a townie with information than being stuck at square one still on day two.
Everyone has PRs. If we lose a hero we lose a PR. If we mislynch we potentially lose three PRs, depending on who the maf/sk go after. We should probably limit the number of people dying per day or we'll find ourselves outnumbered.Just because we can afford to abstain doesn't mean we should. We can very easily end up in a situation where we still have no information and are down a townie - possibly even a PR. I'd rather risk being down a townie with information than being stuck at square one still on day two.
Day 1 typically has a lot of ****posts, only the posts as of right now could portray any sort of reads. If votes aren't random they're typically based on something that isn't alignment indictive, like voting the person above them.^This
Being afraid of lynching townies is just an illusion. I urge y'all to believe in your day play instead of waiting for information to come to you via actions.
No lynching D1 because the lynch is based off RNG or you don't have "proof" is a fallacy for multiple reasons.
Humans are quite in fact bad at randomness, so posts throughout the day phase are usually alignment indicative, and analyzing those will help us solve the game.
No matter the set up we're potentially losing 2-3 towns a night. 2 for night kills and 1 for cult. Adding another casualty to the list, by lynching isn't going to help.Preserving town lives is an illusion due to the fact that regardless, town is going to die anyways, and the only way town can win is by lynching mafia.
Right, except this discussion is giving us information on it's own. Why should we risk losing a townie when we're going to know how people stand based on their votes and posts. Everyone needs to make 3 posts min per day and there's only so much ****posting you can do you circumvent that. I believe it better for us to get an outcome that has us with one less death than one more.You're denying the town information by no lynching, as you can use the stances of who pushed that player or who is defending them, and analyze how they pushed/defended the player to help come up with a read.
You don't need "proof" in the form of NAs to guess who is mafia. You have proof all throughout the day phases in the form of posts. You can analyze their stances and reads to see if they were naturally formed, or their motivation. There isn't one exact way how to scumhunt, but those are just a few off the top of my head.
Try that math again when you include the night kill of the mafia. Spoiler: A mislynch ends the game either way.If we lynch D1, we'll have a higher chance of lynching a mafia in a 3v4 LyLo as opposed to a 3v5 MyLo.
- Alisae
So Nicki was mafia, huh? That's good. Guys, before I give my opinion about the lynching matter, I think I have a good theory about what happened. Maybe Nicki was The Traitor, and the mafia killed her because they didn't know she was The Traitor. Of course that a lot of things could have happened, but I didn't see anyone mentioning this.
Now what I think about lynching someone today:
Both ways have downsides and advantages.
If we abstain today, we won't kill any town, but we also won't kill any mafia.
If we lynch someone, it's very probably that we will lynch a town, but there is always the chance of getting a mafia.
In my opinion, abstaining is a good option, but lynching someone is a better one. I still don't have any reads, and I don't want to lynch someone by RNG. So I will wait a bit more before I cast my vote.
Traitor - is sided with the Zeroes, but the Zeroes will never know who the Traitor is. Wins if the Zeroes win, but does not count towards their majority; will appear innocent on cop reports
Hence, if Nicki was 3rd Party, she would show up as green, or mediator.
Colours are irrelevant, I merely chose it for contrast.
That was before he said that he would reveal alignment. Traitor isn't a Zero, anyway.poke