• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Our weekly protagonist poll is now up! Vote for your favorite Trading Card Game 2 protagonist in the poll by clicking here.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Back to the Basics [Game Over]

JohnnyMustang said:
We need to start considering the possibility of this not being the third setup and a fool, aka gunner is on the loose.
Click to expand...

Either that, or Gunner is going with the punch and trying to make it seem like she's a Fool so we don't lynch her and get confused about the set-up.

In any case, Gunner is most certainly not an innocent role.​
 
do i want to be lynched? probably not. but i don't really care if i do :x all i can say is that im certainly town. :)

if you want me to cooperate, tell me who else do you think is suss.
 
I'm leaning towards a scum-read on Gunner right now because of her "lynch me if you dare, idc" attitude. This is usually a tactic I see used by cornered mafia members to use uncertainty to survive another night.
 
Idk if gunner is fool or not, let's not lynch her for now. I say whoever got gun shoot gunner.
 
Okay I think I've had enough of you.

[Lynch] Johnnymustang

Your aggressiveness, constant mixing up of people's messages and shoving words into their mouths, empty accusations, and you doing something as absurd as telling me that I'm cryptic and asking me what role I am when you did the exact thing with "there's no fab in this game" and refusing to claim. This could easily be a mafia's attempt to look inno considering there are several roles in this setup that are also not in a fab setup, since the people aren't all going to claim just to prove if you're inno or not. I'm not buying it.
 
JohnnyMustang said:
Wut. That was for Gunner lol

EDIT: I'm getting a really scummy attitude from you, Golgari. You softed that you are the Snoop from the beginning of the game, but you could also be the sniper trying to hint your identity to the mafia. So, in case you're not the Snoop, and the real Snoop didn't realize that you were softing that, I suggest they reveal now and we lynch Golgari.

Those are the only ways you could've known we're in the third setup from the bottom, by being either the Snoop or the Sniper.
Click to expand...

I'm actually neither so youre wrong

Edit: idk what made you think snoop in the first place,,,
 
After a reread...

Not much has changed, though now I have Nagi as a slight scum-lean
KetsuekiR said:
Not entirely sure what to make of the Johnny-Alex back and forth but my FOS is slightly leaning towards Alex for the aggression. That said, it's not that strong of a scum-read since Johnny did pretty much call him out and I most likely would've responded in a similar manner.


As opposed to what you're doing which is pretty much calling everyone who isn't iterating the same things already said scummy? It's was Day 1, setup speculation as most of what we can do this early on, with so little go off of. I could go around calling people scummy for not wanting to waste posts and other people's time by posting nonsense but you seem to have that skill down.
[PokeCommunity.com] Back to the Basics [Game Over]
Click to expand...
Well, do you think people that don't provide original thoughts are helpful for town? My point was that setup spec is easy to talk about, but piecing together thoughts about players/the game itself isn't the easiest thing (esp. on D1). Even if someone is struggling at providing thoughts, it's good because it at least shows they're making an effort. Does this make sense?

(also on another note, idk if you're FOSing Alex based simply on aggression, but Alex kind of always plays like this)
jdthebud said:
Alex, disregard your salt war with Johnny for a second. Who are your scum reads?
Click to expand...
jd, I'm not really sure where you stand on your own scum reads currently?
Bardothren said:
I will admit that I find Johnny questionable as well, but he acts that way regardless of alignment. The key isn't raw behavior, it's in analyzing trends and spotting outliers. I make a great example - I tend to be very quiet as an inno and more vocal and informative as mafia... which made me easy to spot in the past. But now that I say this and admit it out loud, well, now you have no idea what to expect :D
Click to expand...
I think it's funny that you say this, because I've always thought it seemed like the opposite :P
Golgari said:
snip
Click to expand...
@Golgari - who is scum besides Johnny?

There's more to respond to but I'm so tired and just not in the mood right now :(
(tomorrow, then)
 
Man. Quite a bit of conversation happened while I was asleep.

@Alex
While I've been "blabbing" on the few posts I've made, you and your little Salt War with Johnny has kinda made me suspicious of you. You're acting more... aggressive then usual.
Plus, not unlike you and the everyone else here, I have a life. School has been taking out a lot of my time recently (I know Summer's coming up, but I homeschool, so I do it year round).
I'm not lynching you because I don't have enough proof, and (unless if I can turn everyone to the Cayman Bandwagon) I wouldn't have enough votes anyway. But I've got my eye on you, mister.

For now [LYNCH] No One
 
JohnnyMustang said:
Wut. That was for Gunner lol

EDIT: I'm getting a really scummy attitude from you, Golgari. You softed that you are the Snoop from the beginning of the game, but you could also be the sniper trying to hint your identity to the mafia. So, in case you're not the Snoop, and the real Snoop didn't realize that you were softing that, I suggest they reveal now and we lynch Golgari.

Those are the only ways you could've known we're in the third setup from the bottom, by being either the Snoop or the Sniper.
Click to expand...

See Johnny, this is what you always do. You see half of the truth and then get stubborn over it. Golgari claimed we're in the third setup from the bottom after you claimed there is no fab. Besides snoop and sniper, he could also be bulletproof, angel, survivor (and maybe cultist but I'd like to think a cultist wouldn't claim that xD)

With his last post that he is 100% certain there is no fool, bp is out because of the last setup, which leaves the rest as possible roles for him. His first post today makes me thing he is a survivor.
 
Well, it seems there's two of them, so yes I don't see any counterclaims happening either.

I can't think of something right now. What happens when you say half the truth?
 
Golgari replied with "I'm neither" so guess the bait didn't help much xD Anyone who's done their homework would not fall for that, I believe. But it's not that bad of a reasoning, I can totally see you pulling stuff like that as town as I've said already, and it's the reason I'm not voting you just yet.

I'd like to lynch someone as well tbh, but after thinking there's 26 people remaining if I'm not mistaken, there is absolutely no reason to rush things since hopefully the cop is still alive. The mafia are only four so there is no reason to rush things. If anything, it's them who should be worried. Not pushing for reveals makes it hard for them to detect and kill the cop.

So, I'll [Vote] no one for now.
 
[lynch] no-one

There seems to be lots of aggression in this game :/ makes it hard to work out if people are baiting or being panicked, or if they're making actual mistakes or just getting caught up.

Anyway, there's definitely no fool so just what is the deal with Gunner <<. Seems odd she'd brag like that to be hunter and kill someone randomly. Bulletproofs can't survive a lynch right?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top