Beginners Mafia 104

[jdthebud]

A Pacifist Day Commenced
Night 1
~24 Hours​

Nobody Died

VS.

VS.

THE GRAVEYARD

IT'S NIGHT!​

If you have a Night Action (often referred to as NA), send your target to both jdthebud and Lycanthropy via private message.

Also remember, no posting during the night! See you guys again in ~24 hours.
​

​

​

Pings:

Spoiler:

I'd love to play if no one else signs up :D

Wow, you're really selling it.
At least enough to make me join, I guess. I'll have a look into this and see how it goes; never done Mafia on a forum before.

I'm 100% in. Let's do this.

I'm familiar with the game, but not as much with an forum presence, so I'll join! Would be good experience!

in lol

Hehe we are at the dark side right? Hugs to everybody. I am in. Watch out for me.

Welcome to the land of salt, new snails! :3
If you need people to fill the game I'm here. I'm not as good at mafia as Bard but I'll do I guess

I'll sign up! I haven't forgotten how to play mafia but it's been ages. So, yeah!

I'm officially the worst mafia player here so if we need existing members I'm here

Yeah I kinda went awol in a few mafia games I was in and I certainly need practice so count me in

^

 

[jdthebud]

Night of Safety
Day 2
~48 Hours​

Nobody Died.

VS.

VS.

THE GRAVEYARD

IT'S DAY!​

Good morning everyone! And a real good morning it is, since everyone survived the night!

As a reminder, you can vote by typing "[Vote] username", and make sure it is bolded. (Alternate common verbs, such as "Kill", "Lynch, etc. are all fine too, as long as it's clear you're voting.) At any time before the end of the day, you may switch your vote to somebody else if you feel like. When the day has ended, the player who has the most votes will be lynched. Abstaining from voting is allowed, in that case please use: "[Vote] no one".
​

​

​

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

Day 2 starts now! :)

 

[Beck!]

Well one good thing is that the third party is not closer to winning with noone dying today.

An interesting development - so someone was targeted by both the Doctor and Mafia.

Based on the events yesterday? I'm going to say that person is Beck. My reason? Beck was a LOT more vocal about people here than everyone else and fired a fair few names around. One of those names clearly has panicked and decided to get rid before more was revealed. FORTUNATELY, the Doctor - whomever you may be - has also realised Beck is innocent and saved him. Yaaaaay.

So long story short: Beck is definitely a good guy and I will not be looking to get rid of him. This leaves me with the people who were challenging or retaliating to him which were EC and drewbie. EC isn't showing many characteristics to imply he is bad in any way whereas drewbie seemed to get real defensive real fast.

Therefore currently, my vote is going to...

[VOTE] drewbie411

Solid post and solid vote. An inkling of concern about TMI and pocketing, but I'll let it simmer.

Regardless of whether it's me or not, the Doctor, whoever they may be, now knows that whoever they targeted is not a wolf. I'm assuming the wolves' NK is compulsory, otherwise we'll have to think again.

I'm most bothered by the fact that we didn't lynch anyone yesterday. Even if it had been a villager, we would have had a lot to look into. Wolves have to make opinions about villagers as well, lest anyone forget. We're note spacing the day without lynching someone.

 

[PankajBlitz]

What a safe day. :) So whats the plan pipz whom to doubt? :(

 

[Beck!]

What a safe day. :) So whats the plan pipz whom to doubt? :(

What do you think we should do?

 

[Abby]

Cop should have 2 reports by now, and doctor is alive, so maybe they could out?

 

[Paranoia_]

Honestly, I'm not surprised I'm being voted right off the bat. Kill me if you want for this claim as well, but I'm a Villager. ofc I'm gonna die, but I can't do anything about that now.

 

[TheCapsFan]

Cop should have 2 reports by now, and doctor is alive, so maybe they could out?

I would not recommend this. I think that the cop should only out if pressured.

Honestly, I'm not surprised I'm being voted right off the bat. Kill me if you want for this claim as well, but I'm a Villager. ofc I'm gonna die, but I can't do anything about that now.

Give us your thoughts. Who is town? Who is mafia?

 

[Paranoia_]

Give us your thoughts. Who is town? Who is mafia?

This might be a bit bias, but I can see Beck being mafia. I agree that putting himself out in the open is risky but it very well could be WIFOM, especially since he claimed villager. Also, Abby telling cop to reveal brings up lots of questions. Volpe also giving lots of insight, getting town from him.

 

[Beck!]

I do not know what you mean by 'pocketing' so I can say that is completely unintentional.

I agree wholeheartedly - someone has to be lynched today to progress it for us Villagers otherwise it's going to become easy pickings for the Mafia.

Pocketing is like sucking up, it's something wolves do to villagers most often, where they'll read a villager as a strong villager and defend that villager to get on their good side. You entering the day suggesting I was likely saved is concerning but not necessarily poor thinking. Just not a conclusion I think is worth coming to.

Cop should have 2 reports by now, and doctor is alive, so maybe they could out?

No. What is with the dependency on PRs? This is lame.

Honestly, I'm not surprised I'm being voted right off the bat. Kill me if you want for this claim as well, but I'm a Villager. ofc I'm gonna die, but I can't do anything about that now.

This is also lame. There's like 30+ hours left in the day, there's no reason to give up. If you're a villager fight the suspicion and help try to solve the game.

Have zoroarkrules25 and GreenLegend56 posted?

Also, [VOTE] TheCapsFan

 

[PankajBlitz]

Why do some people think cop and doctor should reveal their identity?

COP - Hi I am cop mafias feel free to kill me.
DOCTOR - Hi I am doc dont kill cop. kill me I wont heal him then.

Understood?

@beck offline guys I think we should eliminate them?

 

[Abby]

No, doc can save the same person consecutive nights~

 

[Beck!]

Ohhhh, ok. Thanks for the clarification; for what it's worth I can confirm that is not the case and I just feel that since this has progressed you haven't really displayed anything that would make me tag you as Mafia.

Out of interest, would you mind explaining your vote if possible?

Fair enough. I feel similarly about you.

I will explain my vote in time, would love some more I out from TheCapsFan first.

 

[NightKrow]

Ok, I have some spare time now, where to start?

Firstly, I wouldn't be 100% certain that the mafia targeted Beck, especially as he claimed Villager. It could have been any one of the people who were vocal in the last phase. I'd add at least Volpe and myself to the list of potential targets from last night. They could have thought that the doc would protect Beck that night and chose someone else, or maybe they decided that Beck wasn't worth killing yet because he'd claimed Villager and if they picked someone else they might have taken out a power role. We're just lucky that the doc happened to pick the same person as the mafia did, whoever they did pick.

There's no reason for the cop to reveal at all until they've found scum. It's also worth noting that if the doc pins themselves on the cop, the mafia do still have their Lookout, so if the cop is in the open they could also find out who the doc is, then bam! 2 dead PRs. I know I may have just put that idea into their heads but they may have thought of it anyway, so it's probably better that we know that's something that could happen if the cop outs.

I think I saw a post from zoroark last phase, not sure though. Might be imagining that, will have to go back and check. I definitely haven't seen anything from GreenLegend, but I don't see that as scummy yet, as mafia would want to blend in, not be totally inactive.

For now, I will vote to [Kill] G-Cis Harmonia Gropius. His only contributions to the game so far have been two ideas that are better for scum than for town.

 

[Abby]

I get that asking for cop may have been frowned upon as a play, but what was the other?

 

[NightKrow]

The D1 nl, which gave scum an extra chance at a kill before we could lynch again, and gave town no information to work with the next day. I get that you're not entirely responsible for that as a lot of people followed you, but even if you don't count that, that's even less contribution overall.

 

[jdthebud]

Current Vote Count:

G-Cis Harmonia Gropius: 2 (Volpe Artica, Nightkrow)
TheCapsFan: 1 (Beck)
Voteless: Arsonist, drewbie411, EvilChameleon, G-Cis Harmonia Gropius, GreenLegend56, PankajBlitz, TheCapsFan, zoroarkrules25

The phase will end in approximately 15 hours. Get your votes in.

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

15 hours till end of the day.

 

[EC]

[VOTE] Nobody

 

[Lycanthropy]

I also like to mention that GreenLegend56 and TheCapsFan haven't voted either yesterday. A standard procedure in the Underground would be removing people from inactivity (or replacing them by other people) when missing two votes in a row.
Since you didn't know that, we're going to be mild for now. But you better get your votes in. :)

 

[Z25]

I've been watching this thread, but haven't posted much. (Mainly because I've got to finish something for school. Also because of there not being much to comment on yet though)

And there still isn't anything I can use to be concrete for voting. Although some comments are interesting, but I'm not going to outright accuse someone yet until I see more info or posts.

So I'm voting for

[Kill]No One again.