Death Note Mafia [Game Over]

[Nimsy]

Okay, here's my list of the dead and their roles.

Gio7sm- Teru Mikami
Yukari- Misa
Sopheria-Ryuk

Ash- justice w/ unknown role
Klippy-Near
Nagi-Watari

Netto- populace
Arx-populace
Bidoof ftw- populace
seth rollins-populace
sonata-populace
deceptio-populace

no-populace
twiggy-populace
gimmiepie-populace
misdreavus-populace

Absol used bite!-populace
Kiriyuuki Kasuna-populace
Bacteriophage-populace
Jupiter-populace

----------
L- Fun size?
Near -Klippy (deceased)
Mello- Ullion?
Soichiro-Mana?
Watari- Nagi (deceased)
Aiber-Bardothren?

Bard might be lying about being aiber, ash died as a roled-justice and bard rr'd right after she died.

Kira-one of y'all
Misa- Yukari (arrested)
Teru- Gio7sm (arrested)
Kiyomi - one of y'all
Ryuk- Sopheria (left)
Rem- Johnny mustang?

so there's two unknown idealists still out there.

----
Fun Size as L?
Bardothren as aiber?-FOS
Ullion as Mello?-FOS
Mana as soichiro?

arachnidsGrip as a just?
Lycanthropy as a gossip
Nimsy as a gossip
Candy as a pledged just?-FOS

JohnnyMustang as rem?

Kiyoshi the Polar Bear as takada or light?

------

also the third death note holder is out there, and it could belong to anyone.

 

[Mana1]

Ok, it's true. I am Rem, but i can no longer win with the idealists or reveal their identities. I got a new win condition and it is getting Kira arrested, if you guys want to arrest me that's cool because if i don't get kira arrested i'll die anyway, all i have to do is live until Kira gets arrested, but i also have two more nights to do it or i'll lose.

How do you plan on getting Kira arrested when you're not allowed to reveal who he is. Since surely voting someone would 'reveal'.

 

[Nimsy]

Forgot to say that, i can no longer vote. That's why, anyway, i'm done for. Aparently i'll kill Kira if he gets arrested.

Sorry, but there's no reason to keep you around. You've been our enemy and you can't help us in any way.

but you revealing has helped with the list, so I'll change my vote.

[ARREST] collector elwood

voting kiyo will help with the list even more.

 

[Fun Size]

Check your reports again? Gimme died as a populace, so how was he a loyal follower just that night before?

Also, as L, you were unaware who Wartari was? That's a pain :L. Did you ever get to use your kill command through Nagi?

I never had to know who Wartari was all I had to do was PM GF who I wanted Wartari to kill and bye bye person. Why do you think Sopheria's now gone? :P If you're reading this Soph, I'm sorry.

 

[Ullion]

I always considered Bard's reveal to be suss, given the implications it gave Soichiro and the resulting death of Near. I highly agree with checking Ash's alignment, Candy. :)

Also, obviously there's no foolproof way for me to prove that I'm Mello (I literally don't get an NA until L is killed). However, being justice from the start can be seen from the fact that I turned a BW off Klippy to save him and specifically targeted gio7sm who turned out to be an Idealist with a role. If I was Kira or an idealist, WHY THE HELL WOULD I DO THAT ON DAY ONE? :/

 

[Fun Size]

Ok I've thought about it and I'm gonna

[Arrest] Kiyoshi the Polar Bear

My reasoning for this is simple: as an unconfirmed role holder there's a chance he's an idealist and even better is that all the roles for the Justice League have been claimed meaning if he turns out to be Mello/Aiber/Soichiro then we know the person that claimed that role is most likely an Idealist. Of course this also applies to my investigations. If Kiyoshi is arrested today, then I have four people to investigate. If someone turns out to be let's say Aiber and it isn't Bard, then they Bard's basically an Idealist.

Also Candy/Milotic, have you been able to see what Ash's role was?

 

[Candy]

Also Candy/Milotic, have you been able to see what Ash's role was?

It's a Night Action so I can't find out 'til tonight, sadly. :c

Dying of a heart attack is really possible for me tonight. I knew I shouldn't have rr'd 'til I have used my NA, but eh... idk... Either of us will die tonight, so be sure to check on any of the power role claims tonight, especially Bard/Yuli 'cause I have really high suspicions on those two... At least that way one of us can shed some light into the situation, thus narrowing down the possible Idealists.

And I'm also going to go and [ARREST] Collector Elwood. If he turns up as Justice then I'll be sure to check on his exact role as well tonight.

Also the command in this game is [ARREST] lol

 

[Who's Kiyo?]

Aaaahhhhactually, I kind of like this plan. I mean since Mana went to all that trouble of brewing up a fake list and now even the guy playing L thinks it's a good idea to arrest me, I think being revealed as a Justice at the end of the day will speak for itself and there's no real point in spending the next hour sifting through month-old PM's and typing up something you'll disbelieve until I'm dead anyway - besides, the only real value Mana has for claiming Soichiro now is to buy time for the Idealists that won't really matter in the end. With enough investigative snooping from y'all I'm sure at the end of the day somebody's story won't hold up and you'll pretty much have enough material to find the Idealists. I mean Johnny just rr'd, and one of them is Mana, so ... yeah, sure, I'll die now if it only benefits us.

[Arrest] Fun Size (idk if voting for yourself is considered abstaining so I'll change if it's not)

Just promise me you'll kiss me through the window send me some good interrogation questions, eh?

 

[Ullion]

It's a Night Action so I can't find out 'til tonight, sadly. :c

Dying of a heart attack is really possible for me tonight. I knew I shouldn't have rr'd 'til I have used my NA, but eh... idk... Either of us will die tonight, so be sure to check on any of the power role claims tonight, especially Bard/Yuli 'cause I have really high suspicions on those two... At least that way one of us can shed some light into the situation, thus narrowing down the possible Idealists.

And I'm also going to go and [ARREST] Collector Elwood. If he turns up as Justice then I'll be sure to check on his exact role as well tonight.

Also the command in this game is [ARREST] lol

We can always just arrest Rem, and have Soichiro protect you at night while you investigate Ash. Assuming we aren't missing any roles, then Ash has to be Aiber right? I mean from your guys' perspectives other than Bard and I, you'd say she could be Mello too. So that's 2 mafia right there (Johnny and Bard), and then we still have Kiyo/Mana both claiming Soichiro - so one of them is also an idealist, right?

That means 3 idealists left, presumably. And I don't know how many times I need to say it, if I weren't the real Mello (and as a result I'd be mafia), then why would I have puished to kill the fanatic on day one? Unless you guys think I would have purposely started a bandwagon against one of my Idealists just incase a late game situation like this happened? I'd do that in short games like EM, but not on forum mafia. Seriously -.-

Nevertheless, if Soichiro protects Candy and she gets Ash's role revealed then you guys will know I'm telling the truth. /sighs

 

[Ullion]

Well we both declared our arguments. Let's wait for what Candy says then :) If you even want to double confirm, have Fun Size investigate me (which would be for the second time) to see I am still Justice. :P Also, nice attempt trying to pin me as scum on the same line as I'm a maf in another game. I can't wait for next day phase to come so either: you realize how dumb and mistaken you are OR for everyone to find out how guilty you are.

 

[Who's Kiyo?]

lol and here I thought y'all had supposedly pinned me down for Kira

 

[Ullion]

To be honest Kiyo, I am so bloody confused. If Bard is actually telling the truth about Aiber - then who the hell was Ash? I really am dying to know who is who now. ><

Someone is pulling out the BS here, and I just want this day to end so we find all this out. Mind you, if Rem dies today and no matter what sequence of events happen - we (innos) will win regardless, right? If I'm killed at any point, I'll be revealed as Mello and then you guys will know for sure, right? :/

 

[Who's Kiyo?]

To be honest Kiyo, I am so bloody confused. If Bard is actually telling the truth about Aiber - then who the hell was Ash? I really am dying to know who is who now. ><

Someone is pulling out the BS here, and I just want this day to end so we find all this out. Mind you, if Rem dies today and no matter what sequence of events happen - we (innos) will win regardless, right? If I'm killed at any point, I'll be revealed as Mello and then you guys will know for sure, right? :/

I'm pretty positive the innos will win regardless, given that anybody's death will reveal who's telling the truth and who's not. And depending if Candy lives or not after this day phase (unlikely?) she'll certainly dish out the right info.

You know what would be hilarious? If she dug up Ash only to find out she was L. I'm like 100% sure she's not but could you imagine holy **** I would owe Fun Size so many dinners for that pull.

Anyways, when am I dying? We got three more scum to kill once I'm gone. Better get that on before something else ridiculous happens.​

 

[Ullion]

I can confirm L is not dead. If he was, I'd have a Night Action XD

Also I'm very positive L has been mentioned in the day posts after Ash's death. :P

 

[Fun Size]

Aaaahhhhactually, I kind of like this plan. I mean since Mana went to all that trouble of brewing up a fake list and now even the guy playing L thinks it's a good idea to arrest me, I think being revealed as a Justice at the end of the day will speak for itself and there's no real point in spending the next hour sifting through month-old PM's and typing up something you'll disbelieve until I'm dead anyway - besides, the only real value Mana has for claiming Soichiro now is to buy time for the Idealists that won't really matter in the end. With enough investigative snooping from y'all I'm sure at the end of the day somebody's story won't hold up and you'll pretty much have enough material to find the Idealists. I mean Johnny just rr'd, and one of them is Mana, so ... yeah, sure, I'll die now if it only benefits us.

[Arrest] Fun Size (idk if voting for yourself is considered abstaining so I'll change if it's not)

Just promise me you'll kiss me through the window send me some good interrogation questions, eh?

To be honest, it doesn't matter who dies at this moment. I've basically proven that Johnny is Rem since he's admitted to it. If you really are Soichiro, then you'd be doing a huge favor because for one, you've shown that Mana is lying and two that's another unconfirmed: proven. If I survive, then in a best case scenario, tomorrow (D10) there will only be two unconfirmed left. If you really want to know how I feel, I think you're lying and I don't believe your Soichiro. I actually think your the "broadcaster" chick or whatever. I'd like to ask you and Mana something: there was one night in which the Idealists targeted Soichiro, but he didn't die. How?

Also dude, if I was pulling your leg and pretending to be L, then the L's in the narratives would have to be ghosts cause he'd be dead.

 

[Mana1]

You believe I might be lying still? Kiyo didn't even bother trying to muster up a list and I have you all the dates of my PMs even. Lmao.

Also notice how he talks about Candy unlikely to survive the night, rather than just saying he could protect her?

The reason I survived the Death Note (and softed my role a few posts into the following day) was because Kira is my Son and can't kill me directly. So he guilt tripped and had to rub it out, all part of my role.

 

[Fun Size]

You believe I might be lying still? Kiyo didn't even bother trying to muster up a list and I have you all the dates of my PMs even. Lmao.

Also notice how he talks about Candy unlikely to survive the night, rather than just saying he could protect her?

The reason I survived the Death Note (and softed my role a few posts into the following day) was because Kira is my Son and can't kill me directly. So he guilt tripped and had to rub it out, all part of my role.

Yeah that's what I assumed actually. I've felt like you've been Soichiro the whole time because of all the clues you've left. So if what you're saying is true, you're immune to the Death Note as long as Light is the wielder? If that's true, then if you kept protecting me each night wouldn't we be invincible? I feel like there's some catch.

 

[Ullion]

If this is the case, we can do the following:
-> Lynch Johnny, Rem is gone
-> At night, have Candy check Ash's body and have Fun Size check me - thus I will be confirmed and Bard (presumably? Unless body shenanigans have happened) will be revealed as mafia
-> If Candy is mafia and is trying to fool us, then this double investigation would not just clear me but backfire on Candy (ie. if she says Ash's body came up Mello, but Fun Size checks me and gets Justice for a second time)
-> If Candy is telling the truth about her role/alignment then we find out what Ash really is and can make an appropriate lynch tomorrow based off that
-> Deal with Kiyo/Kira (I assume)?
-> game over? Or maybe we have to find and deal with the 3rd Death Note?

edit: If you really are Aiber and are innocent, Bard, then you should have no problems agreeing to this plan. Because if you're really Aiber you have no reason to believe I am Mello and this investigation would reveal me. If it reveals me and you're innocent, Ash's body won't come up as Aiber. On the off chance we're both innocent, then body shenanigans must have happened with Ash and we just have to hope Candy is Blue-aligned now and her NA will see through it and we'll have the truth?

 

[Mana1]

There is a catch but let's kill Kiyo first :x I don't want to let them know how to kill me haha.

 

[Fun Size]

If this is the case, we can do the following:
-> Lynch Johnny, Rem is gone
-> At night, have Candy check Ash's body and have Fun Size check me - thus I will be confirmed and Bard (presumably? Unless body shenanigans have happened) will be revealed as mafia
-> If Candy is mafia and is trying to fool us, then this double investigation would not just clear me but backfire on Candy (ie. if she says Ash's body came up Mello, but Fun Size checks me and gets Justice for a second time)
-> If Candy is telling the truth about her role/alignment then we find out what Ash really is and can make an appropriate lynch tomorrow based off that
-> Deal with Kiyo/Kira (I assume)?
-> game over? Or maybe we have to find and deal with the 3rd Death Note?

edit: If you really are Aiber and are innocent, Bard, then you should have no problems agreeing to this plan. Because if you're really Aiber you have no reason to believe I am Mello and this investigation would reveal me. If it reveals me and you're innocent, Ash's body won't come up as Aiber. On the off chance we're both innocent, then body shenanigans must have happened with Ash and we just have to hope Candy is Blue-aligned now and her NA will see through it and we'll have the truth?

There's actually one catch I'm seeing. If Candy is with Loki, then they could say Ash's Aiber. In turn this will make us think Bard is lying and mafia so we'd probably lynch him, but what if he's actually Aiber and Candy is lying? I guess after that we'd know that Candy was lying and we could kill her the next day. Tonight I will check you for the second time, because truth be told, I've had a feeling that you've been Light this whole time. Of course, from the way you make it sound, you're not Light, so eh. Tomorrow will be quite interesting and a lot will be answered.

You can do it Death/Greenflame/Cosmic! Let's finally get this game over with! I know you have a life and everything, but please, GET THE PHASE CHANGE OUT QUICKLY!