My first neopet was a Shoyru-- you guys know I would pick the one closest to the dragon, it was my knock-off Charmander. I also had a unipeg, kept it in the medieval fantasy theme, unicorns and dragons. Being a little girl I of course painted it rainbow. There was a Scorchio, my poor girl's dragonite. I also had a teecko too, and loved that perky reptile. I don't remember all of the paint brush colors I used after so many years, just some.
I made another one to have more pets and pick up a few more prizes--because of the number limit at the time, which was a big no-no on Neopets. It was more feline-themed this time kacheek and had multiple kougras, one I painted silver, another lost desert and then a fairy one. Eventually my accounts were frozen for being too many, but I rebuilt a new one
I went for a cuddlier look that time, a baby kougra, a poogle, a cloud gnorbu and an Eyrie.
This was all many years ago though...