Battle of the Bands 2 - Top of the Pops! [Game Over.]

Johnny said:
I'm just a survivor ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Click to expand...

If Johnny is a survivor, this vote is purely inconsequential.

I'm going with [END CAREER]Alex Kaz. Bard and Alex seemed to be on the same boat, and voting a third party isn't really helping town. We need to find those scummy people and not third-party.
 
Bardothren said:
Eh... that's exactly the kind of claim a serial killer would make in that situation. I agree that it's unlikely maf and another killer both hit the same target... but I don't see maf wasting a strongman either. Not to mention, it's really early for a vig to start killing people. A serial killer hitting on every other night or simply taking the first night off makes the most sense to me. Not to mention, we could do a lot worse than killing a survivor, and it'd give purple time for more investigations, so it's not as good as lynching a maf, I admit, but it'll help us get on the right track.
Click to expand...

Can you please explain to me how lynching a claimed survivor will help us get on the right track? Purple can still investigate tonight as long as we don't lynch her right?

Also, can we use data on other games as reference? Vig kill N0 in one piece mafia, so nothing is too early for a vig kill A vig will kill if he wants to. It only depends on how skilled a player he is. We also didn't lynch Abby as Survivor in Vesperia, we just let him survive. So idk how lynching Johnny is going to help us.

Also, it was Abby who first pointed out the Alex x Bard.

abby you're the reason for this post. you're the survivor, you're the vig, and you pointed out alex x bard. you rock.
 
It could probably also mean that the mafia took advantage with the fact that BP didn't claim?

And as what Johnny said, lynching a confirmed survivor is not better than lynching a possible town. We can get no read on that and we'll be removing someone who might be helpful in providing reads anyways.

If we lynch Johnny and if he did flip survivor, what do we get?
 
I reaaaally don't like how easily home is buying the survivor claim. How can you even say "confirmed survivor" with a straight face? It's almost triggering.
He is a confirmed third party, not a confirmed survivor.
Reading more into it, I can say with almost certainty that Johnny isn't a fool/jester. A fool wants to get lynched, and a survivor claim goes against that.

The worst thing right now is that Sir Dolan, aka the only person we can absolutely trust, is getting replaced so we can't get anything from her.

Anyhow, I'll be a better person than Johnny was in BttB (yes, some salt still lingers) and realize the fact that lynching a third party isn't as helpful. We can afford to take a shot with someone else. I'm not sure who to look at, though.
 
I'm thinking gp or Fletch. Actually, I wouldn't even mind a gp lynch right now. I already disliked how he jumped on the purplecicada wagon so why not.

[End Career] gimmepie
 
Alex Kaz said:
I reaaaally don't like how easily home is buying the survivor claim. How can you even say "confirmed survivor" with a straight face? It's almost triggering.
He is a confirmed third party, not a confirmed survivor.
Reading more into it, I can say with almost certainty that Johnny isn't a fool/jester. A fool wants to get lynched, and a survivor claim goes against that.

The worst thing right now is that Sir Dolan, aka the only person we can absolutely trust, is getting replaced so we can't get anything from her.

Anyhow, I'll be a better person than Johnny was in BttB (yes, some salt still lingers) and realize the fact that lynching a third party isn't as helpful. We can afford to take a shot with someone else. I'm not sure who to look at, though.
Click to expand...

Well, all right, let me reword it. Confirmed third-party. But I trust Johnny's claim of survivor for now.
 
I think the cop claim is quite believable since no one's actually counterclaiming.

As for my opinion on who we should lynch, I don't think we should actually lynch Johnny since lynching a third party role hardly helps us get any good information at all. As for the Bardothren x Alex conspiracy, I doubt maf would actually make such an obvious partnership during day. I think they would be more low profile and pretend to not be associates. Thus, I think I'll go with voting for gimmepie this time. I don't necessarily scumread him, but the others may be onto something.

[End Career] gimmepie
 
Alex Kaz said:
I'm thinking gp or Fletch. Actually, I wouldn't even mind a gp lynch right now. I already disliked how he jumped on the purplecicada wagon so why not.

[End Career] gimmepie
Click to expand...

What wagon? I was like the second person to vote them and they're being scummy as hell. Even their claim, which I don't believe for a second, is all over the place. Are we just going to ignore that?

I admit I'm not being as active as normal, which might look a little odd, I'm wrapped up in my own life a bit right now and focusing on PC less. Other than that, which I've just explained, the only thing I've done this game is vote for someone acting scummy... and you're voting me for that? I think you're a bit rusty :P
 
Fletch said:
tbh I don't particularly think Bard x Alex are scum, just pushing on something that really gets us nowhere. I'm way more inclined to believe that there was a Vig & Maf hit. Or perhaps, there's a granny here? But then that implies Mafia NK'd. I'm overthinking and probably forgetting basic mechanics.
Click to expand...

Yeah because BP wouldn't have been able to visit granny
 
I don't have much time, so if I forgot something, forgive me please.

So I mainly find it a bit weird that people immediatly jump on Johnny just because he is third party. Immediatly he is a serial killer? I find that a bit weird.

[End Career] Alex Kaz
 
L'Belle said:
I don't have much time, so if I forgot something, forgive me please.

So I mainly find it a bit weird that people immediatly jump on Johnny just because he is third party. Immediatly he is a serial killer? I find that a bit weird.

[End Career] Alex Kaz
Click to expand...

There's probably at least 1 more killing role that's not mafia, so i think it's likely there's sk

That being said, I do buy Johnny's survivor claim, so I'm not lynching him :)
 
gimmepie said:
What wagon? I was like the second person to vote them and they're being scummy as hell. Even their claim, which I don't believe for a second, is all over the place. Are we just going to ignore that?

I admit I'm not being as active as normal, which might look a little odd, I'm wrapped up in my own life a bit right now and focusing on PC less. Other than that, which I've just explained, the only thing I've done this game is vote for someone acting scummy... and you're voting me for that? I think you're a bit rusty :P
Click to expand...

How do you explain purple correctly guessing Johnny's alignment, though? I see two cases here.
1. Plainly put, it's the truth.
2. They are both mafias and are covering for each other. In this case, we can wait one more day and see if we get a cop counterclaim. I mean, if there really is a cop out there and it's not purple, they should claim tomorrow at worst. That hands us two mafias and it wouldn't really be a smart play for them.

Also, that bolded part is screaming mafia mate, ngl.


Miah said:
I'm just gonna do this:

[End Career] Alex Kaz

Edit: Abby, I also got confused about that too lol
Click to expand...
Any particular reason as to why you're voting me?

L'Belle said:
I don't have much time, so if I forgot something, forgive me please.

So I mainly find it a bit weird that people immediatly jump on Johnny just because he is third party. Immediatly he is a serial killer? I find that a bit weird.

[End Career] Alex Kaz
Click to expand...
Same question for you. Did you just ignore the part I agreed with the idea of lynching Johnny isn't helping town enough and switched my vote?

I mean, I've already said enough, pointed enough fingers and gave my townreads already, so my death and alignment reveal would definitely help, but I'd hate to die off of a stupid lynch for no particular reason.
 
Sorry for anything that sounds weird ahead my vision is blurry af and i can't focus very well right now. but i haven't said anything yet so i'd like to at least attempt to do so before the day ends for I have been keeping up with all this but i just haven't been able to post.

i'd like to hear from purple herself why she's so certain to whether johnny is third party. while it's very possible she can just say what johnny have thrown at us hearing it from her own words might help us get a better read on her and the situation. and while i don't read alex as scummy he's not town either. right now he's reading more as a null.

also i'm spice girls before i forget to mention it again.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top