4th Gen Heartgold or Soulsilver?

[ISNorden]

SoulSilver; it's got my favorite species (Teddiursa) available to catch, and HeartGold doesn't.

 

[Fernando Torres]

I think I speak for all the people who are 4th gen fanatics when I say HG/SS are the best Pokémon games ever. They polished all the graphics, added new features, made pokemon follow you, and gave you the option to turn on original GB sounds. I find no problems with these games because they're perfect in every way. HG/SS are my favorite pokemon games ever.

 

[SteveTaylor]

HeartGold. HO-OH, MAN. C'MON. HO-OH.

 

[hisalness56]

I had Silver version back in the day so I had to get Soul Silver first. I ended up with both but Silver was my game of choice so Soul Silver

 

[Daixtey]

I bought Both of them on the day they were realeased but I ended up playing through Soulsilver but not through Heartgold so Soulsilver was my Favourite but its hard to tell because both versions had hardly any differences.

 

[SubVirus]

I enjoyed SoulSilver more then heartgold but i don't really know why. i like both of the legendaries

 

[Starry Windy]

I like Ho-Oh, so I picked HeartGold all the way.

 

[Therizinosaurus]

soulsilver, because im a sucker for alliteration. i own both (actually have two copies of heart gold) but i always hate fighting my way through the bell tower. why would an ancient tower have so many traps and such as stupid maze? it makes more sense to have the maze in the whirl islands, and for that i like soul silver more.

 

[Megan]

Soulsilver, mainly because it has the (for me) better exclusives. Though it has slightly less Pokemon than Heartgold...

Also I had already played Gold, so what would be a better choice than Soulsilver?

 

[Zythrone]

I only played soul Silver... so that I guess.

 

[Sirfetch’d]

I chose SoulSilver just because I originally played silver and I wanted the full remake experience I gues haha! But I do prefer Ho-oh over Lugia, however that wasn't a factor due to being able to obtain both anyways.

 

[XeroNos]

HeartGold for me because I personally prefer Ho-Oh over Lugia as well as those exclusive Pokes featured in the game

 

[WishCookie]

I chose HeartGold since Gold was the one I picked when it was released. I also prefer its features more then the ones in SS. I like both Ho-oh and Lugia tho. :P

 

[Creame]

Soul Silver without a doubt!! I simply love Lugia..

 

[Eme]

Even though SoulSilver was my first game, I like Fire types. And you can get Growlithe. They're so cute!

 

[BUKKØW]

I chose soulsilver but wished i have chose heartgold i just like there exclusive pokes better. But i do love both of these games more than anyother made. ruby,sapphire, emerald is a second than yellow. it really takes me back to my childhood. I ♥ Pokémon

 

[PsychoticMoonlight]

I perfer SoulSilver, mainly because I like lugia. Some of the excluded Pokèmon were a total bummer but that's what the do for twin versions.​

​

 

[Rizardon]

Soul Silver because I played the original Silver game.

 

[Shrew]

I always wanted Silver as a kid, yet never got it. Fast forward years later, I was psyched to get Soulsilver. Heartgold's opening of Ho-Oh flying is much more pleasant to me than Lugia swimming, however.

 

[ShinyNuzLover]

I prefer Heart Gold because it has Ariados. Even though I first had Soul Silver.