4th Gen How did you defeat Whitney?

MILK!!!!

Miltank is evil!

One move in particular i hate with intense passion: MILK DRINK!!!!

It's eeeeeevilllll!

But luckily with the help of a Machop (ar, sorry) I managed to take it down!
 
My Porygon2 wiped the floor with Miltank. :3

Being Genderless, it was immune to Attract. Using Conversion2, Porygon2 (Break) turned into a Steel-type, thus making Rollout almost uselsss. A couple of Confusions later, Miltank was beaten.

- Kat
 
I was expecting a fight, but...

Two Magical Leafs and both of her Pokemon fainted. Chikorita was Level 25, Timid, not EV-trained, and holding a Miracle Seed.

In G/S/C, she was a demon, but she's considerably easier in HGSS... or perhaps I'm more dedicated.
 
I beat her on my first try because I love to over-level, but she was the only gym leader to actually make my starter faint D:
 
It's almost a necessity to have Flaafy for this gym, or a Geodude unless you transfer Pokemon.

I prepared my Flaafy ever since Violet City as a Mareep, but I did kinda..Leave my starter in the dust. It's level 7 I think, I beat the game and Only used it on my way to Violet City.

Ampharos is now 84 and modest.
 
Extremely high defense, a progressively self-strengthening rollout, immunity to male gender attacks, and self-healing abilities all make the match difficult, and she is by far the only difficult gym leader of any early Pokemon game.

What worked for me was using status ailments. Burning and poisoning through stalling. Sleep and paralysis to stall and use items. Also, there is a lady who sells herbal medicine in the tunnel - pick up plenty of it.
 
honestly i had no trouble what so ever from her miltanks RollOout and Stomp which killed almost all my other friends party in their games. the only thing i had trouble with where the miltanks Defenses. my moves barely scratched it ._.
 
Have a heracross at lvl 19, and a few x-attacks(I used 2) and use them on clefairy, as it can't do anything to you unless it gets a lucky metronome attack. Then when miltank comes out, you can 2 hit it.
 
I *just* beat her, out of pure luck. XD

I beat her with just a Level 23 Bayleef, I killed her Clefairy easily. Her Miltank..I hit it twice. Once, then the second time I got a critical hit and it died.

X3;
 
Clefairy was easy with my Mareep... Then Miltank took out two of my pokemon until Hearcross/Brick break= KO'd Cow haha..
 
Why am I the only one who beat her in my first try in less than 5-10 minutes? Because I had a Gastly that knew Hypnosis and Curse that really owned Miltank, then I just mass Water Gun'd it with Croconaw.
 
Lol, i taught one of my pokemon taunt and embargo and she never got a chance to use milk drink or potions...
then killing her with growlithe was a breeze
 
I used a ton of X items and managed to paralyze it with stun spore, and it fell fairly quickly.
 
Attract didn't pose an issue for me, since I had my Level 24, female Quilava handle the entire battle. It was weak against Rollout, but it had also just learned Defense Curl.
While Clefairy (who I didn't consider a threat compared to Miltank) was out, I used Defense Curl over and over to build up an armor defense in preparation for Miltank and its super-effective Rollout. When Miltank came out, I fired one Smokescreen after another at it. Thanks to Defense Curl, Rollout and Stomp did barely anything, and thanks to Smokescreen, nearly all of Miltank's attacks missed. I eventually started laying on the Flame Wheel, and ended up burning Miltank twice (the first time, its Lum Berry healed it).
I thought I had it in the bag there, but then came the Milk Drink. That just made the battle drag on and on, and I was afraid I'd have to wait until Miltank ran out of PP for that move. Luckily, though, I got a critical hit at just the right time, knocking Miltank out before it could heal itself again.

Overall, Whitney was annoying, but not too much of a problem. Morty, on the other hand…
 
She seemed really easy to me? We are talking about the second or third gym leader, right?

If so, she was easy, I had a Teddiursa and it's level must have been about 20-22, I think it gained a level during that battle so that's why I'm not completely sure. I just kept using facade, and she went down fast. Maybe because my Teddiursa was traded from Platinum, and was EV trained, and had a good nature?
 
Honestly, I just beat every trainer I had access to up to that point before facing her for the first and only time. I opened with Quilava, switching over to my female Geodude when I realized Miltank was just going to spam Stomp. It spammed Stomp with flinch hax about 6 times after I sent out Geodude before I got a chance to finish it off by spamming Magnitude.
 
Ah yes, Whitney, the eternal conundrum. She's sometimes even worse than F.E.A.R.

The best thing to do is simply be smart with your moveset and team early on in the game. When I did it in HeartGold I had a Totodile, Mareep, and a miscelany of lower level Pokemon. It turned out better than I thought though. It seems in Gen IV that Whitney goes moreso for Stomp than Rollout. Just be smart and simplistic with your move choices. When all else fails trade that one kid for a Machop.
 
She was easy for me. I just let my Quilava weaken it down (Shockingly it didn't ever use Milk Drink) Quilava fainted I switched in my Shiny Pichu and finished it off with a volt tackle.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top