• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Our weekly protagonist poll is now up! Vote for your favorite Trading Card Game 2 protagonist in the poll by clicking here.
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Back to the Basics [Game Over]

Smh at Johnny's plays.

You blame me for something I didn't do, then vote me because I said I didn't do it, and calling it retaliating for the heck of it, when I do have a reason to, which is you falsely blaming me.
 
No gun here.

Klippy shooting Kaneki!!! doesn't clear him as sided with us, but IMO it's not enough evidence to go lynching over.

With a no-death night we're in a better position today. I'd be happy for one last no-lynch. If the Vig keeps behaving one more inno (or potentially third party!) death won't be too catastrophic.


/I'll read the Johnny V Alex brawl after work :c
 
No gun here...

This little feud that Johnny and Alex are having. So quick to lash at each other's throats! But, you are acting a little different, Alex. I'm not entirely convinced you're scum, though.
 
So, let me get this straight.

First, you accuse me of supporting Klippy when I did the exact opposite.
Then, you say I'm mafia because I said I didn't, which is a fact. You also ignored the fact and said I retaliated for the heck of it. Who in their rightful mind wouldn't object to a lie? Especially when it's headed their way.
Then, you fos me even more because I didn't omgus, when I'm clearly a player that bases his plays on reason, and I'm well aware you know this.

And I'm not really sure about the "everyone is aware of my role" part. I admit I didn't spend too much time on figuring your role out because I was willing to trust you up to the point you said I defended Klippy. You could even be a mafia wifoming, thinking "who would suspect me if I said there is no fab, that's stupid jaja" for all i know.

What happened to "I don't check past games to judge someone's plays because I wanna be impartial" ? You've been doing the exact opposite.
The way I see it you're just trying to get rid of me, basing your plays on anything but reason and facts.

Also, you wanna go off of baseless accusations?
OMFG! I haven't seen you ever as mafia Johnny and now you are acting differently so you have to be mafia!
 
"But you did OMGUS, you "shifted your fos" towards me, just because of that, something that an innocent would just call a mistake, but no no no, you took your chance and tried to suss me out"

So I didn't unsheathe my sword eh? Now, that's a proper bait, not lying because you know how I will react and then call me scum.

Edit : by the way, I did point out you made a mistake, you just ignored it because you're sold in your unfaltering righteousness you call gut.

Edit 2 : Sarcasm is not your thing is it?
 
Last edited:
Alex, use the courier font (or something else, it's better than just bolding) next time when you are conveying sarcasm. Like this:

OMFG! I haven't seen you ever as mafia Johnny and now you are acting differently so you have to be mafia!

Yes, this is why I voted Kiyo as "hardest to read" in the snail awards way back when. Initially all I was reading was sarcasm. :P

In any case, Johnny, you seem to be tunneling a bit too much. I'm not smelling the same scummy stench you seem to smell.

Alex, disregard your salt war with Johnny for a second. Who are your scum reads?
 
First of all, it's not a salt war, it's a battle of egos. Johnny baited my ego out, as he knew I'd react offensively to being falsely accused xD

Other than that, no strong reads atm. All I have is that Klippy fired his gun after being told so by Johnny and Bard. For all i know they're all mafia and arranged this beforehand. But that's just me over thinking this probably. It's too early to have a decent read, and the no lynch yesterday didn't help much.
 
Not entirely sure what to make of the Johnny-Alex back and forth but my FOS is slightly leaning towards Alex for the aggression. That said, it's not that strong of a scum-read since Johnny did pretty much call him out and I most likely would've responded in a similar manner.

Superjolt said:
I was going to point out how all he was doing at the time (and it was all he ended up contributing through the day) was just setup speculation, it's a good way to make it look like he's contributing something important without really contributing anything, and when I asked him for some thoughts with actual substance he ignored me, so I found that sort of scummy
Click to expand...
As opposed to what you're doing which is pretty much calling everyone who isn't iterating the same things already said scummy? It's was Day 1, setup speculation as most of what we can do this early on, with so little go off of. I could go around calling people scummy for not wanting to waste posts and other people's time by posting nonsense but you seem to have that skill down. :)
 
Collector Elwood said:
Please say something substantial instead.
Click to expand...

So far what I got.....

Spoiler:

After everything there is something superjolt calling out Ketsu. I was thinking both of them as slight scum. My fos Bard, superjolt, candy last one is pretty much gut feeling.
 
Bardothren said:
Well, since we're doing scumreads all of the sudden...

I personally believe both Ulli and Klippy are inno, along with Nimsy. alex does seem more confrontational than usual, so he'd be my first scumread. For everyone else, I only have gut feelings (so don't trust them) but I'm keeping an eye on Charlie, Kiyo, and Superjolt.
Click to expand...

How can I be confrontational when I'm the one confronted and not the one confronting? Johnny has been needlessly pushy this phase, and you didn't even mention him in this post. At this point, I think it's worth noting that you guys have been agreeing on pretty much anything.
 
Hi, I still exist! Maybe...

No guns here either.

I haven't had much of a chance to read everyone yet, I've been very busy D:
But, off the top of my head, something does seem a little off about Alex, but I don't think it is enough to lynch him. As Bac pointed out, he could be a power role. Alex vs Johnny could just be town vs town imo, but I could be wrong.

I'll put this here for now: [Vote] no-one
 
I've uh... been playing video games as celebration for clearing up exams... shut up.

This Johnny vs Alex debate makes me feel like Alex could be scum. I got my eyes on Gunner as well. Aside from that, I'm still pretty chill with the rest.

And before I disappear into video games again, I'll put this here: [KILL] No One. As people have already pointed out, it's a safe bet for now since no one died last night.
 
Huh. Anybody else find it terribly weird that no gun has been claimed today? There's been plenty of time. Now, I still stand by my statement that Klippy's reasoning to shoot Kaneki isn't scummy in itself; I still think that trying to pin him as scum for taking a shot that he both telegraphed and was encouraged to take is a bit ridiculous. Also that quip from Johnny about "testing him" was a load of what.

But ... you know, if we are indeed in the sixth set-up, there is a sniper; who has a gun to shoot during the day phase. It's not boding well for Klippy that no one has claimed and no one new has died; because we're missing a gun. But then again, it could've been given to a member of the mafia to incriminate Klippy in exactly this way. Or, Klippy was just on the receiving end of the gunsmith's dying action.

Food for thought. [LYNCH] No One for now. If anyone has the gun, claim now, because if we find out later in another phase, I'll be the first to say that hiding it was as suspicious as hell.​
 
I definitely feel like we lost our GS. :/ Unless someone just hasn't been online to say they got it.

[Lynch] no one
 
Johnny is looking pretty suss to me, but at the same time, Johnny's attitude always makes me suss of him ?_?
 
JohnnyMustang said:
What do you think it was, then?
Click to expand...

You just confuse me, Johnny. I don't know what to make of that conversation you had with alex.

Bardothren said:
GS could've been blocked too, you know. I doubt we lost the gunsmith so early.
Click to expand...

If I'm reading this right, you're making quite the soft claim. Either way, I think the GS is as good as dead if your situation is to be believed. That means the mafia knows who the GS is and will most certainly kill them tonight anyway.​
 
> Randomly wakes up in the middle of the night
> Decides to reread the whole thread
> Apparently, I need to stop posting while I'm at work, it affects my behaviour

So, going by the phase post and the "stuff didn't happen" the gs could potentially be blocked, which definitely makes Bard's softclaim seem honest.

I still can't wrap my head around Johnny's plays. I can see you pulling that "bait" as a townie, but still..
I've narrowed down your possible role to a select few now. If my theory is correct, I can see why you picked me as the bait target, and I'd suggest we leave it alone for now and I ask you to think of what might the case be.

I'm against another no lynch too. I'm thinking we should lynch one of Gunner or Catman.
Gunner for her effortless posts so far. She's been snailing a lot lately, including not having updated mcm scratched yet, so it's not much of a read, but if she's gonna keep being silent and not helping, then good riddance I guess.
Catman is even more silent than usual and his posts are nothing but blabling. I feel that he would have tried to share his thoughts as town by now.
Other candidates could be Lost and Lisia, going by the silent and slippery factor. I can see Lost vegging yet again tbh.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top